Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 841–850 ENTRIES
841
JAN 9, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
SFPUC Commission Meeting January 9, 2024: Capital Projects, Contract Performance, and Community Concerns

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on January 9, 2024, to discuss wastewater capital projects, contract delivery performance, and community contracting concerns. The Commission approved the consent calendar, received reports on contract performance and wastewater capital improvements, and addressed public comments regarding local hiring and LBE inclusion. The meeting also included a closed session where the Commission recommended approval of a $9 million settlement. Consent Calendar - Approved unanimously (5-0) the consent calendar, which included: - Contract No. CS-1412 for water and power resource studies in the Tuolumne River Watershed (not to exceed $2,000,000, 4 years). - Contract No. HH-1009 for San Joaquin Pipeline Valve and Safe Entry Improvements Phase 3 – Tesla Surge to Tower Mountain Cascade, Inc. ($11,051,305). - Contract Nos. PRO.0254 A & B for Construction Manager services to CM Pros PRO.0254.A and PMA Consultants LLC & Dabri Joint Venture, Inc. PRO.0254.B (each not to exceed $7,500,000, 8 years). - Contract No. PRO.0257 R for Underwater Tank Reservoir Inspection & Cleaning Services to Underwater Resources, Inc. (not to exceed $1,800,000, 5 years). - Accepted work and increased contract amount for WD-2811 Water Main Replacement on 17th Street. - Increased construction cost contingency for Contract No. WD-2840 (new cost limit $27,344,289). - Approved 120-day increase for Contract No. WD-2871 Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant. - Decreased contract amount for WD-2882 Trousdale Oaks Tree Removal by $199,765 (total $2,587,187). - Awarded Contract No. WD-2896 for 12-Inch Ductile Iron Water Main Installation on Webster Street. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Several community members and business owners expressed concerns about lack of local hiring and inclusion of micro-Local Business Enterprises (LBEs) in SFPUC projects. Speakers included: - A community advocate who stressed the need for a needs assessment and community consultation, referencing the Bayview community's struggles. - Atuma Belfry, a skilled electrician and San Francisco native, who highlighted challenges for local workers in getting retained on projects. - Aron A. Sterling, owner of Sterling Builders, who requested fair opportunities for micro-LBE contractors on SFPUC projects. - Dennis Williams, community leader and real estate developer, who appealed for more contracts for the Black community, noting statistics showing they receive the lowest share. - On Wastewater Capital Report: A public commenter criticized the lack of transparency and detailed reports on energy use at the biosolids facility, calling for more accountability. Discussion Items - Wastewater Enterprise Capital Improvement Report (5a): Bessie Tam presented Q1 FY2023-24 status. Key points: 120 projects, overall program at 64.8% complete for SSIP Phase 1; highlighted projects completing in 2024 (Wawona Stormwater, Ocean PSD Clarifiers, Southeast Plant Power Feed). Biosolids Digestive Facilities project at 45% construction, with a forecast budget increase due to market conditions. New Headworks facility nearing completion, also with potential cost/completion changes. - Commissioners asked about performance-based contracts, timeline extensions (e.g., Kansas and Marin project pushed to 2036), and energy generation opportunities at the biosolids facility. - Contract Performance and Delivery Methods (5b): Stephen Robinson presented data on 89 completed construction contracts (5 years). Findings: 40% completed within 10% of budget; 67% within 10% of schedule. Compared to industry benchmarks of 31% (budget) and 25% (schedule). Discussed diversification of delivery methods (design-bid-build down to 64% of active contracts; integrated delivery up to 34% by dollar amount). Emphasized need to select appropriate delivery strategies early. - Commissioners praised the analysis, requested benchmarking against similar utilities, and suggested exploring community-based public-private partnerships and performance-based contracting. - Items Initiated by Commissioners (8): Commissioner Maxwell requested a report on LBE and community benefits for the Biosolids project; Commissioner Jami requested information on the feasibility of restoring remote public comment, noting other commissions still offer it. Closed Session and Actions - Closed Session (Item 11 & 12): The Commission unanimously (5-0) voted to assert attorney-client privilege and entered closed session to discuss: - Conference with legal counsel: Proposed settlement of a personal injury claim (Mason Masuda vs. City and County of San Francisco) for $9,000,000. - Conference with labor negotiator: Issues related to unrepresented employee compensation. - Post-Closed Session: The Commission recommended approval of the settlement and voted unanimously (5-0) not to disclose further details. Key Outcomes - Approved consent calendar unanimously (5-0). - Approved minutes from December 12, 2023 (5-0). - Directed staff to compile a report on LBE participation and community benefits for the Biosolids project (for February 2024). - Directed staff to investigate the timeline and feasibility of reinstating remote public comment. - Recommended approval of the $9 million settlement to the Board of Supervisors. Note: The meeting minutes were not available; this summary is based on the agenda and raw transcript. There may be discrepancies between the agenda and the verbal proceedings (e.g., the agenda lists items 5a, 5b, 5c, but only 5a and 5b were presented in the transcript).

