Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 881–890 ENTRIES
881
NOV 6, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting - November 6, 2023: Police Staffing, Airport Surveillance, and Appointments

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, November 6, 2023, at 6:00 PM UTC, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, with Vice Chair Shaman Walton and Committee Member Asha Safai. The meeting covered four agenda items: a mayoral appointment, airport surveillance technology policies, a behavioral health commission composition update, and a contentious charter amendment on police department staffing. The meeting lasted approximately 1.5 hours. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (Mayoral Appointment – Kent Lim): Unanimously approved with an amendment to strike the word "reject" from the motion, sending the appointment to the full board with a positive recommendation. Public comment was not taken. - Item 2 (Airport Surveillance Technology Policies): Approved unanimously as presented, covering three technologies: application-based commercial transport (Uber/Lyft), electronic toll readers (Fastrak), and a pilot gunshot detection system. No public comment. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 4 (Police Staffing Charter Amendment): Over 20 speakers provided public comment. Supporters of the amended version (requiring a future tax revenue source) included representatives from SEIU 1021, IFPTE Local 21, Chinese Progressive Association, and others, who argued that public safety requires a holistic approach including nurses, dispatchers, and mental health services, and that the original set-aside would harm other city services. Opponents of the amended version, including the San Francisco Chamber of Commerce, residents, and a community activist, argued that the funding should come from the general fund, not a new tax, and that the amendment was a political ploy that delayed action on police staffing. One speaker supported the continuance of item 3. Discussion Items - Item 3 (Behavioral Health Commission Composition): Chair Dorsey noted that amendments were not ready and moved to continue the item to the call of the chair. The committee unanimously voted to continue. One public commenter supported the continuance. - Item 4 (Charter Amendment – Minimum Police Department Staffing and Five-Year Annual Funding Requirement): This item generated extended debate. Chair Dorsey, the original sponsor, strongly opposed the amended version (passed last week) which made minimum staffing contingent on voter approval of a future tax. He called it a "CopTax scheme" and argued it denied voters agency. Supervisor Safai, now the sponsor of the amended version, defended it as fiscally responsible given a projected $500 million deficit, and argued that the original set-aside would pit police against other public safety services. Vice Chair Walton supported the amended version, noting that the original minimum staffing level was unachievable and that the police department was not defunded by $120 million in 2020. The committee voted 2-1 to send the item to the full board without recommendation, with Chair Dorsey dissenting. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved as amended (motion to strike "reject") and sent to the full board with a positive recommendation. (Unanimous) - Item 2: Approved and sent to the full board with a positive recommendation. (Unanimous) - Item 3: Continued to the call of the chair. (Unanimous) - Item 4: Sent to the full board without recommendation on a 2-1 vote (Walton and Safai in favor, Dorsey opposed). No further action was taken by the committee.

PUBLIC SAFETY 51% · PROCEDURAL 18% · PUBLIC COMMENT 16% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 5%
882
NOV 6, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - November 6, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on November 6, 2023, at 9:30 AM. Vice Chair Dean Preston presided in place of Chair Mirna Melgar, who was excused. Board President Aaron Peskin also attended. The meeting consisted of a single agenda item which was continued to the next meeting. Key Outcomes - Excusal of Chair Melgar: Vice Chair Preston moved to excuse Chair Melgar from the proceedings. The motion passed unanimously (2-0). - Continuance of Agenda Item 1: The ordinance to create the Non-Profit Arts Education Special Use District (bounded by Francisco, Jones, Chestnut, and Leavenworth Streets) was continued to the next Land Use and Transportation Committee meeting on November 13, 2023. President Peskin requested the continuance because the item had not yet been heard by the Historic Preservation Commission due to a lack of quorum. The committee voted unanimously (2-0) to continue the item, with the intention of sending it as a committee report to the full Board of Supervisors on November 14, 2023. - Public Comment: No public comments were received on the continuance motion. - Adjournment: With no further business, the meeting was adjourned.

