Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 831–840 ENTRIES
831
JAN 22, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
SFPUC Special Commission Meeting on Budget Priorities and Proposed Bureau Operating Budgets - January 22, 2024

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a special meeting on January 22, 2024, to conduct a public hearing on proposed budget priorities for FY2024-25 and FY2025-26, and to discuss the two-year operating and capital budgets, ten-year capital plan, ten-year financial plan, and proposed bureau operating budgets. The meeting was the first of four budget hearings scheduled over the following weeks, leading to budget adoption on February 13, 2024. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 3 – Budget Priorities: - Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust): Cited that FY2022-23 water deliveries were 172 million gallons per day (MGD), the second lowest on record. He noted that Slide 43 projects 202 MGD in sales by 2034, a 14 MGD increase over last year's projection of 188 MGD for the same year. He expressed concern that overprojecting water sales could undermine affordability, noting that the FY2023-24 first quarter budget report already shows water sales $25 million below projections and sewer $26 million below. - Dave Warner: Supported Commissioner Ajami's and Stacy's concerns about declining sales and increasing spending. He urged the commission to request a sensitivity analysis showing what affordability would look like under lower demand scenarios, potentially necessitating capital spending reductions. He emphasized the need for transparency about the risks. - Nicole Sankula Bosca (CEO): Stressed the importance of ensuring that staffing progress (temp-to-permanent conversions) is sufficient to execute the capital program. She also urged the commission to understand the full cost of projects beyond the 10-year capital plan horizon. - Item 4 – Bureau Operating Budgets: No members of the public provided comments. Discussion Items 1. Budget Priorities and Financial Overview (Item 3) - Presenters: General Manager Dennis Herrera, Chief Financial Officer Nancy Hom, Deputy CFO Laura Bush, and Financial Planning Director Aaron Corvinova. - Three Core Priorities: Affordability, responsible management, and investing where it matters. - Operating Budget: $1.99 billion for FY2024-25, growing to $2.1 billion in FY2025-26. Growth is 18% ($323 million) over two years. Two main cost drivers — capital costs (36% of budget) and power purchase/distribution (26%) — account for 83% of the growth. New proposals represent only $33 million (9% of growth). - Capital Budget and 10-Year Capital Plan: The proposed 10-year capital improvement plan (CIP) is $11.8 billion, the largest ever and 34% larger than the prior plan. Key drivers include the $1.5 billion Nutrients Reduction Project (wastewater), Moccasin Penstock Replacement, and water main replacements. The plan is expected to sustain over 50,000 jobs, with two-thirds in construction. It also prioritizes union labor, local hiring (37% of SSIP construction hours by San Francisco residents), and projects in historically disadvantaged communities. - Financial Plan and Rates: Combined single-family water and sewer bill is projected to rise 8.1% annually (from $142/month now to $238/month in 10 years, to $436/month in 20 years). This is within the affordability policy targets adopted in November 2023. Hetch Hetchy power rates are forecast to increase 14% in the next year but remain 30% cheaper than PG&E. CleanPowerSF rates are forecast to increase 12% next year, then flat for the following nine years. Assumes 6% interest rate on new debt. - Debt: Total existing debt is $12.1 billion ($8.5 billion outstanding). The 10-year CIP would require an additional $11.1 billion in debt issuance over 10 years. Wastewater will carry the heaviest debt burden. - Staffing: Requesting 171 new permanent positions, of which 87 are conversions of existing temporary staff to permanent. Net increase of 73 FTEs over two years, or about 2% net growth. Attrition savings increased from 11% to 15% to offset costs. - Racial Equity: For the first time, the budget process included a racial equity lens: a scoring rubric of five questions applied to all budget proposals, led by Chief DEI Officer Dr. Christian Bijou. - Commissioner Questions and Comments: - President Paulson highlighted the importance of temp-to-permanent conversions and union jobs. Commissioner Ajami raised concerns about demand forecasting (decoupling rates, sensitivity analysis for lower consumption), the wastewater debt burden, and the need for innovation in rate design and enterprise synergy. Commissioner Maxwell questioned the rigor of the capital planning process and sought clarification on salary savings. Commissioner Stacy emphasized concerns about wastewater debt and declining usage. 2. Proposed Bureau Operating Budgets (Item 4) - 4a. Business Services (Nancy Hom): Budget of $98.4 million. Largest driver is labor (IT and finance). Requesting 12 new positions (2 off-budget), 21 temp-to-permanent conversions, and 19 substitutions. IT budget includes $1.4 million in capital funding for cybersecurity and SCADA upgrades. Key new positions: senior data analysts for financial forecasting and grant support. - 4b. External Affairs (Masood Ardakani): Budget of $11.5 million. No new positions; 14 temp-to-permanent conversions and several substitutions to align positions with actual duties. Focus on retaining communications, community benefits, and policy staff. - 4c. Human Resource Services (Wendy Macy): Small budget increase. 4 net new positions (after offsetting attrition) including an HRS innovation team, two additional trainers, an apprenticeship pipeline coordinator, and a hiring analyst. Emphasized need to support agency-wide recruitment and retention, especially converting temps to permanent. - 4d. General Manager (Dennis Herrera): Budget grows from $16.9 million to $18.5 million. Requesting 4 new positions: a data analyst and management assistant for racial equity, an innovations program director (to coordinate enterprise-wide innovation, technology, and partnerships), and a records retention manager (position unfilled for three years). Also two substitutions in real estate and emergency planning. - 4e. Infrastructure (Stephen Robinson): Budget (overhead recovery) currently $100 million. Current vacancy rate 30.9%, but 63 positions are in active hiring, yielding a flexible vacancy of 11%. Requesting 8 new positions and 29 substitutions to match capital plan demands. New positions include: contract support staff (admin analysts for online bidding), a program controls data analyst, an HR business partner, and a public information officer. Capital Planning Improvement Initiative (CPPI) has standardized processes and improved deliverability. Infrastructure recovers costs through an overhead multiplier of 2.79, competitive with industry. - Commissioner Comments: Commissioners appreciated the emphasis on innovation, temp-to-permanent conversions, and the Capital Planning Improvement Initiative. Commissioner Maxwell asked about the meaning of "substitutions" and the risk of unmet goals. Commissioner Ajami urged using climate change as an overarching lens across all bureaus. Commissioner Stacy praised the focus on collaboration and learning. Key Outcomes - No formal decisions were taken on the budgets (discussion only). The commission will continue budget hearings on January 26 (Wastewater Enterprise), January 29 (Water Enterprise), and February 2 (Power Enterprise). - Motion to continue the meeting to a special meeting on Friday, January 26, 2024, at 9:00 a.m. Passed on a unanimous roll-call vote (President Paulson, Commissioner Maxwell, Commissioner Ajami, Commissioner Stacy — all ayes). - The commission's regular meeting is scheduled for January 23, 2024. - Budget adoption is anticipated at the regular meeting on February 13, 2024.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 16% · CAPITAL PLANNING 14% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 7% · INFRASTRUCTURE 7%
832
JAN 22, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
SF Land Use Committee Meeting Summary - January 22, 2024