PROCEDURAL 41% · INFRASTRUCTURE 12% · CONTRACT MANAGEMENT 9% · WASTEWATER MANAGEMENT 7%
842
JAN 9, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - January 9, 2024

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its first regular meeting of 2024 on January 9, 2024, at 2:15 PM. The meeting included a consent calendar, committee reports, and a lengthy discussion and vote on a ceasefire resolution concerning the Israel-Gaza conflict. The board also addressed routine approvals, public comments, and several proclamations and introductions. Consent Calendar - Approved minutes from November 14, 2023, November 28, 2023, and the November 20, 2023 special meeting (11-0). - Passed ordinances and resolutions on consent, including: - Item 1: Accept and expend a $15,326,301 grant from the Board of State and Community Corrections for the Organized Retail Theft Prevention Grant Program. - Items 2-6: Planning code amendments for fleet charging, public art relocation, and landmark designations (Chata Gutierrez Mural and Carnaval Mural). - Item 7: Exempt certain PDR and arts uses from conversion limits in Eastern Neighborhoods (8 votes required, passed unanimously). - Items 8-19: Prevailing wage rates, eviction defense grant amendment ($11.4 million aggregate), and ten technology marketplace contracts (each up to $20 million, five-year terms). - Item 20: Accept $6,336,363 grant from California State Library for Main Library seismic and roof projects. - Item 22: Liquor license transfer to Willow on the Green (1327B 9th Avenue). - Item 23: Appointment of Azalina Eusope to the Sanitation and Streets Commission (term ending July 1, 2026). Special Order – Public Comment Accommodation - The board provided a special accommodation for a caller, Kevin Lamb, who identified as a disability activist. He requested that meeting minutes include details of prior public comments, including his support for Supervisor Dean Preston and homeless populations. He also stated that his ADA request to speak on the ceasefire resolution the previous day was denied, and he expressed frustration with the denial of accommodations. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Several speakers addressed the board: - Chris Workline alleged illegal wiretapping by the city and requested removal of surveillance systems. - Jordan Pronunciate Day criticized the board on multiple issues, including remote public comment, the Safeway closure, and Supervisors Mandelman, Dorsey, and Stephanie. - Mauricio Chavez (NorCal Carpenters Union) spoke in support of union labor standards, apprenticeship programs, and living wages. - Nina Smollett (Collective Impact) opposed the planned closure of the Safeway in the Fillmore/Western Addition, citing food justice concerns for seniors and the loss of a pharmacy and bank. - Matthew Beeston (NorCal Carpenters Union) emphasized the importance of labor standards on construction projects. - Daniel Landry supported Supervisor Preston’s resolution to halt the Safeway closure, noting historical racial profiling by Safeway. - Rev. Amos Brown (NAACP San Francisco) urged the board to unanimously support Supervisor Preston’s measure and called for community engagement before any closure. Discussion Items - Ceasefire Resolution (Item 26): The board debated a resolution calling for a ceasefire in Gaza, humanitarian aid, release of hostages, and condemnation of hate. - President Peskin proposed amendments to streamline the resolution into a one-page document, focusing on: a sustained ceasefire, humanitarian aid, release of all hostages, urging the Biden administration to act, condemning antisemitic, anti-Palestinian, and Islamophobic rhetoric, condemning the Netanyahu government’s attacks resulting in tens of thousands of Palestinian civilian deaths, calling for new leadership on both sides, and urging an international investigation into war crimes, including gender-based violence and killing of children. - Supervisor Preston, the original author, thanked the public and staff, and expressed hope the amendments would build consensus. - Supervisor Ronan spoke passionately about the need for bravery in calling for a ceasefire, referencing the book “Number of Stars” and the role of U.S. support for Israel. - Supervisor Mandelman stated he could not support the resolution despite appreciating efforts at consensus, and voted no, hoping for peace. - Supervisor Walton voiced support, emphasizing the need to end violence and hatred. - Supervisor Melgar supported the compromise, acknowledging deep divisions but urging attention to local issues. - Supervisor Dorsey explained his opposition, citing the failure to explicitly condemn Hamas’s October 7th attack and its gender-based violence, and expressed concern that the resolution would reward terrorism. - Supervisor Stephanie stated she could not vote for the resolution, citing the rise in antisemitic attacks, the need to condemn Hamas, and the weaponization of sexual violence. - Supervisor Safai, born in the region, supported the resolution as a way to show solidarity and reduce fear in local communities. - Amendments Vote: The amendments passed 8-3 (Supervisors Dorsey, Mandelman, and Stephanie voting no). - Final Resolution Vote: The resolution as amended passed 8-3 (same three supervisors voting no). - Committee Reports (Items 24-27): - Item 24: Ordinance reducing membership of the Behavioral Health Commission from 17 to 12 seats, passed on first reading. - Item 25: Ordinance approving a modified surveillance technology policy for city administrator’s security camera systems, passed on first reading. - Item 27: Motion appointing Nkita Kumar to the Sunshine Ordinance Task Force, approved 9-0 (Supervisors Preston and Ronan absent). Key Outcomes - Ceasefire Resolution Adopted: The board passed a resolution (8-3) calling for a sustained ceasefire, humanitarian aid, release of all hostages, condemnation of hate, and an international investigation into war crimes. - Committee Assignments Announced: President Peskin announced new committee lineups effective January 10, 2024, including: - Budget and Finance: Chair Chan, Vice Chair Mandelman, member Melgar. - Public Safety and Neighborhood Services: Chair Stephanie, Vice Chair Engardio, member Dorsey. - Government Audit and Oversight: Chair Preston, Vice Chair Stephanie, member Chan. - Land Use: Chair Melgar, Vice Chair Preston, member Peskin. - Rules: Chair Ronen, Vice Chair Walton, member Safai. - Memorials: The board adjourned in memory of Gertrude G. G. Platt, Mary Edda Moose, Falkor Short Gullickson, Lawrence Larry Carp, Dennis James Kern, and Gloria M. Lucas Davis. - Legislation Introduced: Supervisors introduced several items, including: - Supervisor Preston: Resolution demanding Safeway reconsider its planned closure of the Fillmore store (co-sponsored by Walton). - Supervisor Safai: Ordinance requiring the Lakeview Library to be built at 100 Orizaba, prohibiting city funds for other locations pending environmental review. - Supervisor Stephanie: Resolution supporting California Senate Bill 905 (auto burglary prosecution) and a letter to SFUSD on school safety after a December 8 incident. - Adoption Without Committee Reference: Item 30 (retroactive 90-day extension for Planning Commission review of cannabis retail uses) was adopted unanimously (11-0).

PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS 20% · PUBLIC SAFETY 12% · PROCEDURAL 10%
843
JAN 8, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting - January 8, 2024: Ceasefire Resolution and Other Items

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, January 8, 2024, at 6:15 PM UTC, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey. The meeting featured a crowded agenda of five items, including routine appointments and a high-profile resolution calling for a ceasefire in Gaza. The committee unanimously approved the first four items and, after extensive public comment, voted 2-1 to send the ceasefire resolution to the full Board of Supervisors without recommendation. Consent Calendar - Item 1: Appointment of Ankita Kumar to the Sunshine Ordinance Task Force (seat 4, term ending April 27, 2025) – recommended unanimously to the full board. - Item 2: Ordinance amending the Administrative Code to reduce the Behavioral Health Commission from 17 to 12 seats, with a floating requirement for a child or youth advocate – amended and sent to the full board unanimously. - Item 3: Ordinance amending the Campaign and Governmental Conduct Code to update Form 700 filing requirements for the General Services Agency under the City Administrator – sent to the full board with a positive recommendation unanimously. - Item 4: Ordinance approving a modified surveillance technology policy for the City Administrator’s Office regarding security camera systems – sent to the full board with a positive recommendation unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Public comment on Item 5 (ceasefire resolution) lasted approximately 5.5 hours, with over 100 speakers. The overwhelming majority of speakers urged the committee to pass the resolution as originally introduced by Supervisor Dean Preston, without amendments. Many speakers identified as Jewish, Palestinian, healthcare workers, educators, union members, and residents of various districts. They expressed support for an immediate and permanent ceasefire, humanitarian aid, and the release of all hostages. Some speakers opposed the resolution or supported amendments, citing the need to explicitly condemn Hamas’s October 7th attack, call for the removal of Hamas, and include a two-state solution. Several speakers criticized Chair Dorsey’s proposed amendments as one-sided, divisive, and racist. Representatives from the Jewish Community Relations Council (JCRC) and others urged a more balanced resolution. Many speakers noted that the death toll in Gaza had exceeded 22,000, including over 9,000 children, and that the entire population of 2.3 million had been displaced or faced starvation. Discussion Items - Item 5 – Resolution Calling for Ceasefire in Gaza: Supervisor Dean Preston, the author, presented the resolution and described amendments he circulated, which updated casualty figures, added condemnation of both Hamas’s October 7th attack and Israel’s attacks, and called for a lasting peace and accountability for war crimes. Chair Dorsey introduced his own amendments, which included detailed condemnation of Hamas’s sexual violence, a call for Hamas to surrender, support for a two-state solution, and updated figures. Supervisor Ahsha Safai suggested that the resolution be sent to the full board for further amendments, noting that the conversation had shifted from whether to hold a ceasefire to what the final language should be. Supervisor Shamann Walton emphasized the need to condemn all hate, return hostages, and allow humanitarian aid. After debate, the committee voted on Dorsey’s amendments: Walton and Safai voted no, Dorsey voted yes, so the amendments failed. The committee then voted 2-1 (Dorsey dissenting) to send the resolution to the full Board of Supervisors without recommendation as a committee report. Key Outcomes - Items 1-4: All passed unanimously and sent to the full board with positive recommendations. - Item 5 (Ceasefire Resolution): Chair Dorsey’s amendments were rejected by a vote of 2-1 (Walton and Safai no, Dorsey yes). The resolution was then forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors without recommendation by a vote of 2-1 (Walton and Safai yes, Dorsey no). The matter will appear on the January 23, 2024, board agenda, and no additional public comment will be accepted at the January 9th meeting.

INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS 31% · PUBLIC COMMENT 23% · HUMAN RIGHTS 19% · PUBLIC HEALTH 8%
844
JAN 8, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting - January 8, 2024