PROCEDURAL 100%
883
NOV 2, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Regular Meeting – November 2, 2023

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, November 2, 2023, at approximately 1:30 PM (local time) in City Hall, with President Tanner presiding. All seven commissioners were present: Vice President Moore, Commissioners Braun, Diamond, Imperial, Koppel, and Ruiz. The meeting covered continuances, a consent calendar, commission matters, department reports, general public comment, and seven regular calendar items, including a major school expansion and three discretionary review cases. Votes were recorded on all actions. Consent Calendar - Items 6–10 (Conditional Use Authorizations): Routine approvals for residential unit conversions at 2999 California Street (503), 3420 18th Street (204, 402, 403), and 750 Van Ness Avenue (1103, 1303, 201). Approved unanimously (7-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Georgia Shuttish (in-person): Urged codification of residential flat preservation policy, citing a recent sale that eliminated a second kitchen. Supported maintaining original flat configurations. - Angela Adams (Carpenters Union Local 22): Introduced herself as a field rep, advocated for fair wages, labor standards, and developer accountability for construction workers in San Francisco. - Sue Hester (remote): Requested a written report from the Planning Department on a recent HCD letter that shifts approvals from the commission to staff, warning of conflicts with voter-approved ballot measures (e.g., Prop M). Expressed concern about loss of commission authority. - Additional public comment on specific items: (See respective Discussion Items below.) Discussion Items - Item 1–5 (Continuance Calendar): Items 1 (business signs) continued to Dec 7; Item 2 (eliminating public art requirement for 100% affordable housing) continued to Nov 16 after Commissioner Ruiz recused herself (7-0); Items 3 & 4 continued indefinitely; Item 5 withdrawn. All continuances passed (7-0 except Item 2 with Ruiz recused, 6-0). - Item 16 (Non-Profit Arts Education SUD): Continued to Nov 9 due to HPC quorum loss. - Item 17 (68 Nantucket Ave – Rezone): The owner (Darren) requested rezoning two parcels from Public (P) to RH1 to allow future residential development. Staff supported, no opposition. Approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 18 (2001 37th Ave – St. Ignatius College Prep Expansion): Project Description: Demolish 60,000 sq ft of buildings (including dormitory) and construct a 40-ft-tall, 180,000 sq ft addition with educational spaces, chapel, and dining. No enrollment increase. Public Testimony: Approximately 35 letters of opposition (Sunset Community Garden, citing shadow impacts from Nov–Feb) and 100 letters of support. Over 20 speakers: students urged approval for modern learning spaces; union representatives (plumbers, laborers, glaziers, etc.) praised 100% union commitment; community garden members requested a continuance to redesign the north facade to reduce shading. Commission Action: Acknowledged garden concerns but found impacts not severe enough to deny. Approved with conditions: five-year permit validity (phase 1), 20-year limit on phase 2, staff to continue working with community garden. Motion by Commissioner Koppel, seconded by Moore. Vote: 7-0. - Item 19 (322-324 Fair Oaks – Remove Unauthorized Unit): Project to remove an unpermitted dwelling unit (kitchen) to restore storage; unit was unoccupied and substandard. One letter of support. Approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 20 (600 Ortega – Demolition & Rebuild): Demolish existing single-family home and build a new 4,465 sq ft three-story home due to unstable soil (30 ft of loose sand). Neighbor concerns addressed via revised deck setbacks. Approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 21 (2277 33rd Ave – Change of Use from RCF to SFR): Conversion of a vacant residential care facility back to a single-family home. After continuance for negotiation with Self-Help for the Elderly (funding unavailable), project sponsor confirmed no viable operator. Staff report noted small RCFs are disappearing due to funding gaps. Approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 22a/b (355 Lombard – DR & Variance): Discretionary Review: Two DR requesters (neighbors at 347 and 361 Lombard) opposed a three-story addition over garage, citing light, noise, privacy, and echoing. Staff recommended taking DR and requiring a 9-foot setback of the front roof deck. Variance: Zoning Administrator granted the required exposure variance. Commission voted to take DR (7-0) and approve with staff condition, plus ongoing work with neighbors. - Item 23 (552 Jersey – DR): DR requester (Lane Kennedy, 560 Jersey) requested frosted glass on new side windows facing her property to protect privacy. Staff recommended no DR, arguing no extraordinary circumstances. Commission voted to take DR (5-2, Diamond and Tanner dissenting) and require obscure glass on the ground-floor bathroom window only. Key Outcomes - Approvals (all unanimous unless noted): Continuances (Items 1–5); Consent Calendar (Items 6–10); Adoption of Sept 14 & Oct 19 minutes (7-0); Rezone at 68 Nantucket (Item 17, 7-0); St. Ignatius expansion (Item 18, 7-0); Removal of unauthorized unit (Item 19, 7-0); Demolition/rebuild at 600 Ortega (Item 20, 7-0); Change of use at 2277 33rd Ave (Item 21, 7-0); DR at 355 Lombard with 9-ft setback (Item 22, 7-0); DR at 552 Jersey with obscure glass on one window (Item 23, 5-2). - Variance granted for 355 Lombard (Item 22b). - Commission Comments: Commissioners Imperial and Moore raised concerns about insurance companies leaving California (affecting housing viability) and requested department tracking. Commissioner Imperial also praised SFMOMA for a Filipino art exhibit and a community equity council vision for downtown. - Director's Report (Aaron Starr): Reviewed land use committee actions: Irish Cultural Center SUD (continued), citywide commercial/retail expansion ordinance (continued with amendments), constraints reduction ordinance (continued), and passage of nighttime entertainment Castro Street NCD amendments. - General Public Comment: Three speakers addressed issues including residential flat preservation, union labor standards, and the HCD letter on administrative approvals.