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on January 22, 2024. The committee was chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar and included Board President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston. The agenda included items on a street encroachment permit, code corrections, state-mandated ADU regulations, housing production streamlining, fire code amendments, and a hearing on the West Side emergency firefighting water system (EFWS). Discussion Items 12th Street Plaza Encroachment Permit (Item 1) The committee considered a resolution granting a revocable permit to Otis Property Owner LLC for the 12th Street Plaza at 90 12th Street. Madison Tamp from Supervisor Dorsey's office presented, describing the plaza as part of the "30 Otis" / "Course Apartments" project, which includes over 400 residential units. The plaza is intended to fulfill an in-kind agreement obligation for infrastructure fees and will provide public space in 'the Hub' neighborhood. No public comment was offered. Planning and Administrative Code Corrections (Item 2) Aaron Starr from the Planning Department requested a continuance to draft amendments. The ordinance aims to fix typographical errors, outdated cross-references, and other non-substantive errors in the code. President Peskin raised a question about the interaction of the sign amendments with pending legislation on Articles 10 and 11 districts. No public comment was offered. State-Mandated Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) Controls (Item 3) Planning Department staff (Veronica Flores and Natalia Fassi) presented a comprehensive set of amendments to align local ADU regulations with state law (AB 221 and SB 897). This legislation is needed for the city to receive a pro-housing designation from HCD. President Peskin proposed several additional amendments, including aligning with the newest state laws, restoring tenant notification requirements that were removed in response to an HCD letter, expanding historic resource protections, and altering the hybrid ADU program to encourage the local discretionary path. Staff requested a two-week continuance to draft these amendments. In public comment, Ryan Patterson from Yes In My Backyard expressed concern that the proposed reduction in ADU square footage violates state law SB 330. Housing Production Streamlining (Item 4) The committee considered an ordinance to exempt certain housing projects from Section 311 notice and review procedures outside of Priority Equity Geographies (PEGs) and to remove conditional use requirements for large lot housing developments outside the PEG special use district. President Peskin requested a clear definition of "planning entitlements" before proceeding. Chair Melgar noted the need for more time to coordinate with Chinatown stakeholders on the application of 311 noticing. Avi from the Chinatown Community Development Center spoke in public comment, requesting more due diligence to ensure the protections are properly applied and truly protect communities. Fire Code Amendments (Item 5) Supervisor Chan, joined by Fire Marshal Ken Coughlin, presented an ordinance requiring building owners to file proof of 5-year sprinkler and annual alarm inspections with the Fire Department, mandating a cost-recovery fee, and requiring a minimum five feet of access from the public right-of-way to residential structures on newly subdivided lots. The Fire Marshal provided visuals demonstrating the difficulty of accessing rear units with current four-foot allowances allowed by state law, arguing the additional foot is critical for emergency equipment. Supervisor Chan urged the committee to move the item forward, citing the two months since introduction and the ability to amend it later. Jake Price from the Housing Action Coalition requested a continuance, stating the measure could kill numerous lot split projects. Emergency Firefighting Water System (EFWS) Hearing (Item 6) The committee held a hearing on the funding and design of the EFWS for the West Side. Katie Miller (SFPUC) detailed the significant cost increase for the system (from $15M to $42M per mile) and proposed a $145M increase in water bond funding to make the project shovel-ready. Brian Strong (ORCP) discussed financing strategies and strongly advocated for mandating automatic gas shut-off valves as a rapid and cost-effective fire prevention measure. Deputy Chief Darius Luttropp (SFFD) highlighted investments in hose tenders and a planned demonstration to improve immediate firefighting capabilities on the West Side. Supervisor Chan and Chair Melgar stressed the need for robust infrastructure coordination to match the city's aggressive housing production targets. During public comment, Eileen Bogan raised concerns about the legal basis for using ESER funds for a potable-water EFWS, the lack of a fully executed MOU for the system transfer, and alternative funding strategies. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (12th Street Plaza): Passed and sent to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 2 (Code Corrections): Continued to the January 29, 2024 meeting (3-0) to allow for drafting of amendments. - Item 3 (ADU Controls): Continued to the February 5, 2024 meeting (3-0) to allow for drafting of extensive amendments. - Item 4 (Housing Production): Continued to the call of the chair (3-0) to allow for further stakeholder negotiation and definition drafting. - Item 5 (Fire Code): Passed and sent to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 6 (EFWS Hearing): Continued to the call of the chair (2-0, with President Peskin noted as absent).