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on Monday, January 8, 2024, at 9:45 AM. Chair Myrna Melgar presided, joined by Board President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston. The committee considered four items: a conditional land exchange on Edgehill Mountain, landmark designation for Westwood Park entrance gateways, supplemental inspection requirements for tall buildings, and fire code amendments for lithium-ion batteries in mobility devices. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 2 (Westwood Park Landmark): Kathleen Badicks, a 40-year resident, spoke in strong support of the designation, noting broad neighborhood support and the desire to preserve the pillars. - Item 4 (Lithium-Ion Battery Fire Code): - Cyrus Hall, sustainable transportation advocate, supported the ordinance but urged alignment with California SB 712 (1 device per resident), a path for owners of non-compliant devices, and careful treatment of commercial maintenance/sales. - Claire Mobley, San Francisco Bicycle Coalition advocacy director, thanked President Peskin, proposed amendments reducing spacing from 3 feet to 12 inches for certified devices, removing limits on UL-certified devices in R2 occupancy, and having the Department of Environment lead the public awareness campaign. - Cash, owner of Warren Planet Bikes, raised engineering concerns: the 3-foot spacing requirement is unrealistic (bikes fit on 10-12 inch centers), and extension cord use is unrelated to battery fires if properly rated; he also requested to submit written comments. Discussion Items - Item 1 - Conditional Property Exchange (Edgehill Mountain): Chair Melgar detailed a proposal to exchange five developable lots on unstable Franciscan chert on Edgehill Mountain (prone to landslides—major slides in 1952, 1967, 1982, 1995, 1997) for city-owned paper streets near Moraga and Noriega Avenues, rezoned for higher density housing. The city worked for three years with the community group CARES and HCD (state housing department) to structure the swap. A geologist (George Berwasser) testified that excavation destabilizes the rock, and a resident (Anne Way) described safety risks on narrow Kensington Way, used as a direct route for emergency vehicles. President Peskin clarified that conditions precedent include rezoning and street vacations at the developer's cost; the exchange is likely a year or more out. No public comment was offered. - Item 2 - Landmark Designation - Westwood Park Entrance Gateways and Pillars: The ordinance designates three sets of gateway pillars built in 1916, designed by architect Louis Christian Mulgardt, as historic landmarks. The Historic Preservation Commission unanimously recommended designation. Supervisor Preston expressed concern about the history of racially restrictive covenants in Westwood Park (legally binding until removal in 1992), arguing the gateway symbolized exclusion. Chair Melgar countered that the neighborhood is now diverse (e.g., 30% Chinese) and that current residents should own their history while preserving character. The item was sent to the full board without committee recommendation. - Item 3 - Existing Building Code - Supplemental Inspections for Tall Buildings: President Peskin introduced legislation mandating visual inspections every five years for buildings over 15 stories, focusing on windows and exterior glass to prevent failures like those during the March 2023 windstorm (over a dozen failures, including at Fox Plaza). The Building Inspection Commission and a WJE report supported the approach. No public comment was received. - Item 4 - Fire Code - Lithium-Ion Batteries in Powered Mobility Devices: President Peskin and Fire Marshal Ken Coughlin detailed amendments to address fires from e-bikes, scooters, etc. Fire incidents rose from 12 (first year) to 58 (most recent year); San Francisco had one death versus over a dozen in New York. Key amendments exempt single/two-family homes from stringent storage rules if devices meet safety standards, allow up to four devices per dwelling in multifamily buildings (up from three), define battery cabinets, and require separation for repair areas. Public comment raised concerns about alignment with state law, spacing, and non-compliant devices. Supervisor Preston noted a fatal fire in his district possibly involving a scooter battery. The committee voted to amend and continue the item to January 29, 2024. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved unanimously (3-0: Melgar, Preston, Peskin) with a positive recommendation to the full Board. - Item 2: Approved (3-0) to send to the full Board without committee recommendation. - Item 3: Approved unanimously (3-0) with non-substantive amendments and a positive recommendation. - Item 4: Approved unanimously (3-0) to adopt amendments and continue the item to the January 29, 2024 committee meeting.

LAND USE 28% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 18% · PUBLIC SAFETY 14% · PROCEDURAL 10%
845
DEC 14, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Regular Meeting and Hearings, December 14, 2023

The San Francisco Planning Commission held its final hearing of the year on Thursday, December 14, 2023, beginning at approximately 12:30 PM. The meeting included consideration of continuances, consent calendar items, commission and department matters, general public comment, and a full regular calendar covering planning code amendments, large project authorizations, conditional use authorizations, and discretionary reviews. The commission took action on a range of housing, land use, and policy items. Consent Calendar - Items 1 & 2 (345 Spear St & 1060 Howard St): Continued indefinitely. Unanimous vote (7-0). - Item 4 (250-270 Masonic Ave): Commissioner Diamond recused. Approved on consent (6-0). - Item 3 (615 Sansome St): Approved on consent (7-0). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (early): A speaker raised concerns about speculative development and demolition loopholes (Section 317), urging the commission to codify residential flat policy. Another speaker requested easier access to planning department correspondence with HCD and the reinstatement of remote public comment for accessibility. - Item 11 (655 4th Street): Multiple speakers supported the project: Amy Morgan (Operating Local 3) highlighted Tishman Spire's partnership with labor; Carla Laurel (West Bay Filipino Multi-Service Center) praised community engagement; Elena Calaghi (TransBay Joint Powers Authority) expressed support for foundation coordination. - Item 12 (State Density Bonus Delegation): Several speakers opposed delegation, citing lack of transparency and reliance on passive enforcement to catch tenant displacement. Speakers included Jerry Dratler, Sandra Dratler, Bridget Maley, and Teresa Flandric. - Item 13 (Tenant Protections): Public comment criticized enforcement gaps, the rental housing inventory's limitations, and the lack of adequate right-of-return tracking. Speakers included Renee Curran, Anastasia Bonabolis, and representatives from the San Francisco Tenants Union and Housing Rights Committee. - Item 14 (724 Valencia): Nine speakers supported the cannabis retail use, highlighting Latina ownership and community benefits. - Item 16 (1153 Guerrero): The DR requester (Paul Orr) described structural hazards and inaccuracies in plans; the project sponsor (Robert McKern) argued the porch had historically existed and permits were properly inspected. - Item 17 (2475 Washington): DR requesters (Kathleen Markov and Maurizio Barone) raised concerns about loss of light, privacy, and building massing; the project sponsor (Mark Jensen) defended the design as responsive to the neighborhood. Discussion Items - Item 10 – Exceptions and Extensions for Existing Uses: Staff presented a code amendment to correct errors from two projects (Bernal Heights signage, Japantown signage) and extend temporary cannabis and inclusionary housing programs. The commission approved with a modification (7-0). - Item 11 (a,b,c) – 655 4th Street (Creamery): The project sponsor (Tishman Spire) presented a redesigned 1,105-unit residential building with ground-floor retail and a POPOS, replacing a prior 2019 approval. The project includes a Downtown Rail Extension fee waiver. During discussion, Commissioner Diamond requested e-bike parking; the sponsor committed to providing charging. A shared-light condition was added for nested bedrooms. Commissioner Imperial expressed concerns about loss of impact fees and inclusionary housing. The commission voted 6-1 to approve (Imperial opposed). - Item 12 – Resolution Delegating Authority to Planning Director for State Density Bonus Projects: After public opposition and commissioner debate, President Tanner proposed amendments requiring a weekly oral report of addresses and a dedicated webpage. Commissioner Moore opposed delegation, citing loss of oversight. The resolution passed 4-3 (Ruiz, Imperial, Moore against). - Item 13 – Tenant Protections (Informational): Staff from Planning, the Rent Board, and MOHCD presented on existing protections, the rental housing inventory, and anti-displacement programs. Commissioners discussed coordination gaps, the need for better tracking of right-of-return, and clearer tenant notifications. - Item 14 – 724 Valencia Street (Cannabis Retail): The applicant (Bianca Gutierrez) described a social-equity-focused dispensary. The commission approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 15 – 505 Brannan Street (Office Tower Addition): The project sponsor proposed an 11-story vertical addition atop an existing podium office building. Commissioner Diamond asked about e-bike facilities and residential alternatives. The commission approved unanimously (7-0); the Zoning Administrator granted variances. - Item 16 – 1153 Guerrero Street (DR & Variance): The DR requester alleged structural hazards and inaccurate plans. Commissioner Tanner proposed continuing to January 25, 2024, for a site inspection to verify plans. The motion passed unanimously (6-0). - Item 17 – 2475 Washington Street (DR & Variance): After discussion about a potential light well, the commission voted not to take DR and approved the project (6-0). The Zoning Administrator took the variance under advisement. Key Outcomes - Item 10: Approved planning code amendment (7-0). - Item 11: Approved large project authorization, conditional use, and fee waiver (6-1; Imperial opposed). - Item 12: Adopted delegation resolution with amendments (4-3; Ruiz, Imperial, Moore opposed). - Item 14: Approved conditional use (7-0). - Item 15: Approved large project authorization and office allocation (7-0). - Item 16: Continued to January 25, 2024 for site inspection. - Item 17: Approved, no DR taken (6-0). - The meeting was adjourned in honor of Gigi Platt, a preservation advocate.