PUBLIC EDUCATION 29% · LAND USE 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 10%
884
NOV 2, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting – November 2, 2023

Date: November 2, 2023 | Time: 18:15 UTC | Location: City Hall, San Francisco This regular meeting of the Government Audit and Oversight Committee (GAO) convened at 18:15 UTC to address seven agenda items, including a memorandum of understanding for the San Francisco Public Library, annual financial audit reports for FY2021-2022, three civil grand jury reports (teacher shortage, hiring crisis, and small business support), and a hearing on the impact of downtown business closures. The committee was chaired by Vice Chair Supervisor Catherine Stefani, joined by Supervisors Connie Chan and Joel Engardio. Supervisor Dean Preston was excused. Consent Calendar - Item 1 – MOU with Friends and Foundation of the San Francisco Public Library: Approved unanimously (3-0) with a positive recommendation to the full Board. The 10‑year MOU defines roles, responsibilities, and fiscal support for library fundraising, operations, and capital projects. No public opposition was voiced. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1: Carrie Blanding (interim executive director, Friends and Foundation) expressed full support for the MOU. Matthew Keniston (board member and treasurer) advocated for approval. - Item 3 (Civil Grand Jury – Hiring Crisis): Continued to the call of the chair at the request of Supervisor Preston (absent); no public comment. - Item 4 (Teacher Shortage): Two public speakers: Michael Kerboy praised the grand jury report and urged close oversight of SFUSD; Lawrence Lee (former grand jury member) described HR and payroll failures as a “house on fire.” - Items 5 & 6 (Small Business Report): No public comment. - Item 7 (Downtown Business Closures): No public comment. Discussion Items Item 1 – Library MOU Maureen Singleton (COO, San Francisco Public Library) summarized the MOU’s key articles, including annual fiscal support, capital projects, grant applications, and a 10‑year term. The committee asked no questions and moved the item forward. Item 2 – Annual Comprehensive Financial Reports & Audit Plans Presenters: Annie Louie (MGO), Kathy Lai (Crowe LLP), and Todd Ristrom (Deputy Controller). For FY2021-2022, the city received unmodified opinions (highest assurance) with no deficiencies in internal controls or compliance. The audit plan for FY2022-2023 was introduced, covering over 20 deliverables, including new auditors for SFO and MTA. Supervisor Chan asked for clarification on “single audits” (federal grant audits required when expenditures exceed $750,000). The hearing was filed unanimously. Item 4 – Civil Grand Jury Report: “Not Making the Grade: San Francisco’s Shortage of Credentialed Teachers” Presented by jury member Pauline Sofa. Key findings: - Only 83% of classrooms statewide are staffed by fully credentialed teachers; San Francisco is second-worst in the Bay Area (ahead of Alameda). - San Francisco has more than twice the state average of “ineffective teachers” (teachers without correct credentials). - Starting teacher salary in SF is only about 60% of the federal low‑income threshold and lags behind many Bay Area districts. - The district lost 9–10% of teachers per year; recruitment suffers from low pay, a payroll crisis (11,000 tickets at peak, reduced to 2,086), and poor publicity of benefits. - Six recommendations were issued: the district agreed to most; the controller’s office declined to research the payroll fiasco. SFUSD response (Hong Mei Pang, Head of Communications; President Kevin Boga; HR Director Swan Irvin): - The district acknowledges the challenges but notes the teacher shortage is statewide/national. - Since the report, they hired 600 teachers, reduced payroll tickets to 2,086, and reached a tentative agreement with UESF including a $9,000 raise for teachers in 2023-24 and an additional 5% in 2024-25. - Out of 4,500 teachers, “approximately” 1,700 employees (including teachers) have open payroll cases; many are clerical but some have taken months. Supervisor Chan pressed for specific numbers on teachers with unresolved payroll issues beyond one pay period. The district promised to follow up. The hearing was filed. Items 5 & 6 – Civil Grand Jury Report: “Taking Care of Business: San Francisco’s Plan to Save Its Small Businesses” & Board Response Resolution Presented by jury member Rob Chancellor. Key findings: - Proposition H (30‑day permit processing, elimination of neighborhood notification) and the “First Year Free” program (waived fees for new businesses) are underutilized due to poor tracking and technology gaps. - Only 68% of eligible businesses in some areas (e.g., zip 94104) recovered; downtown business openings dropped 20% post-pandemic. - Nine recommendations were made, including making First Year Free permanent, extending Proposition H protections for three years, integrating cross-departmental technology, and requiring supervisors to hold quarterly small business meetings. Vice Chair Stefani proposed a resolution with the Board’s positions: - Finding 1 (First Year Free benefits modest): Agree. - Finding 9 (perception that city is inhospitable): Partially disagree – city has deployed resources but cannot confirm sufficiency. - Recommendation 1 (make First Year Free permanent): Requires further analysis; BLA to study financial impact by June 30, 2024. - Recommendation 5 (extend Prop H protections to Dec 2026): Not yet implemented but will be by June 30, 2024. - Recommendation 7 (technology integration): Not yet implemented; will not be implemented until BLA study complete. - Recommendation 8.5 (quarterly supervisor meetings): Will not be implemented because districts are unique and most offices already hold such meetings regularly. - Recommendation 9 (marketing campaign): Has been implemented through existing resources (Shop Dine SF, videos, handouts). The resolution was adopted 3-0, and the hearing was filed. However, the committee later rescinded the vote to keep the hearing open for final adjustments; the item was then continued to the call of the chair. Item 7 – Hearing: Impact of Downtown Business Closures Lead sponsor: Supervisor Engardio. Chief Economist Ted Egan (Controller’s Office): - Downtown businesses (sales-tax remitting) declined 20% from 4,000 pre-pandemic to 3,200 in 2023. - Non-downtown recovery is stronger (90% of pre‑pandemic levels). - Retail recovery downtown <80%; restaurants 90%. - Office vacancy 30% ; office attendance 42% of pre‑COVID. However, San Francisco saw the largest year‑on‑year office attendance gain in the US (July 2022–2023). - Five largest tech companies pay $70M/year in business taxes; they face 20–100× higher tax burden than South Bay cities. - “Doom loop” not currently present, but risks exist if business tax reforms are not pursued. - Proposed shift from payroll‑based to sales‑based tax allocation to reduce incentive for firms to leave. - Housing prices have come down: condos now 4× national average (down from 6×). Sarah Dennis Phillips (OEWD): - Downtown recovery is slow but improving; retail changed permanently; tourism rebounding (Asia-Pacific tourism still lagging). - Mayor’s “Roadmap to Recovery” focuses on safety, retention, activation (e.g., night markets), and public spaces. - 67% of pre‑pandemic foot traffic recovered, despite 42% office attendance – indicating people come for other reasons. - Examples: Mission Rock, East Cut, The Crossing (pickleball) are models for mixed‑use downtown. - Strategic challenges: HCSO healthcare costs burden businesses; office‑to‑residential conversions are financially infeasible for most buildings. The hearing was filed unanimously (3-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1: MOU approved and sent to full Board. - Item 2: Hearing filed; audit plans accepted. - Item 3: Continued to call of the chair (motion passed 3-0). - Item 4: Hearing filed; district asked to provide data on teacher payroll issues. - Items 5 & 6: Resolution adopted (3-0) directing clerk to prepare Board responses; hearing initially filed but later rescinded and continued to call of the chair for final adjustments. - Item 7: Hearing filed (3-0). - Other: The committee excused Supervisor Preston (2-0, Chan absent). All roll‑call votes were 3-0 in favor of motions.

PUBLIC EDUCATION 20% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 18% · SMALL BUSINESS SUPPORT 17% · PROCEDURAL 9%
885
NOV 1, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - November 1, 2023

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Wednesday, November 1, 2023, at 10:00 AM (estimated) in City Hall. Chair Connie Chan presided, joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Ahsha Safaí. The committee considered 12 agenda items, including a $300 million affordable housing bond, several contracts, emergency declarations, and leases. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 1 & 2 (Affordable Housing Bond): - Elena Engel (350 San Francisco) expressed support for the bond but argued that the 30 million for housing preservation should include a firm commitment to electrify units (remove methane gas). She stated that decarbonization costs are about 3–4% of the preservation fund. - John Avalos (Council of Community Housing Organizations) expressed full support for the bond, stating it is necessary for San Francisco’s economic recovery and will leverage state and federal funds. He noted that decarbonization can be funded through other sources like the Public Utilities Commission. - Items 6–8 (Jackson Park Grant & Emergency Declarations): - Multiple parents and community members (e.g., Sasha Xavier Reich, Zuri Peace Green) spoke in favor of the Jackson Park renovation, citing the need for better facilities, safe bathrooms, and reduced conflict over field usage. J.R. Epler (Potrero Boosters) noted the park’s critical role in the neighborhood’s open space ecosystem. - Woody LaBounty (San Francisco Heritage) supported the Trocadero Clubhouse repairs, calling it a historic neighborhood jewel. - Item 11 (SF General Hospital Foundation Lease): - Kim Meredith, CEO of the Foundation, stated the organization has raised $245 million since 1993 and has a five-year plan to raise another $250 million. She noted they invested $2 million in building upgrades and requested continued rent-free space. Discussion Items - Items 1 & 2 – Affordable Housing General Obligation Bond (Not to Exceed $300,000,000): - The committee heard these items after a one-week hold due to amendments requested by President Peskin. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) recommended approval. Vice Chair Mandelman added as co-sponsor. The committee voted 2-0 (Safaí absent) to forward both items to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Note: The bond will appear on the March 5, 2024 ballot. - Item 3 – Administrative Code – Reproduction and Notary Fees: - The Department of Administrative Services requested fee increases for the Permit Center’s print and notary services to recover costs. The BLA recommended approval. The committee voted 2-0 (Mandelman absent) to forward with a positive recommendation. - Item 4 – Purchase of Used CNG Buses from Phoenix ($350,000): - SFO proposed buying 14 used compressed natural gas transit buses (13–14 years old, useful life 3–5 years) for $25,000 each to expand employee shuttle service. Total cost with towing and parts estimated at about $110,000 per bus, far less than new electric buses ($900,000 each). The BLA recommended approval. The committee voted 3-0 to forward with a positive recommendation. Supervisor Safaí noted the decision balances environmental goals with fiscal prudence. - Item 5 – District 7 Participatory Budgeting Appropriations ($527,000): - Supervisor Melgar’s office presented 17 projects selected by district residents, including mural art, playground upgrades, traffic calming, and emergency preparedness. The BLA recommended approval. The committee voted 3-0 to forward with a positive recommendation. - Items 6 – Jackson Park Renovation Grant ($12,440,735): - Rec and Park presented a $12.4 million grant from Friends of Jackson Park to renovate the 5‑acre park (last renovated 1998). The total project cost is about $40 million, with $30 million already raised. The design includes multi‑use courts, flexible open space, and a renovated clubhouse. Supervisor Safaí raised concerns about scheduling conflicts between basketball and pickleball; staff said community meetings continue (next on Nov. 11). Chair Chan questioned the in-kind architectural donation and community input. The committee voted 3-0 to forward the resolution with a positive recommendation. Supervisor Safaí added as co-sponsor. - Items 7 & 8 – Emergency Declarations for Storm Damage: - Rec and Park declared emergencies for winter storm damage at Stern Grove (debris removal) and Trocadero Clubhouse repair. The BLA noted