FIRE SAFETY 30% · LAND USE 24% · PUBLIC SAFETY 15% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 9%
833
JAN 18, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - January 18, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular meeting on Thursday, January 18, 2024, beginning at approximately 12:15 PM. The meeting was streamed live but not televised live due to a prior event running long. The commission took up a range of items including consent calendar continuances, election of officers, and several regular calendar items involving planning code amendments, conditional use authorizations, and a discretionary review. All votes were unanimous (7-0) unless noted. Consent Calendar - Items 1-4 (1846 Grove Street, 1701 Fillmore Street, 2450 San Bruno Avenue, 1526 Powell Street) were continued to February 29, 2024, on a motion by Commissioner Braun, seconded and passed 7-0. - Item 16 (2955 Sacramento Street) was withdrawn. Election of Officers - Commissioner Coppel nominated Commissioner Sue Diamond for President and Commissioner Moore for Vice President. The motion passed 7-0. Commissioner Diamond assumed the presidency, and Commissioner Moore continued as Vice President. Former President Tanner expressed gratitude and acknowledged the commission's collegiality. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: A speaker urged the commission to actively plan the city, noting the lack of a land use element in the General Plan and the importance of proactive planning despite implementation challenges. - Item 10 (Density Controls): Corey Smith (Housing Action Coalition) and Jana Tolley (SF YIMBY) supported the staff recommendation to maintain form-based density in historic districts while protecting historic resources. Jeremy Paul emphasized the importance of the state historic building code for adaptive reuse. - Item 11 (Unauthorized Unit Removal): No public speakers. Staff noted public comments from Georgia Shurdish and Anastasia Yovanopoulos suggesting additional safeguards; these were considered but not adopted. - Item 12 (Potrero Power Station): No public comments. - Item 13 (2515 Folsom Street): Speakers included RBA (support), Deborah Hawley (representing adjacent neighbors objecting to roof deck, penthouse, and parapet), and Tim Doherty (resident supporting minor modifications). The project sponsor's attorney responded to concerns. - Item 14 (767 Bush Street): No public comments. - Item 15 (3751 21st Street): DR requester Deborah Nelson opposed the flat roof on a rear extension citing privacy and potential future deck. Project sponsor Lucas Eastwood offered to eliminate the deck and raise window sills. The Dolores Heights Improvement Club argued the rear extension was illegal and required a sloped roof. Discussion Items - Item 10: Density Controls in Community Business Districts [BF 231079] – The commission considered a Planning Code amendment sponsored by Supervisor Peskin to reinstate numeric density limits in C2 districts east of Columbus and north of Washington. Staff recommended limiting the reinstatement to historic districts (Northeast Waterfront and Jackson Square) and allowing adaptive reuse projects to use form-based density. After discussion, the commission voted 7-0 to approve the ordinance with staff modifications, forwarding comments to the Board of Supervisors. - Item 11: Conditional Use Authorization for Removal of Unauthorized Unit [BF 231185] – Sponsored by Supervisor Melgar, the ordinance would allow removal of a UDU without a CUA if not rented in 10 years and owner resides in primary unit for 3 years, plus rent control. Staff recommended two modifications: limiting the open space/exemption to projects requiring a variance, and requiring the unit to meet minimum floor-to-ceiling height if possible. The commission voted 7-0 to approve with staff modifications, acknowledging the need for further discussion between the sponsor and planning. - Item 12: Potrero Power Station Mixed-Use Project – EIFD Amendment – The commission considered a resolution recommending approval of an amendment to the Development Agreement to create an Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District (EIFD) to fund infrastructure, affordable housing, and parks. Staff and project sponsor reported progress including a workforce housing building groundbreaking. The commission voted 7-0 to adopt the resolution. - Item 13: 2515 Folsom Street – Conditional Use Authorization – Request to demolish a single-family home and construct a four-unit building (three 3-bedroom, one 2-bedroom) with parking. The project was fully code compliant and had 27 support letters. Opponents sought modifications to reduce shadow impacts. After discussion, Commission President Diamond encouraged continued neighborly gestures, and the commission voted 7-0 to approve with conditions and suggested the sponsor work with staff and neighbors on additional modifications. - Item 14: 767 Bush Street – Conditional Use Authorization – Request to remove a vacant laundromat (closed 2016) and establish a restaurant. Staff found the project met all four findings (comparable services, closure rate, essential needs, poverty rate). The commission voted 7-0 to approve. - Item 15: 3751 21st Street – Discretionary Review – A DR request by neighbors opposed a flat roof on a rear extension, fearing a future deck. The project sponsor eliminated a previously approved deck and offered other mitigations. Staff found no exceptional or extraordinary circumstances. The commission voted 7-0 to not take DR and approve the permit as proposed, noting the roof would be an unoccupied green roof. Key Outcomes - Items 1-4 continued to February 29, 2024 (7-0). - Election of Officers: President Diamond and Vice President Moore elected (7-0). - Item 10: Approved with staff modifications (7-0). - Item 11: Approved with staff modifications (7-0). - Item 12: Approved resolution recommending EIFD amendment (7-0). - Item 13: Approved with conditions (7-0), with request for further neighbor discussions. - Item 14: Approved (7-0). - Item 15: DR denied, permit approved (7-0). - Remote public comment: Scheduled for discussion at a future hearing (agenda item added for two weeks later). Note: The meeting was not televised live due to a prior event running long, but was streamed. All votes were unanimous. The meeting adjourned after item 15.

ZONING AND LAND USE 24% · LAND USE 11% · PROCEDURAL 9% · UNLAWFUL DWELLING UNIT 9%
834
JAN 18, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Reviews Civic Bridge Waiver and Water Main Break Settlements on January 18, 2024

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on January 18, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Vice Chair Catherine Stephanie and President Aaron Peskin present. Supervisor Chan was excused. The committee considered a resolution authorizing a behested payments waiver for the Civic Bridge program, an ordinance to expedite settlements from a September 10, 2023 SFPUC water main break, and nine settlement items in closed session. Public Comments & Testimony - One member of the public, who identified as homeless, spoke on each open-session item. On the Civic Bridge item, he expressed full support for the program and suggested the committee also include civil rights and pro bono providers to ensure rights are protected. On the water main break item, he praised the expedited settlement process and asked how homeless individuals could receive compensation. Before closed session, he expressed hope for better days for the city. Discussion Items Item 1: Civic Bridge Program Behested Payments Waiver Sophia Kittler and Matt Larson from the Mayor's Office of Innovation presented a resolution to waive the behested payments ordinance for six months, allowing the city to solicit in-kind donations from for-profit companies for the Civic Bridge program. The program, in its 10th cohort since 2015, pairs city departments with pro bono consultants on short-term strategic projects. This cohort focuses on homelessness, street outreach, and housing. The waiver would permit outreach to a list of companies that have expressed interest or worked with the city previously, with a valuation of $195 per hour per person based on the Taproot Foundation standard. Once matched, the city would return to the Board for an accept and expend resolution. The cohort is expected to last 16 weeks, starting in March 2024. Chair Preston asked about conflict-of-interest protections; Kittler explained that the Mayor's Office handles all outreach and checks for impropriety. She also noted that formal reporting on outcomes had not been requested previously but offered to present if desired. Item 10: SFPUC Settlement Authority for Water Main Break Vice Chair Stephanie, the sponsor, introduced an ordinance authorizing the SFPUC and City Attorney to approve settlements from the September 10, 2023 water main break at Fillmore and Green Streets. Jeremy Spitz from the SFPUC detailed that a 16-inch high-pressure pipe burst, flooding streets and damaging approximately 43 residential and commercial properties. The ordinance would allow settlements over $25,000 up to $1 million per claim, with an aggregate not to exceed $7 million, and delegate authority for related litigation. It requires biannual reports to the committee. The purpose is to enable prompt payment to affected property owners, bypassing the usual process that requires separate Board approval for each claim. The committee expressed support. Closed Session The committee convened in closed session to consider items 2–9, which included ordinances and resolutions to settle various lawsuits and unlitigated claims, ranging from approximately $40,000 to $7 million. Among these was a settlement related to the same September 2023 water main break. After the closed session, the clerk reported that all items were recommended without objection. The committee voted unanimously (2–0) not to disclose the discussions. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Civic Bridge Waiver): Moved to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation (2–0, Chan excused). - Item 10 (SFPUC Settlement Authority): Initially moved with positive recommendation, then the vote was rescinded to correct the action type. The item was re-voted to forward to the full Board as a committee report (2–0, Chan excused). - Items 2–9 (Closed Session Settlements): Recommended without objection; closed session discussions not disclosed. - The meeting adjourned after completing all business.