HOUSING 18% · PUBLIC COMMENT 17% · LAND USE 13% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 8%
846
DEC 14, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
Special Joint Planning and Recreation & Park Commission Hearing on 545 Sansome Street - December 14, 2023

This special joint hearing between the San Francisco Planning Commission and Recreation & Park Commission considered a downtown project authorization, office allocation, shadow resolution, and shadow findings for the proposed office development at 545 Sansome Street. The project involves demolishing a one-story commercial building and renovating and expanding a historic nine-story building by six floors, creating a 127,602 gross square foot, 217-foot-tall building with ground-floor retail, a new privately owned public open space (POPOS), and bike parking. The project requires raising the absolute cumulative shadow limit (ACL) on Maritime Plaza and a recommendation on whether the net new shadow would have a significant adverse impact. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were listed; all items were considered separately. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public provided testimony, either in person or remotely. Discussion Items - Presentation by Staff and Project Sponsor: Planning Department staff Claire Feeney and Recreation & Park staff Chris Towns presented the project details, including proposed shadow impacts. The project sponsor Michael Schvah (custodian of Transamerica Pyramid) and architect Simone Martin (Foster + Partners) described the design vision, community benefits, and commitment to activating the block. - Shadow Analysis: The proposed project would add 0.0345% shadow to Maritime Plaza (existing 67.88%, total 67.91%), occurring only in late afternoons (after 4:30 PM) from mid-March to mid-May and mid-July to late September. The shadow falls on the western half, including a central lawn area. - Commissioner Discussion: Several commissioners expressed support, noting the minimal shadow impact and the project's benefits for downtown revitalization. Commissioner Moore proposed creating a "savings account" for shadow allocations to protect other open spaces. Rec & Park commissioners commented on the limited recreational use of Maritime Plaza and the project's public benefits. - Questions on Office Allocation: Commissioner Imperial asked about future office space trends. Schvah emphasized creating healthy, amenity-rich offices with natural light and outdoor access. - E-Bike Parking: Commissioner Diamond raised concerns about e-bike charging infrastructure. Staff indicated work is planned for 2024, and the project sponsor agreed to address e-bike parking during design refinement. - Streetscape and Activation: Commissioner Moore inquired about external improvements. Schvah described landscaping expansions, removal of bollards, and cultural programming to activate the area. Key Outcomes - Joint Commission Action (Item 1A): The joint commission voted unanimously (Rec & Park: 5-0; Planning: 7-0) to raise the absolute cumulative shadow limit on Maritime Plaza. - Rec & Park Commission Action (Item 1B): The Recreation & Park Commission voted unanimously (5-0) to find that the net new shadow from the project would not have a significant adverse impact on the use of Maritime Plaza. - Planning Commission Actions (Items 2A-2C): The Planning Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to: 1. Adopt shadow findings pursuant to Planning Code Section 295 that the new shadow is not adverse. 2. Approve the downtown project authorization and exception for height limits. 3. Authorize up to 49,999 gross square feet of general office use (office allocation). - The project sponsor agreed to include e-bike parking and charging as part of design refinement conditions.

PROCEDURAL 24% · LAND USE 19% · PUBLIC REALM 9% · DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION 9%
847
DEC 14, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety Committee Hearing on Liquor License Transfer - Dec 14, 2023

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on December 14, 2023, to consider a single agenda item: the proposed transfer of a Type 20 off-sale beer and wine liquor license to Source and Sinclair, LLC, doing business as Willow on the Green, located at 1327 Bine Avenue in District 7. The committee heard testimony from the applicant and SFPD, determined the license would serve public convenience or necessity, and voted unanimously to forward a positive recommendation to the full Board of Supervisors. Discussion Items - Liquor License Transfer (Item 1): Officer Salmus from the SFPD ABC Liaison unit reported zero letters of protest or support, noted the location is in a high-crime census tract (909) and high-saturation area (census strike 30202), but that Tenderloin Station had no opposition and the liaison unit recommended approval. Applicant Sinclair of Source and Sinclair LLC described the business as the only British tea shop on the West Coast, operating for 1.5 years, and that customers had requested low-ABV ales. The applicant noted that the license would allow them to sell low-alcohol beverages. Supervisor Stephanie confirmed that District 7 Supervisor Melgar supported the transfer. Key Outcomes - Motion and Vote: Chair Stephanie moved to prepare a resolution finding that the issuance of the Type 20 license would serve the public convenience or necessity and to send it to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. The motion passed 2-0 (with Vice Chair Guardio excused). The resolution is expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on January 9, 2024.