that the department missed the 60‑day deadline to submit resolutions to the board. The committee amended Item 8 to cap the Stern Grove emergency work at $2.1 million (as recommended by BLA). The committee voted 3-0 to forward both items without recommendation to the full board, with the expectation that Rec and Park will establish written emergency procedures within 30 days. - Item 9 – Radiation Detection Badge Services Contract ($420,000): - The Office of Contract Administration (OCA) requested approval for a five-year contract (with two-year option) for dosimetry monitoring for city employees exposed to radiation. The BLA recommended approval. The committee voted 3-0 to forward with a positive recommendation. - Item 10 – Gasoline Contract Amendment with Western States Oil (Not to Exceed $35,450,000): - OCA requested retroactive approval of a fifth amendment increasing contract value by $2.95 million and extending term by 19 days (to November 19, 2023) due to rising fuel prices. The BLA found the increase reasonable. The committee voted 3-0 to forward with a positive recommendation. - Item 11 – Lease with SF General Hospital Foundation ($0 Rent): - The Real Estate Department proposed a 20‑year no‑rent lease for the foundation (about 4,900 sq ft) to continue its fundraising support for Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital. The BLA noted a past unpaid rent issue (now resolved) and that the total rent waived over 40 years is $13.6 million, calling it a policy matter. The committee voted 3-0 to forward with a positive recommendation, acknowledging the foundation’s $245 million fundraising and future $250 million goal. - Item 12 – Lease at 3801 3rd Street (Bayview Plaza, $554,347/year): - The chair requested a continuance to the call of the chair due to outstanding BLA analysis and her concerns. The committee voted 3-0 to continue the item. Key Outcomes - Items 1 & 2 (Affordable Housing Bond): Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (2-0, Safaí absent). - Item 3 (Reproduction Fees): Forwarded with positive recommendation (2-0, Mandelman absent). - Item 4 (CNG Bus Purchase): Forwarded with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 5 (District 7 Budget Transfer): Forwarded with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 6 (Jackson Park Grant): Forwarded with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 7 & 8 (Emergency Declarations): Forwarded without recommendation (3-0) after amending Item 8 to cap at $2.1 million; Rec and Park to report back within 30 days on emergency procedures. - Item 9 (Radiation Badges): Forwarded with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 10 (Gasoline Contract): Forwarded with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 11 (SFGH Foundation Lease): Forwarded with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 12 (Bayview Plaza Lease): Continued to call of chair (3-0). The meeting adjourned after approximately 2 hours.

PARKS AND RECREATION 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13% · CONTRACT MANAGEMENT 11% · EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT 7%
886
NOV 1, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - November 1, 2023

The San Francisco Police Commission met on November 1, 2023, at 1:45 PM to address routine business, receive reports, and discuss policy revisions and data on use of force disparities. Key actions included adopting a revised use-of-force policy for tire deflation devices, hearing the Chief’s crime report, and receiving a presentation on racial disparities in use of force. Consent Calendar - Received and filed the DPA August/September 2023 monthly statistical report (unanimous vote, 6-0). - Adopted minutes from the meetings of October 4, 11, and 18, 2023 (unanimous vote, 6-0). Public Comments & Testimony - An unidentified speaker criticized the commission for hindering police, claimed authority to fire commissioners, and expressed disappointment in the commission’s performance. - Jay Connor Biertega (Co-President of Econic D3) thanked SFPD officers, criticized the Board of Supervisors for neglecting public safety, stated that officers fear repercussions for mistakes, and asserted that the silent majority will no longer accept crime. - Alan Burodell thanked the previous speaker and later commented that discussions on overdose deaths and law enforcement should be properly agendized. - A speaker on the officer recognition line item stressed that police uniforms do not absolve responsibility. - During public comment on the Chief’s report: one speaker questioned the need for massive law enforcement presence for APEC; another supported the Chief’s enforcement efforts and community assistance; Mark Bruno discussed volunteer work with homeless and mental health; another speaker disputed the claim that law enforcement increases overdoses; and a mother of a homicide victim spoke about her son’s unsolved case and the Day of the Dead. - During commission reports, a member of the public argued that comments on policy should be made only after they are agendized to allow public preparation. Discussion Items - Weekly Officer Recognition (Item 1): Sergeant Justin Bugarin was recognized for his work developing the Critical Mindset Coordinated Response (CMCR) training, which reduced use-of-force incidents. He received a statewide outstanding instructor award from the Commission on Police Officer Standards and Training (POST). Commissioners, the Chief, and DPA Director praised his impact on training and culture. - Chief’s Report (Item 5): Chief William Scott reported year-to-date crime statistics: overall crime down 7% (3,000 fewer crimes), violent crime up 2% (112 more incidents), property crime down 8% (3,000 fewer). Homicides up 7% to 46 (47th from a prior stabbing); gun violence down 6%; gun recoveries up 2% to 912. Detailed recent homicides, shootings, and an explosives incident where a suspect threw devices at officers. Discussed APEC preparations: thousands of law enforcement personnel, SFPD leading local tactics, Secret Service overall security, MOUs with local agencies, full mobilization of all officers ensuring station coverage. Commissioners asked about the tenderloin strategy; the Chief cited collaboration with health navigators (9 people accepted services in one night) and fentanyl seizures (100,000 grams since May 29). Commissioner Yanez raised concerns about increased overdose deaths possibly linked to enforcement, citing an Indianapolis