PROCEDURAL 44% · PUBLIC COMMENT 29% · TECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATION 12% · HOMELESSNESS 8%
835
JAN 17, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - January 17, 2024

The Budget and Finance Committee convened on Wednesday, January 17, 2024, at 6:15 PM, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Myrna Melgar. The committee considered seven items, including retroactive grants, a contract waiver, a two-year budget resolution, and a hearing on the city's financial outlook. Key actions included forwarding most items to the full Board, amending and continuing one item, and hearing public testimony on the city's deficit. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (Resolution 231238): Retroactively authorized the Department of Juvenile Probation to accept a $360,570 grant from the California Department of Social Services for intensive foster care and family preservation services (Oct 1, 2021 – Sep 30, 2026). Passed unanimously and forwarded to the full Board. - Item 3 (Ordinance 231054): Approved contracts with the American Registry for Internet Numbers (ARIN) for internet protocol address registration, waiving certain administrative code requirements (annual cost $10,500). Passed unanimously and forwarded. - Items 4 & 5 (Resolution 231277 and Ordinance 231222): - Item 4: Retroactively accepted a $1,200,000 grant from the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation for the Safety and Justice Challenge to reduce jail incarceration and racial disparities (Jan 1, 2023 – Dec 31, 2025). - Item 5: Retroactively accepted a $2,050,000 grant from the California Board of State and Community Corrections for organized retail theft vertical prosecution, adding two grant-funded positions (Oct 1, 2023 – Jun 1, 2027). Both passed unanimously and forwarded. - Item 6 (Resolution 231196): Adopted a fixed two-year budget for the Airport, Port, and Public Utilities Commission for FY2024-2025 and FY2025-2026. Passed unanimously and forwarded. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 7 (Five-Year Financial Plan Hearing): Multiple speakers urged the committee to avoid cuts to essential services for vulnerable populations: - Marnie Regan (Larkin Street Youth Services) opposed cuts to food security for homeless youth, stating the $200,000 cut is meager compared to the deficit and would harm tenants. - Janice Canal (Safe and Sound) requested sustained investments in family support services to prevent homelessness and mental health crises. - Hope Kmer (Compass Family Services) reported a family sleeping in a car and warned that cuts to HSH, ERAP, and tenant right to counsel would increase child homelessness. - Adam Noor Varoco (SF LGBT Center) implored funding for homeless youth services, emphasizing that cuts lead to increased homelessness and reduced care standards. - Chanel Brown (Black Early Educators Policy Council) urged maintaining childcare investments, noting the DreamKeeper Initiative created childcare slots and pipeline programs. - Maria Lostari (Parent Voices SF) opposed mid-year cuts, stating they harm at-risk children and families. Discussion Items - Item 2 (Ordinance 231237): Retroactively authorized the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner to accept a $1,086,740.83 grant from the California Department of Public Health for the Overdose Prevention Initiative (Dec 1, 2023 – Jun 30, 2028). The grant funds reanalysis of accidental overdose cases for novel drugs. The committee heard testimony from Chief Forensic Toxicologist Dr. Luke Rhoda, who detailed the 400% increase in accidental overdoses and the need to develop automated testing methods. The Office of City Administrator proposed technical amendments to correctly categorize grant-funded positions as "grant-funded" instead of "temporary" and to align language. The committee adopted the amendments and then continued the item to the January 24, 2024 meeting for one week, as the amendments were substantive. - Item 7 (Hearing 231284): The committee held a hearing on the Five-Year Financial Plan Update (FY2024-2025 to FY2027-2028) and Mayor’s Budget Instructions. Director Anna Dooning (Mayor’s Budget Office) and Carol Liu (Controller’s Office) presented a grim outlook: a $245 million deficit in FY2024-2025, $550 million in FY2025-2026, growing to $1.3 billion by FY2027-2028. Revenue growth is flat (2-3%), while expenditures grow over 18%, driven by salary and benefits ($500M increase), healthcare costs (9% growth vs. historical 4-5%), and CBO contract inflation. Major taxes (property transfer, business, hotel, sales) are stagnant due to high office vacancies (30.4% in Q3 2023, rising to 32.1% in Q4) and stalled hospitality recovery. One-time sources (ARPA, FEMA) are depleting. The Mayor’s instructions ask departments to propose 10% reductions each year and contingency plans for additional 5% cuts. Supervisors Chan and Melgar questioned the effectiveness of prior economic strategies (e.g., downtown tax exemptions) and emphasized the need for structural reforms, consolidation of city services, and a comprehensive review of contracting and staffing. The chair noted ongoing work by the Budget and Legislative Analyst to evaluate efficiency and contract performance. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Passed unanimously (3-0) and forwarded to the full Board. - Item 2: Amended unanimously (3-0) to correct position classifications; then continued to January 24, 2024 (3-0). - Item 3: Passed unanimously (3-0) and forwarded. - Items 4 & 5: Passed unanimously (3-0) and forwarded. Supervisor Mandelman added as co-sponsor to Item 4; Supervisor Melgar added as co-sponsor to Item 5. - Item 6: Passed unanimously (3-0) and forwarded. - Item 7: Hearing heard and filed unanimously (3-0).

BUDGET AND FINANCE 30% · JUSTICE AND CORRECTIONS 18% · PUBLIC SAFETY 11% · PROCEDURAL 9%
836
JAN 17, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting – January 17, 2024