PROCEDURAL 62% · LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 38%
848
DEC 13, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting – December 13, 2023

The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on December 13, 2023, to consider a hearing on the Citywide Project Labor Agreement (PLA), several grant acceptances, contract approvals, and annual budget guidelines. The committee approved most items, continued two items, and heard public testimony on the PLA. Consent Calendar - None. All items were discussed individually. Public Comments & Testimony - On the PLA hearing, multiple speakers expressed strong support for the policy. John Doherty (Electrical Workers Local 6) noted the PLA’s effectiveness in getting people into skilled trades but highlighted challenges due to a 75% drop in downtown electrical permit activity and a four-year halt in taking on new apprentices. Alex Lantzberg (research and advocacy director) echoed concerns about downtown work decline and urged clarification that affordable housing projects with city grants should be covered. Dave Fahy (UA Local 38) praised the PLA and noted successful City Build graduations. Joshua Arce (Northern California Laborers Union) cited data showing 51% local workforce and 80% local apprentices on PLA-covered projects vs. 34% and 51% overall. Anthony Viscuso (Local 16) noted that a non-PLA project in the building had no apprentice, while PLA projects always pair journeymen with apprentices. No public comment was offered on items 2–17. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Hearing on Citywide PLA and Annual Reports): The committee reviewed the PLA’s implementation since 2019. Key reports from the Controller’s Office (Mark DeLarosa, Hunter Wang) and the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement (Pat Mulligan) detailed progress: 23 PLA-covered projects awarded (over $428 million total), 23 planned projects ($381 million), 284 letters of assent signed, 88 from LBEs, 46 statements of exemption, and 47 pre-job meetings. No strikes or work stoppages occurred. Supervisor Safai, who led the PLA negotiations, emphasized the importance of full implementation. Rudy Gonzalez (Building Trades Council) highlighted the PLA’s role in expanding local hire and apprenticeship, with 80% local apprentices on PLA projects. He encouraged extending the PLA to other departments, especially housing. Supervisor Chan raised concerns about affordable housing projects not being covered, noting a previous city position that was rescinded. The committee discussed the need for legal clarity and potential expansion. - Item 2 (Organized Retail Theft Prevention Grant – $15,326,301): The ordinance was a duplicate of a previously passed item; the committee considered amendments to clarify a waiver for equipment purchases. After a deputy city attorney noted the amendment was substantive, the committee voted to amend and continue the item to January 10, 2024. - Item 3 (Emergency Declaration – Zuckerberg SF General Hospital): The department requested a continuance. The committee continued the item to January 10, 2024, acknowledging the urgency of the repairs. - Item 4 (Library Grant – $6,336,363): The San Francisco Public Library accepted a state grant for seismic moat and roof replacement projects at the main library. The grant requires a 1:1 match from the library preservation fund, covering 45% of total project costs ($13.94 million). The committee approved the resolution. - Item 5 (Eviction Defense Collaborative Grant Amendment – $4,400,000 increase to $11,391,504): MOHCD presented the amendment to fund tenant right-to-counsel services, increasing clients served from 892 to 1,450. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) noted that performance data is collected but could be better aggregated for easier evaluation. The committee approved the resolution, with Supervisor Chan requesting improved reporting. - Item 6 (Prevailing Wage Rates): Annual resolution fixing prevailing wage rates for various city contract workers. The committee approved, with Supervisor Chan adding as a sponsor. An updated rate for motor bus drivers was included. - Items 7–16 (Technology Marketplace 3.0 Contracts – 10 contracts, each up to $20 million): The Office of Contract Administration explained the new pool of 61 suppliers for as-needed IT goods and services. The contracts have a five-year term, an 18% LBE subcontracting requirement (increased from 15%), and 37 micro-LBE set-asides. The committee approved all 10 resolutions. - Item 17 (Board of Supervisors/Clerk of the Board Annual Budget Guidelines – FY 2024-25 and FY 2025-26): Clerk Angela Calvillo presented the department’s budget highlights, including a $23.6 million current budget, 94 FTE, and ongoing projects such as a new legislative management system and IT infrastructure upgrades. The committee filed the hearing. Key Outcomes - Approved (moved to full board with positive recommendation): Items 4, 5, 6, 7–16. - Amended and continued to January 10, 2024: Item 2 (to allow substantive amendment). - Continued to January 10, 2024: Item 3 (emergency declaration). - Heard and filed: Items 1 and 17. - Votes: All actions passed unanimously (2–0, with Supervisor Safai excused for items 2–17). - Next Steps: The PLA hearing will be revisited; the committee will seek legal advice on extending PLA coverage to affordable housing projects. The next meeting is scheduled for January 10, 2024.

LABOR RELATIONS 24% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11% · PROCUREMENT 10% · PROCEDURAL 9%
849
DEC 12, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting - December 12, 2023