study; the Chief argued for more time and a holistic approach. Commissioner Byrne noted increased federal prosecutions and asked about Union Square deployment; the Chief confirmed 16 officers assigned. Commissioner Yee asked about a fatal pedestrian collision and APEC joint exercises. - DPA Director’s Report (Item 6): Director Henderson reported 668 cases opened, 610 closed, 316 pending, 48 sustained, 21 cases past nine months, 18 of which are tolled. Highest allegation category: neglect of duty (14%). Mission station had most allegations this week. - Commission Reports (Item 7): Commissioner Walker requested that APEC coordination and agenda clarification be agendized. Commissioner Benedicto noted DGO 7.01 (juvenile policy) is posted for public comment. Vice President Carter Overstone announced a policy analyst position was frozen by the mayor, and requested a future presentation on reward policy reform. He defended Commissioner Yanez’s comments as within the agenda scope. - Discussion on DGO 5.01 – Tire Deflation Devices (Item 8): The commission discussed the revised policy on preemptive use of spike strips. The Chief requested a 30-business-day implementation delay due to APEC training constraints. The motion passed 6-0. - Presentation on Use of Force on People of Color (Item 9): Catherine McGuire (Strategic Management Bureau), Jason Cunningham (analyst), and Sergeant Rivera presented data on racial disparities. The per capita disparity ratio for Black vs. White individuals reached 25x in Q4 2022, driven by a larger decrease in White use-of-force counts. Cunningham explained the calculation method. Commissioner Yanez questioned why disparities persist despite policy changes (May and December 2022), asked about evidence-based outcomes for training (e.g., Sojourn trips), and pressed for measurable plans. Chief Scott noted challenges in determining causation, cited ongoing partnerships (CPE, Stanford, UC Berkeley), and argued that training rarely has direct outcome studies. Commissioner Benedicto emphasized the need to address the recent jump in disparities, not just the long-term trend. Commissioners discussed factors like command-directed enforcement, recidivism, and data limitations. DPA Director Henderson advocated for expanded data sharing. The presentation was received for discussion; no vote was taken. - Closed Session (Items 10-13): The commission voted 6-0 to hold a closed session and subsequently voted 6-0 not to disclose any discussion from closed session. Key Outcomes - Adopted revised DGO 5.01 (tire deflation devices) with a 30-business-day implementation delay (unanimous, 6-0). - Received and filed DPA monthly statistical report (unanimous). - Adopted minutes from October 4, 11, and 18, 2023 (unanimous). - Voted to hold and not disclose closed session discussions (unanimous). - Directed the department to consider further analysis of the recent use-of-force disparity increase, including potential commission follow-up in early 2024. - Items identified for future agendas: APEC coordination, clarification of agenda rules, reward policy presentation, community policing manual status, and progress on juvenile pre-arrest diversion.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 36% · PUBLIC SAFETY 22% · PROCEDURAL 19% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 9%
887
OCT 31, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - October 31, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, October 31, 2023 (Halloween). The meeting included a consent agenda covering routine settlements and administrative items, several legislative items on the regular agenda, committee reports, and introductions of new business. Notably, the board honored Dr. Gina Fromer for her decades of community service, and debated public safety issues including police staffing and behavioral health workforce vacancies. Consent Calendar - Approved minutes of September 26, 2023 board meeting. - Adopted items 1–8, including settlements: Katy Sullivan ($207,500), Adam Smith et al. ($130,401.66), Macquarie Holdings ($252,526.71), Bank of New York Mellon ($1,355,943.09), PFP Holdings ($1,039,237.26). - Approved administrative code changes for Library Laureate Programs, Assessment Appeals Board remote hearings, and Graffiti Advisory Board. Public Comments & Testimony - Several members of the public spoke on a range of issues: - Jordan (disabled trans activist) criticized city employees for misgendering, called for firings, and opposed Supervisor Mandelman's charter reform, advocating for a council-manager system and elected controller. - Leah McGeever (D6 resident) expressed concern about transphobic harassment in San Francisco, noting attacks on trans activists and calling for greater protection. - Jay Connor B. Ortega (co-president of Iconic D3) criticized the board for unclean streets and homeless encampments, urged treatment over drug dens, and warned of ballot initiatives to restructure city government. - Dmitry Yakushkin (D8 resident) argued that police force size has no statistically significant effect on crime, citing a systematic review of 62 studies, and urged investment in behavioral health instead. - Other speakers addressed personal safety, charter reform, and CDC quarantine stations. Discussion Items - Item 9 (Nighttime Entertainment in Castro NCD): Ordinance to allow nighttime entertainment with conditional use authorization on second floors in the Castro Street Neighborhood Commercial District. Passed 9–1, with Supervisor Peskin dissenting. - Item 10 (Cash Revolving Funds): Removed authorization for certain city departments and reduced the Port's fund. Passed 10–0. - Item 11 (YMCA Truancy Program Grant): Retroactively approved a $5,390,219 not-to-exceed grant increase and one-year extension (July 1, 2013–June 30, 2024). Adopted. - Item 12 (Water Main Break Emergency): Declared emergency for repairs on Fillmore and Green streets, cost not to exceed $5,000,000. Adopted. - Item 13 (Harvey Milk Plaza Gift): Accepted design documents valued at approximately $1,275,000 from Friends of Harvey Milk Plaza. Adopted. - Items 14-15 (Mission Rock Special Tax Bonds): Authorized issuance of up to $58,335,000 in special tax bonds and related pledge agreements for Mission Rock infrastructure. Adopted. - Item 16 (Japanese Community Youth Council Grant): Supervisor Chan explained the item was voted out of committee without recommendation due to data tracking discrepancies between DCYF, OEWD, and the Human