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, January 17, 2024, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included a weekly officer recognition, reports from the Chief of Police and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), a presentation on the SFPD budget priorities, and a presentation on the DPA annual report. The commission also voted to hold a closed session and subsequently voted not to disclose any discussion from that session. Officer Recognition - Sergeant Patrice Heath of the Forensic Services Division (CSI) received a weekly officer recognition certificate. She was praised for her dedication, training of new recruits, and work on standard operating procedures. Her unit has conducted over 1,000 crime scene responses in 2023. General Public Comment - A speaker criticized the current commission, stating it lacks experience in the criminal justice system and has become an obstacle to SFPD, calling for a return to partnership and reform rather than punishment. - A speaker thanked the commission for reforms and suggested creating a court for police abuse incidents and repealing qualified immunity. - A mother of an unsolved homicide victim (Arbor Abercassa, murdered August 14, 2006) urged the commission to find ways to pay tipsters and solve her son's case. - A speaker thanked SFPD officers and implored the commission to give them the tools needed to continue the downward crime trend. Chief's Report - Chief Scott reported an overall 40% reduction in crime compared to the same period last year, with approximately 800 fewer crimes reported. - Homicides are even with last year (two year-to-date). One homicide occurred on the 100 block of Barrie; suspects not yet in custody. - Drug market enforcement resulted in 78 arrests and 5,335 grams of narcotics seized (mostly fentanyl) in the past week. Since the inception of DMAC, 127,091 grams of narcotics have been seized. - Significant arrests included a homicide suspect from a December 28, 2023 stabbing, and a carjacking suspect tracked via GPS to Vallejo. - A stunt driving event with about 200 motorcycle riders occurred on January 14; no arrests yet. - Commissioner Yee asked about a series of commercial burglaries in the Richmond district; Chief Scott confirmed they are believed to be connected, with five incidents, only one successful burglary. - Commissioner Yee also asked about an attack on an SFMTA worker in December; Chief Scott said an arrest was made but would provide further details. - President Elias asked about policing on 16th and 24th Street corridors; Chief Scott acknowledged the vending ban has helped but noted that enforcement gaps on holidays (e.g., Martin Luther King Jr. Day) led to a return of vendors. He emphasized the need for consistent deployment. - Staffing update: an academy class of 22 expected to graduate next month, and four lateral officers were recently hired. DPA Director's Report - Executive Director Paul Henderson reported that 20 cases have been opened so far in 2024, 16 cases closed, and 317 cases remain open. Three cases have been sustained. - 26 cases exceed the nine-month investigation period, with 19 of those due to officer availability (tolled). - Eight cases are pending with the commission, 87 with the chief. - The highest allegation category this week is conduct unbecoming of an officer. - DPA is expanding outreach and social media presence. - Vice President Carter Oberstone asked about the status of stop data requested for an audit. Chief Scott stated that data will be provided on a rolling basis starting in about a week and a half (end of January). Director McGuire confirmed that no data has been turned over yet, citing the need to redact juvenile data and other scheduling issues. Commissioner Walker expressed concern about a leak of confidential information and asked for a report on the investigation; Director Henderson said DPA was not involved in the leak. Commission Reports - President Elias asked commissioners to prioritize discipline cases to prevent a backlog. Eight cases are pending with the commission, 87 with the chief. - Commissioner Yaniez announced she will be away from January 25 to February 12. She reported on language access DGO and noted that required annual and bi-annual reports have not been presented to the commission. She also requested a discussion on RIPA best practices for 2022 and 2023. - Vice President Carter Oberstone addressed a previous public comment from a mother of an unsolved homicide victim, stating that the commission had planned to hire a policy analyst to research tip incentives, but the position was frozen by the mayor. He requested a joint SFPD/DPA presentation on best practices for incentivizing tips. - Commissioner Walker reported ongoing work on the patrol specials issue and a planned tour of Code Tenderloin infrastructure. Presentation on SFPD Budget Priorities - Executive Director Catherine McGuire presented the budget priorities. Key points: - The city faces a $800 million deficit over two years, leading to a 10% reduction in adjusted general fund support for each of the next two fiscal years, plus a 5% contingency. - No new FTEs are allowed; departments must prioritize core operations and eliminate non-essential services. - The SFPD budget is largely personnel-driven; overtime costs are high due to vacancies. In FY23, overtime was $37 million, and in FY24 year-to-date it is $45.8 million, including 68,000 hours for APEC. - The department has a

PROCEDURAL 52% · PUBLIC SAFETY 14% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 12% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 10%
837
JAN 11, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - January 11, 2024: Potrero Yard, Fleet Charging, Islais Creek Bridge