The Port Commission met on December 12, 2023, at 10:15 AM. The meeting included the Executive Director's year-end report, approval of consent items, updates on major development projects (Pier 70, Piers 30-32, and YMCA Building 49), and presentations on the Waterfront Resilience Program's engineering procurement and program management contract. Commissioners and members of the public provided comments and questions. Executive Director’s Report - Elaine Forbes presented the 2023 End-of-Year Report, highlighting: 115 cruise calls with 375,000 passengers; $81.5 million in grants awarded; $28 million in revenue this year (total fund balance $156 million, above pre-COVID levels); 60% of contracts awarded to local small businesses; completion of the Waterfront Land Use Plan and CEQA document; activation successes (APEC, Juneteenth, Portola Music Festival, Fisherman's Wharf SkyStar Wheel); leasing innovations using brokers Maven and Cushman & Wakefield; engineering progress on 15 projects; Mission Rock project (Visa occupancy in 2024, retail leases); Pier 70 leases (brewery, bakery, design studio); resilience milestones including draft plan release in January, federal interest in Ferry Building, and $60 million in resilience grants; equity programs (Rising Tide internship, Sail GP, youth sailing). Commissioners praised the report and staff efforts. - Commissioner Lee emphasized supporting small businesses and the off-the-boat fish sales program. - Commissioner Harrington requested details on a $2.2 million Fisherman's Wharf grant and noted the importance of the “tone at the top” regarding accountability. - Commissioner Gilman thanked maintenance crews and highlighted the success of equity programs and youth initiatives. - President Brandon congratulated staff on reaching pre-pandemic levels. Consent Calendar The Commission approved the consent calendar unanimously, including: - Resolution 2352: Accept and expend a $9,607,500 grant from the Port Infrastructure Development Program for the Amador Street Infrastructure Improvement Project. - Resolution 2353: Operating Agreement with ISOFLEX USA for Foreign Trade Zone No. 3 at 1801 Lombard Street (5-year term, one 4-year extension option). - Resolution 2354: Amendment to professional services contract with COWI/OLMM Joint Venture for Mission Bay Ferry Landing Project. Public Comments & Testimony - Katie Liddell (co-chair, Northern Advisory Committee; 30-year resident) spoke in strong support of the Piers 30-32 project, noting community engagement by Strata, redesign improvements (reduction of 137 housing units, shift to one pier with market hall), and urgency to fill the long-vacant site. She urged commission support. - Eddie Reyes (President, Iron Workers Local 377; San Francisco Building Trades Council) supported the project, emphasizing that it will privately finance $400 million in public infrastructure, create good union jobs, and train local apprentices. - Greg Hardeman (International Union of Elevator Constructors Local 8) also supported the Piers 30-32 project, highlighting the long-term revenue from ground leases and activation of the Embarcadero. Discussion Items 11A. Pier 70 28-Acre Site – Phase 1 Horizontal Improvements - Christine Maher (Port Real Estate) and Paul Chazen provided an informational update. Phase 1 includes up to 600 residential units, 460,000 sq ft office, 3.5 acres parks, and 115,000 sq ft retail/light industrial. Brookfield has completed subdivision, site prep, and horizontal improvements; rehabilitation of Building 12 is complete with nine leases signed (including five women-owned businesses). The project is in a “down market delay” until at least 2024 due to low appraisal of parcel E2. Acceptance of streets and infrastructure is scheduled for early 2024. The Port will accept non-standard improvements (special paving, custom furniture, understory plantings) while standard infrastructure goes to Public Works. A Disposition and Development Agreement (DDA) amendment will allow the developer to maintain improvements until revenue from vertical development is available. Commissioners asked about down-market trigger (five-year cap), maintenance planning (likely contracted out), material quality oversight, and mixed-use amenities (e.g., grocery store). Brookfield’s Tim Bacon confirmed grocery store is planned for Building 12, pending more housing. The item will return for formal action in January. 11B. Piers 30-32 and Seawall Lot 330 Mixed-Use Development - Wyatt Donnelly-Wandelt (Port Development) and Jesse Blout (Strata Group) presented the project status. A term sheet is under negotiation and will be brought for approval in January 2024. Key highlights: SB 273 passed in September 2023, granting state authorization; project now planned in up to three phases (seawall lot first, then pier). Phase 1-2 includes 619 housing units (92 on-site BMR, plus a separate 100% affordable building with 94 units – total 25% affordable). Phase 3 involves demolition of existing piers, reconstruction of a resilient pier (including aquatic center, deep-water berth, 375,000 sq ft office, 70,000 sq ft retail/market hall). The infrastructure cost for the pier is $460 million. A $125 million financing gap remains, to be closed through market improvement, tax increment, grants, or fee adjustments. The developer committed to a Project Labor Agreement, a BIPOC artisan retail program, and a nonprofit-managed pool to address water access disparities. Commissioners asked about affordable housing timeline, market hall viability, and deep-water berth complementarity with existing cruise terminal. Public comment strongly supported the project. The term sheet will return in January for approval. 11C. YMCA Building 49 at Crane Cove Park – Lease Amendment - Jamie Hurley (Port Real Estate) presented a proposal to amend the lease with YMCA of San Francisco. The original lease (approved earlier in 2023) required a $5-6 million capital investment including a “gold standard” seismic upgrade that became financially infeasible. The amendment reduces seismic scope (still meets code for existing buildings at lower cost), eliminates the Port’s obligation for seismic rent credits (up to $500,000), extends the rent commencement date to October 1, 2024, and requires public restrooms to open by July 1, 2024. The YMCA remains committed; building is expected to open early fall 2024. Commissioners expressed support and noted the item will return for formal approval in January 2024. 12A. Waterfront Resilience Program – RFP for Engineering Consultant Services - Steven Real (Deputy Program Manager) presented the plan to issue a single RFP to a pre-qualified pool (7 firms) for up to four contracts covering detailed design of Embarcadero early projects. The contracts: (1) Downtown Coastal Resilience ($9.5M, 7 yrs, Piers 5-22.5), (2) Southern Embarcadero Coastal Resilience ($9M, 7 yrs, Piers 24.5-32), (3) Wharf J9 Replacement Phase 2 ($6M, 6 yrs), (4) Seawall Earthquake Safety Improvements ($4M, 6 yrs, multiple locations). Evaluation is qualifications-based; each firm can win only one contract. The goal is to speed design and construction. Commission will authorize awards in April 2024. Commissioners asked about weighting of public-space design (important for contracts 1 and 2), and about managing expectations for subconsultants. Staff noted that the pre-qualified pool reduces bureaucracy and allows simultaneous project advancement. 12B. Waterfront Resilience Program – CH2M Hill Contract Status - Brad (Program Manager) presented the history of the $60 million contract with CH2M Hill Engineers (entered 2017, ending June 2024). The contract supported planning, risk assessment (multi-hazard), public engagement, Army Corps feasibility study, and early project pre-design. Achievements include 28% LBE participation, $81.5M in grants, and foundational data for the draft plan (due January 2024). The remaining funds will support Army Corps work through June 2024. A new competitive solicitation for program management services will be brought to the Commission in Q1 2024. Commissioners requested a clear narrative for the public on how funds are used and called for transparency on expenses. The contract includes oversight; a stop-work order was issued to subconsultant RDJ Services after the firm’s executive was indicted. Commissioners appreciated the progress and look forward to the new contract. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Resolutions 2352, 2353, and 2354 adopted unanimously. - Pier 70 (11A): Informational only; formal action to accept improvements and amend DDA scheduled for January 2024. - Piers 30-32 (11B): Term sheet to be brought for approval at January 23, 2024 meeting. - YMCA Building 49 (11C): Amended lease to return for approval at January 23, 2024 meeting. - WRP Engineering RFP (12A): Authorization to award contracts expected in April 2024. - WRP CH2M Hill Contract (12B): New program management contract to be presented in Q1 2024. - New Business: Commissioner Harrington requested follow-up on the $2.2 million Fisherman’s Wharf community benefits district grant. Staff will provide a detailed performance schedule for Piers 30-32 in January. - Adjournment: Meeting adjourned at 5:50 PM.