Rights Commission. He noted an audit by the controller and a new RFP for 2024, but urged approval. Adopted same house, same call. - Item 17 (Twilio Settlement): Authorized $18,000,000 settlement for a tax refund lawsuit covering periods 2009–2018. Passed on first reading. - Items 18-19 (Charter Amendments): Both items (SFMTA budget mayor approval, Department of Emergency Management) were continued one week. - Item 22 (Foot and Bike Patrol Strategy): Supervisor Safai presented the ordinance, requiring the police chief to adopt a foot and bike patrol strategy by January 1, 2024, with annual reports. He argued it would build community trust and improve morale. Passed on first reading. Key Outcomes - Votes: Item 9 passed 9-1; Items 10, 22, and consent items passed unanimously; Items 11-16 adopted without recorded dissent. - Police Staffing Debate: Supervisor Dorsey submitted a drafting request for a police full staffing fund and reappropriation of $8.4 million this fiscal year, emphasizing urgency. Supervisor Ronan countered by introducing a resolution for an emergency hiring plan for behavioral health workers, noting 144 vacancies at DPH and zero investment compared to $149 million for SFPD since 2022. - Charter Reform: Supervisor Mandelman outlined a six-point charter reform package for potential 2024 ballot: repealing deputy mayor prohibition, allowing mayor to fire department heads, giving mayor veto over board appointments to commissions, ending board-initiated ordinances to voters, streamlining commissions, and expanding emergency declaration powers to address homelessness and overdoses. - Commendation: The board recognized Dr. Gina Fromer for her leadership at Children's Council, prior roles at YMCA ($8.5M raised for Bayview Y), Trust for Public Land, and her new position as CEO of Glide. Multiple supervisors praised her impact on child care and community. - For Adoption Without Committee: Item 25, urging the Department of Elections to report on implementation of Assembly Bill No. 57 for 2024 elections, was adopted unanimously. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned in memory of Jose Orlando Salazar on behalf of Supervisor Safai.

PUBLIC COMMENT 34% · PROCEDURAL 12% · CHARTER AMENDMENTS 8% · PUBLIC SAFETY 8%
888
OCT 30, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting - October 30, 2023: Police Staffing Charter Amendment and Community Policing Ordinance

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, October 30, 2023, at 18:15 UTC, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, with Vice Chair Shimon Walton and Committee Member Asha Safai. The committee considered two items: a proposed charter amendment to establish minimum police staffing levels and a five-year funding requirement, and an ordinance requiring a foot and bike patrol strategy. The meeting featured extensive public comment and debate, culminating in votes to amend and continue the charter amendment and to advance the community policing ordinance. Public Comments & Testimony - Numerous speakers from labor unions (SEIU 1021, IFPTE Local 21), community organizations, and residents opposed the original charter amendment, arguing it would drain other public safety services (e.g., 911 dispatchers, nurses, mental health workers) without a dedicated revenue source. Many supported Supervisor Safai's amendment requiring a funding source. - Several speakers, including small business owners, a firefighter, and tourism representatives, supported Supervisor Dorsey's original charter amendment, citing the need for a fully staffed police department to address crime, fentanyl crisis, and public perception. - A few speakers, including a public defender representative and harm reduction advocates, opposed the charter amendment entirely, arguing that more police do not address root causes of crime and that the department has a track record of misconduct. - No public comments were made on the second item (community policing ordinance). Discussion Items Item 1 – Charter Amendment: Minimum Police Department Staffing and Five-Year Annual Funding Requirement - Supervisor Dorsey presented the charter amendment as a response to a "public safety crisis" driven by fentanyl, open-air drug markets, and police understaffing. He argued the amendment would provide the certainty of funding over five years to recruit and retain officers. - Supervisor Safai proposed an amendment to tie the funding to existing or new revenue sources, citing the city's projected $780 million budget deficit and the mayor's request for mid-year cuts. He argued that the police department's recruitment budget had been flat at $250,000 since 2007 and that the mayor could address this through the normal budget process. - Vice Chair Walton stated that the original charter amendment was a "myth" because staffing cannot be guaranteed, and that the focus should be on improving the public perception of policing to attract recruits. - Chief of Police Scott and Commander Jones testified that the certainty of multi-year funding would help in recruiting, but acknowledged that staffing challenges are also due to a competitive environment and a lack of desire to become police officers. - The committee debated the effectiveness of the amendment, with Supervisor Dorsey calling the Safai amendment a "poison pill" that would require a tax hike, while Supervisor Safai defended it as fiscally responsible. Item 2 – Administrative Code: Community Policing and Foot and Bike Patrols - Supervisor Safai presented amendments to require the Chief of Police to adopt a foot and bike patrol strategy by January 1, 2024, and the Police Commission to hold annual hearings. The goal is to ensure equitable deployment across districts. - Chief Scott noted that the plan is dependent on staffing levels, but that he supports the concept. The committee unanimously approved the amendments and sent the ordinance to the full board. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Charter Amendment): Supervisor Safai's amendment to require a funding source (existing or new revenue) was approved by a vote of 3-0 (Dorsey, Walton, Safai all in favor). The item was then continued to the November 6, 2023 Rules Committee meeting on a motion passed 2-1 (Walton and Safai in favor, Dorsey opposed). - Item 2 (Community Policing Ordinance): The amendments were adopted unanimously, and the ordinance was sent to the full Board of Supervisors as a committee report with a positive recommendation (3-0).