Date: January 11, 2024 Time: 20:15 UTC (12:15 PM Pacific) Location: City Hall, San Francisco, CA The Planning Commission held a regular meeting covering a consent calendar, a planning code amendment for fleet charging, the Potrero Yard Modernization Project (including certification of the final EIR and project entitlements), and review of the draft EIR for the Islais Creek Bridge Project. The meeting also included commission matters, department reports, and general public comment. Consent Calendar - Items B1–B4 (Seawall Lots 323 & 324, 555 Pacific Avenue, 399 Fremont Street, 310-320 Dolores Street): The commission approved all four consent calendar items unanimously (7-0), waiving separate discussion and adopting the staff recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: - A speaker (name not stated) addressed planning code Section 317, urging the commission to tighten demolition calculations, preserve flats and upper dwelling units (UDUs), and scrutinize speculative projects, especially in priority equity geographies. - Tom Radilovich (Livable City) encouraged the commission to be more proactive in planning, revive public realm planning (noting 25% of city land is public right-of-way), and initiate legislation rather than only reacting to state or mayoral directives. - A remote speaker (anonymous) requested the commission reinstate remote public comment, citing the flu season and accessibility barriers; they noted other commission bodies still allow remote participation. - Regular Calendar Item 10 (Fleet Charging): - Mark Lisa Terram (Teamsters Joint Council 7) and Peter Ziblat (land use counsel) spoke in support of the ordinance, emphasizing that the current loophole (Footnote 24) allows as‑of‑right conversion in PDR zones without scrutiny and that conditional use authorization ensures proper review. - Regular Calendar Items 11–12 (Potrero Yard Modernization Project): - Anna Herrera (Legislative Aide to Supervisor Hillary Ronen) expressed enthusiastic support, highlighting 100% affordable housing, improved transit facilities, and broad community backing (e.g., from Puente Latino Cultural District, Sierra Club, SF Transit Riders). - Additional public comment came from a representative (name not given) supporting the project for its climate and equity benefits. - Regular Calendar Item 13 (Islais Creek Bridge Project Draft EIR): - A speaker from the San Francisco Transit Riders voiced concern about the 24‑month closure of the T‑Third light rail line, warning it could erode transit ridership in the Bayview neighborhood and exacerbate historical inequities; they urged shorter timelines and better alternative transit options. Discussion Items - Item 10 – Fleet Charging Planning Code Amendment (Board File 231080): - Sponsored by Board President Peskin, the ordinance would require a conditional use authorization (CU) for converting private parking or vehicle storage lots to fleet charging in all Production, Distribution, and Repair (PDR) districts, closing a loophole (Footnote 24) that allowed as‑of‑right conversion. - Sunny Angulo (Peskin’s office) proposed two potential future amendments: a grandfathering date for applications submitted before today’s meeting, and a clarification to ensure Section 311 public notice is required for all building permits involving fleet charging in every zoning district. - Staff (Joseph Sackey) noted no formal recommendation because the amendments were presented only the day before, but saw the ordinance as closing a procedural loophole and creating uniform scrutiny. - Commissioners discussed the value of consistency and supported the amendments, with Commissioner Coppel making a motion to approve staff’s recommendations while leaving the door open for the later amendments. - The motion passed unanimously (7‑0). - Items 11 & 12 A–E – Potrero Yard Modernization Project (2500 Mariposa Street): - Staff presented the final Environmental Impact Report (EIR) and six entitlement items: certification of the final EIR, CEQA findings, general plan amendments, planning code text and zoning map amendments (creating the Potrero Yard Special Use District), shadow findings (Planning Code §295), and a conditional use authorization for a planned unit development. - Project Description: Demolish the existing 100-year-old bus yard and construct a new state-of-the-art transit facility (phase 1), plus up to 465 100% affordable housing units (phase 2‑3) with a backup paratransit variant (104 units). The project includes 2,886 sq ft of commercial space, a public restroom, and street improvements. - The final EIR finds significant unavoidable impacts on historic resources (demolition of an eligible historic building) and toxic air contaminants (construction and operations). Staff clarified the cancer risk was 6.87 per million vs. a threshold of 7, and PM2.5 was well below significance. - Commissioners expressed strong support, praising the housing component, worker conditions, community engagement (over 140 meetings), and the backup option. Concerns about toxic air contaminants and shadow were addressed; the Park and Recreation Commission had already recommended the shadow would not be adverse. - A motion to certify the EIR passed unanimously (7‑0). A second motion to adopt all remaining items (CEQA findings with statement of overriding considerations, general plan amendments, code amendments, shadow findings, and conditional use) also passed unanimously (7‑0). - Item 13 – Islais Creek Bridge Project Draft EIR (Third Street over Islais Creek, Bayview/Hunters Point): - The project involves demolition and replacement of the structurally deficient bridge (NBI rating 20 out of 100) with a new bridge that meets seismic and sea‑level rise standards (up to 2100). The new bridge will be about 5.2 feet higher with a 26‑foot dedicated light rail trackway, two travel lanes per direction, and a pedestrian/bicycle path. - Construction is estimated at 24 months with no traffic or transit through the area; a temporary bus bridge and detours are planned. The draft EIR analysis shows significant unavoidable impacts to historic resources (bridge is eligible for National Register) and construction‑related transit delays. - Public comment raised concerns about interrupting the T‑Third light rail service for two years and urged minimizing disruption. Commissioners echoed those concerns, asking about timeline shortening, alternative alignments, and the decision to install tracks recently only to remove them. - No approval was requested; the commission took the item for review and comment. The comment period closes January 22, 2024. - Item 14 – Discretionary Review: 426 Fillmore Street, Unit C: - Continued by unanimous vote to March 14, 2024 (7‑0) at the request of the applicant. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar (B1–B4): Approved unanimously (7‑0). - Minutes (December 14, 2023): Adopted unanimously (6‑0; Commissioner Coppel absent). - Item 10 – Fleet Charging Ordinance: Approved with staff recommendations (unanimous 7‑0). The commission indicated openness to later amendments on grandfathering and noticing. - Items 11 & 12 – Potrero Yard Modernization Project: - Final EIR certified unanimously (7‑0). - All project entitlements (CEQA findings, general plan amendment, planning code and zoning map amendments, shadow findings, conditional use) adopted unanimously (7‑0). The project will proceed with a preferred aim of 465 affordable units; if housing financing is not secured, the paratransit variant (104 units) will be triggered after a reasonable time frame (5–10 years, with possible extensions). - Item 13 – Islais Creek Bridge Project: No vote; taken for public comment. The commission will consider certification of the final EIR in spring/summer 2024 after the comment period closes. - Remote Public Comment: Commissioner Moore raised the idea of reinstating remote public comment due to the flu season; the commission agreed to discuss at the next officers’ meeting. The issue was not voted on. Adjourned: The meeting concluded without a formal adjournment time noted.

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW 25% · TRANSPORTATION 20% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 9%
838
JAN 11, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting - January 11, 2024

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on January 11, 2024, at 6:15 PM. Vice Chair Joel Engardio presided, joined by Supervisor Dorsey. Chair Stephanie was excused. The committee considered five items: two liquor license applications, a health code amendment, a resolution supporting the SoMa Pilipinas Gateway cultural marker, and a hearing on working conditions for women in the SFPD. Item 1: Liquor License Transfer - RM212 (690 Sacramento Street) - Presentation: Officer Stephen Jonas from SFPD ABC Liaison unit reported that the application for a Type 48 on-sale general public premises license from Chan Enterprises (doing business as RM212) had no letters of protest or support. The location is in a high crime area (plot 150) and high saturation census tract (611.01). Recommended conditions include noise control and loitering prevention. - Applicant Statement: Ricky Chan, representing the AAPI-owned business, described the restaurant's struggle since COVID-19 and the hope that a Type 48 license would revitalize the business. - Public Comment: David Villalobos expressed support, noting the application aligns with the city's downtown recovery plan and the applicants are hardworking. - Key Outcome: The committee voted unanimously (2-0) to prepare a resolution finding that the license transfer would serve the public convenience or necessity and send it to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Item 2: Liquor License Issuance - The Record Bar (177 Eddy Street) - Presentation: Officer Jonas reported on the Type 90 on-sale general music venue license application by SR Visions LLC. No letters of protest or support were received. The location is in a high crime area (plot 176) and high saturation census tract (125.03). Recommended conditions mirror those of Item 1. - Representative Statement: Mark Rennie, representing the applicant, explained that the venue is losing money and plans to sell its current Type 47 license (with a price spread of approximately $165,000–$185,000) to fund renovations. He described the venue's popularity and expressed optimism about San Francisco's nightlife recovery. - Supervisor Dorsey expressed support for nightlife and the cultural value of the venue. - Public Comment: None. - Key Outcome: The committee voted unanimously (2-0) to prepare a resolution finding that the license issuance would serve the public convenience or necessity and send it to the full board with a positive recommendation. Item 3: Health Code Amendment - Regulating Medical Specimen Test Collection Sites - Presentation: Melissa Hernandez, legislative aide to Supervisor Preston (sponsor), presented an amended ordinance that builds on a previously passed version. The new amendments prohibit paying individuals to take medical tests and make violations a misdemeanor, expanding enforcement tools. - Supervisor Dorsey thanked Supervisor Preston and co-sponsor Supervisor Ronen, noting the importance of regulating pop-up COVID testing sites to protect vulnerable residents. - Public Comment: None. - Key Outcome: The committee voted unanimously (2-0) to recommend the amended ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors. Item 4: Support for SoMa Pilipinas Gateway Cultural Marker - Presentation: Supervisor Dorsey (sponsor) introduced the resolution, noting it now has unanimous co-sponsorship from all 11 supervisors. He read a series of amendments into the record. - Community Presentation: Raquel Redondias, director of SoMa Pilipinas, presented the gateway design by artist Francesca Gamez. The design features an arch with shadow play and bronze narrative elements, located at Folsom and Russ Streets. Hundreds of community members provided input over two years. - City Agency Support: Planning Director Rich Hillis and Arts Commission Director of Cultural Affairs Ralph Remington expressed strong support and committed to partnering on funding and implementation. - Public Comment: Patricia Zamora (Community Arts Stabilization Trust) spoke in support, praising the community-driven process. - Key Outcome: The committee first adopted the amendments unanimously (2-0), then voted to recommend the amended resolution to the full board (2-0). Item 5: Hearing - Working Conditions for Women in the SFPD - Sponsor Supervisor Melgar requested to continue the hearing to a later date. - Public Comment: None. - Key Outcome: The committee unanimously (2-0) continued the hearing to the call of the Chair.