PROCEDURAL 22% · LAND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 20% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 12%
850
DEC 12, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - December 12, 2023

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission met on December 12, 2023, to discuss and act on a range of items including budget reports, capital improvement programs, a fee schedule for the Southeast Community Center, a contract award, revised electric service rules, and an extension of credit support for CleanPowerSF. The meeting also included the Citizens Advisory Committee annual report, public comments, and a closed session. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes of November 28, 2023, unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Francisco de Costa (district 10 representative) urged the Commission to provide quarterly reports on biosolids and digesters, and to ensure community benefits from the $6 billion (now heading to $12 billion) water system improvement project reach those most in need. - On item 6B (Water CIP), a speaker requested the Commission focus on lead pipes in Bayview-Hunters Point, stating children are at risk from contaminated water. - On item 7 (Southeast Community Center fees), several community members (Susan Murphy, Francisco de Costa, Oscar James, Orande Sterling, Dennis Williams, Demetrius Williams, Lisonya Mansfield) expressed concerns that fees would burden small businesses and community organizations, and called for more community involvement and resources. Susan Murphy, chair of the Southeast Community Center Commission, praised staff and the center’s success. - On item 12, no public comment. Discussion Items - Citizens Advisory Committee Annual Report (Item 5): Chair Moises Garcia reported that all 17 seats are filled, highlighted joint meetings with the Southeast Community Facility Commission and Muwekma Ohlone leadership, and outlined priorities for the coming year: capital program implementation, rates and customer assistance, and workforce retention. Commissioners thanked the committee and expressed appreciation for their engagement. - General Manager’s Report (Item 6): - 6a: Quarterly Budget Status Report – Laura Bush presented first quarter FY24 results. Water enterprise projected a $14.6 million shortfall due to removal of drought surcharge and lower wholesale volumes; wastewater positive $6.9 million; power positive $38.7 million; CleanPowerSF positive $52.9 million. All financial ratios on target. - 6b: Water Enterprise Capital Improvement Program – Katie Miller reported on 38 projects with $3.1 billion total budget, 33% expended. Key projects: lead service line replacement (184 lines replaced in quarter, estimate 1,300 total), reservoir coatings, and emergency firefighting water system. - 6c: Water System Improvement Program – Program 99% complete, $5 million expenditures in quarter. Alameda Creek Recapture Project still under evaluation; unused materials auctioned for $100,000. - 6d: No additional announcements. - Southeast Community Center Fee Schedule (Item 7): Staff presented a fee structure with three tiers (individual, business, special events), hourly rates $90-$125, deposits, discounts for District 10 residents and nonprofits. Approved after public comment. - Contract Award WD-2862 (Item 8): Awarded to Big Valley Electric for $8,869,322 for San Antonio Pump Station replacement and seismic retrofit, duration 1,125 days. - Revised Electric Service Rules (Item 9): Catherine Spaulding presented updated rules and regulations, effective February 12, 2024, incorporating stakeholder feedback and clarifying customer responsibilities. Approved unanimously. - Credit Support Extension for CleanPowerSF (Item 10): Staff requested authorization to extend the General Manager’s ability to enter into credit agreements up to $150 million for an additional 10 years, to maintain liquidity and meet CPUC requirements. Approved unanimously. - Communications (Item 11): Noted and filed. - Items Initiated by Commissioners (Item 12): Commissioner Stacy highlighted a San Francisco Chronicle article on recycled water and praised SFPUC staff. Key Outcomes - Approved minutes of November 28, 2023 (5-0). - Approved fee structure and schedule for Southeast Community Center reservable rooms (5-0). - Awarded contract WD-2862 to Big Valley Electric for $8,869,322 (4-0, Commissioner Maxwell absent). - Adopted revised Rules and Regulations Governing Electric Service (5-0). - Approved proposed ordinance amendment to extend credit support authorization for CleanPowerSF for 10 years (5-0). - In closed session, recommended approval of settlement for Lynette Chung claim ($42,115.44) and took no other action; motion to not disclose discussions passed (5-0). - Meeting adjourned after closed session.

PROCEDURAL 58% · PUBLIC COMMENT 7% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 7% · PUBLIC UTILITIES 6%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com