PUBLIC ART 29% · LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 21% · PUBLIC COMMENT 20% · PROCEDURAL 13%
839
JAN 10, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - January 10, 2024

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on January 10, 2024, at 6:15 PM (UTC) to consider ten agenda items, including retroactive grant acceptances, appropriations, emergency declarations, and lease extensions. The committee heard presentations from city departments and received no public testimony on any item. All items except one were forwarded to the full board with positive recommendations; item six was forwarded without recommendation. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was designated; each item was considered individually. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public spoke on any agenda item. Written comments were accepted via email or postal mail. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Ordinance - Organized Retail Theft Prevention Grant Waiver): The Police Department requested a waiver of competitive procurement requirements to expedite the purchase of 400 Flock cameras using state grant funds. The cameras will be distributed approximately 10 per supervisory district, covering major corridors citywide. Stonestown and 19th Avenue were cited as key areas. The item passed unanimously. - Item 2 (Resolution - Accept $375,000 from Mellon Foundation): The Public Library retroactively accepted a grant to continue the Jail and Re-entry Services Program. The grant runs from October 1, 2023, to December 31, 2024. The delay was due to administrative processing. The item passed unanimously. - Item 3 (Resolution - Accept $1,000,000 from DOJ Stop School Violence Program): The Department of Children, Youth, and Their Families presented a retroactive grant to enhance school crisis coordination, including hiring staff, developing a social media campaign, and procuring a database. Between March 2022 and September 2023, 143 conflict mediations and 30 CBO referrals occurred. Supervisors expressed interest in prevention and communication infrastructure. The item passed unanimously. - Item 4 (Resolution - Accept $305,850.45 from Blue Shield): The Department on the Status of Women retroactively accepted an increased grant for the Healing Roots Collaborative, funding a podcast and partner compensation. The grant period is April 1, 2023, to March 31, 2024. The item passed unanimously. - Item 5 (Ordinance - Appropriation of $1,540,000 from Treasure Island Bonds): The Treasure Island Development Authority appropriated bond proceeds for pre-development of a 150-unit affordable housing project (Parcel IC 4.3). The Budget and Legislative Analyst recommended reducing the amount to $1,350,239 based on actual sale proceeds, which was accepted. The item passed unanimously as amended. - Item 6 (Resolution - Emergency Declaration for ZSFG Chiller/Boiler/Cooling Tower): Department of Public Health and Public Works requested approval for an emergency replacement project at Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital after catastrophic cooling tower failure on September 6, 2023, which ejected 72-75 pound fan blades. The project is estimated at $47 million, fully funded. The BLA recommended approval. Chair Chan expressed concerns about cost overruns and lack of a return trigger. The committee voted to forward without recommendation. The item passed unanimously without recommendation. - Item 7 (Resolution - Accept $100,000 from California Energy Commission): Department of Building Inspection retroactively accepted a grant for the Solar App Plus automated permitting platform. The platform went live October 1, 2023, and has issued about 50 permits. The item passed unanimously. - Item 8 (Ordinance - Vacant Storefront Fee Suspension): This item was continued to the call of the chair at the request of the mayor's office and Department of Building Inspection, to be part of budget discussions. - Item 9 (Resolution - Master Lease Extension with Navy): Treasure Island Development Authority requested a one-year extension of the master lease from December 1, 2023 to November 30, 2024. The lease covers three facilities and a walking path. The Navy issues only one-year extensions. The item was amended to add retroactive language and passed unanimously. - Item 10 (Resolution - Accept $5,100,000 from California State Coastal Conservancy): Recreation and Park Department retroactively accepted a grant for Phase 2 of the 900 Innes Redevelopment Project (India Basin Waterfront Initiative). The project is under construction, expected completion summer 2024. A deed restriction prohibiting residential and sensitive commercial uses in perpetuity was approved. The item passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 2: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 3: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 4: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 5: Forwarded to full board as amended (reduced to $1,350,239) with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 6: Forwarded to full board without recommendation (3-0). Chair Chan noted intent to revisit Administrative Code Section 6.60 regarding cost cap triggers. - Item 7: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 8: Continued to the call of the chair. - Item 9: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation after amendment adding retroactive language (3-0). - Item 10: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0).

PROCEDURAL 14% · PUBLIC SAFETY 10% · SCHOOL SAFETY 10% · TECHNOLOGY AND INFRASTRUCTURE 9%
840
JAN 10, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting – January 10, 2024: Pursuit Policy, DGO Revisions, and Crime Report

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, January 10, 2024, at 1:45 PM (UTC). The meeting included presentations on the SFPD pursuit policy and associated data, discussion and votes on several Department General Orders (DGOs), reports from the Chief and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), public comment, and a closed session. The meeting was adjourned in memory of Oakland Police Officer Tuan Lee, killed in the line of duty. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously voted to receive and file the following items: Family Code 628 incident report release, Police Commission's report of disciplinary actions for the fourth quarter of 2023, SFPD's third quarter document protocol memo, DPA's third quarter document protocol memo, SFPD's third quarter non-city entity live monitoring report, SFPD's 1421 and SB16 monthly report, and DPA's 1421 and SB16 monthly report. (Motion passed 6-0) - The minutes for the meetings of November 1, November 8, and December 5, 2023, were adopted unanimously (6-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Chris Ward Klein alleged that illegal wiretaps and bugs have been placed on him and others in the city, including the police commission, and called for their removal. - Paul Allen argued that the commission is willfully failing to comply with the city charter by not setting forth its legal authority, purpose, and goals. He urged the commission to adopt a draft he submitted. President Lyons responded that a draft is being prepared for review. - A mother of an unsolved homicide victim (Arbor Casas, murdered August 14, 2006, case 06086238) requested more resources to solve the case, including potential funding for tipsters. She asked about a prior suggestion that DPA investigators could help. - Jake Connor B. Ortega, a San Francisco resident, thanked the SFPD for their work during APEC and expressed general support for the department. He urged the commission to remember that most residents support SFPD. - A speaker supported the chief’s report, agreed that removing fentanyl from the streets saves lives, and argued that SFPD's job is not to be nurses but to ensure safety. He criticized the city’s lack of treatment funding. - Paul Allen, during the public comment on the chief’s report, commented on the drug enforcement discussion, noting that the commission cannot direct SFPD not to enforce the law, and that both enforcement and treatment are needed. Discussion Items - Chief’s Report (Item 4): Chief Scott reported that overall Part 1 crime in the first week of 2024 was down 49% compared to the same period in 2023 (39% in violent crime, 50% in property crime). He highlighted one homicide, three non-fatal shootings (injuring four, including an 8-month-old and a 7-year-old child), two fatal collisions, a series of ATM burglaries, and fentanyl seizures (over 119,610 grams in 2023, equivalent to 59.8 million lethal doses). The DMAC operation resulted in 452 arrests and 1,400 grams of narcotics seized in the first week of 2024. Vice President Carter-Oberstone questioned the effectiveness of the policy of arresting drug users, citing a record number of overdose deaths in 2023. Chief Scott defended the strategy, arguing that seizing fentanyl saves lives and that no alternative exists. Commissioner Yanez raised concerns about displacement of drug activity to night hours and adjacent neighborhoods. Chief Scott described a phased approach including night operations and non-police resources (Urban Alchemy, co-tenderloin). - DPA Director’s Report (Item 5): Director Henderson reported that DPA has opened 7 new cases in 2024 and closed 6, with 311 open cases. 31 cases have gone past the 270-day investigation period. He noted a new audit of SFPD's handling of officer misconduct (released Dec. 21, 2023) and a new audit of SFPD's stop data. He also mentioned outreach events. - Commission Reports (Item 6): Commissioner Yanez provided an update on the investigative social media DGO, which is being extended to allow more feedback. He also highlighted progress on the juvenile DGO 7.01, including language allowing officer discretion to avoid handcuffing youth and continued development of a pre-booking diversion program with restorative justice. Commissioner Benedicto shared updates on meetings with the department regarding juvenile DGO 7.01 and coordination with SFMTA on stolen car identification. - Presentation on SFPD’s Pursuit Policy (Item 7): - Lieutenant Obot (Training Division) presented on the current policy (last updated 2013), training (120 hours for recruits, annual recertification, biennial perishable skills), and pursuit data from 2018-2022 (39 pursuits in 2021, 26 in 2022, 9 in 2023 as of mid-year). He noted that 38% of chases resulted in collisions and roughly 1 in 4 resulted in injury. He cited a CHP report that pursuits with air support had a 68.8% higher apprehension rate. - Janelle Kwood (DPA Policy Director) presented a national survey of best practices, noting that 532 people died in police pursuits in 2020. She compared policies from Boston, New Orleans, Philadelphia, Detroit, Baltimore, Chicago, LAPD, and NYPD. She found SFPD’s policy is not an outlier; it permits pursuits for violent felonies or when there is an imminent threat to public safety. She recommended updating DGO 5.05 to include tire deflation devices and consideration of drones or GPS launchers (e.g., StarChase) as alternatives. Chief Scott confirmed the department is exploring drone policy and has researched StarChase but not yet requested budget. - Discussion: Commissioners asked about data on third-party injuries and apprehension rates. Lieutenant Obot noted that SFPD does not currently retain pursuit statistics locally, but new reporting systems are planned. - DGO 7.04 – Safeguarding Children of Arrested Persons (Item 8): Lieutenant O’Connor presented the revised order, which expanded definitions and clarified procedures. Discussion centered on the requirement to contact Family and Children’s Services (FCS) even when another parent is present. Commissioner Byrne raised concerns about delays, proposing a 30-minute window for FCS response, then officer discretion. DPA supported adding clarifying language. The commission decided to refer the item back for further refinement, with input from the Bar Association representative, and not to vote today. - DGO 9.05 – Citation Control (Item 9): Unanimously approved (4-0) for meet and confer. - DGO 2.06 – Vehicle Crashes Involving Employees (Item 10): Unanimously approved (6-0) for meet and confer. - DGO 3.13 – Field Training Program (Item 11): Unanimously adopted (6-0) after Commissioner Benedicto expressed frustration with delay (originally approved by commission in January 2023 but stuck in meet and confer). - DGO 7.03 – Megan’s Law (Item 12): Unanimously adopted (6-0). - Closed Session (Items 13-16): The commission voted unanimously (6-0) to go into closed session, and later voted (5-0) not to disclose the closed session discussion, except for factual information in the minutes for Item 15C. Key Outcomes - Votes and approvals: - Consent calendar items received and filed (6-0). - Minutes of November 1, 8, and December 5, 2023 adopted (6-0). - DGO 9.05 (Citation Control) approved for meet and confer (4-0, with one commissioner present less due to rotation). - DGO 2.06 (Vehicle Crashes Involving Employees) approved for meet and confer (6-0). - DGO 3.13 (Field Training Program) adopted (6-0). - DGO 7.03 (Megan’s Law) adopted (6-0). - Motion to hold closed session approved (6-0). - Motion not to disclose closed session discussion approved (5-0). - Referrals and next steps: - DGO 7.04 (Safeguarding Children) sent back to department and DPA for further revision, with expected return to commission after meet and confer. - Commissioner Yanez will extend the timeline for the social media investigative DGO to end of January to incorporate feedback. - Commissioner Benedicto will meet with the traffic division regarding STOMPA coordination on stolen car identification. - The commission will agendize a deeper discussion on the drug enforcement strategy, potentially inviting DPH, as requested by Vice President Carter-Oberstone and Commissioner Yanez. - Chief Scott indicated the department is developing a drone policy and will consider including GPS launchers (StarChase) in upcoming budget request. - DPA will forward the DOJ best practices report on vehicle pursuits to the commission.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 32% · PROCEDURAL 21% · PUBLIC SAFETY 13% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com