POLICE OVERSIGHT 42% · PUBLIC SAFETY 26% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 12% · PUBLIC HEALTH 8%
889
OCT 30, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - October 30, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on October 30, 2023, at 9:45 AM. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, joined by Board President Aaron Peskin and Supervisor Hillary Ronen (substituting for Vice Chair Dean Preston, who was excused). The committee considered four agenda items: a cultural center special use district, neighborhood amenities permitting, commercial use expansion, and housing production streamlining. Public comment was taken in person, and several items were continued to November 27, 2023, due to outstanding legal reviews and amendments. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Cultural Center SUD): Multiple speakers, including Eileen Boken and Evan Rosen, opposed the special use district, citing procedural errors with the California Coastal Commission. They argued that the planning department had improperly conditioned a coastal zone permit on a future Local Coastal Program amendment, and urged the committee to table the item. - Item 2 (Love Our Neighborhoods): Commenters generally supported the ordinance but raised concerns about planter boxes used as hostile architecture. Scott Feeney and Aaron Breet Ward highlighted that such installations can block ADA access, stroller routes, and sidewalk flow. Michael Smith emphasized the need for clear regulations ensuring accessibility and maintenance. - Item 3 (Commercial Use Expansion): Speakers expressed support for streamlining small business permits but called for better interagency coordination. Eric Brooks (Our City SF) advocated for commercial rent control and public banking. Simon Bertrand (SF New Deal) noted the need for accountability across city departments. - Item 4 (Housing Production): A large number of commenters opposed the streamlining legislation. David Wu (Soma Pilipinas), Charlie Shamus (Council of Community Housing Organizations), and others argued it prioritizes market-rate housing over affordable housing, threatens rent-controlled units, and weakens community input. Calvin Welch (HOPE) called for rejecting the bill entirely. One speaker, Robert Fruckman (SF YIMBY), urged passage to avoid HCD penalties. Discussion Items Item 1: Wawona Street and 45th Avenue Cultural Center Special Use District – Supervisor Joel Engardio (sponsor) presented the ordinance to redevelop the Irish Cultural Center. Planning staff and project sponsor John Kevlin provided an overview. President Peskin noted that a letter from the California Coastal Commission (dated October 30) was received only at 1:01 PM, creating transparency issues. After debate, the committee adopted all amendments except one finding (related to the LCP amendment) and continued the item to November 27, 2023. Item 2: Public Works Code – Love Our Neighborhoods Projects – Director Carla Short described a three-tier permit system (Tier 1: registration, no fee; Tier 2: $500 fee; Tier 3: $1,000 fee) for community-led amenities like benches, libraries, and murals. Discussion focused on fee structures, interagency coordination, and ensuring that planters do not block public right-of-way. President Peskin suggested a single-point-of-entry approach and noted that Tier 3 fees could be burdensome for community benefit districts. The item was continued to November 27, 2023. Item 3: Planning Code – Citywide Expansion of Commercial, Restaurant, and Retail Uses – Director Katie Tang (Mayor's Office of Small Business) presented the legislation, which aims to reduce barriers for small businesses by permitting more uses on ground floors, eliminating conditional use requirements for certain changes, and expanding the priority review program. Supervisors Melgar, Peskin, and Ronen voiced strong support but also criticized inconsistent guidance from DBI, Public Works, and other departments. Peskin noted that many permitting problems stem from departmental practices, not legislation. The committee adopted Tang's amendments (including two late additions regarding Folsom Street NCT and limited corner commercial uses) and continued the item to November 27, 2023. Item 4: Planning Code – Housing Production – Supervisor Melgar explained that the item needed to be continued because the city attorney required time to review guidance from HCD and reconcile the mayor's legislation with her own special use district amendments. Supervisor Mandelman, now a temporary member, proposed amendments to replace conditional use requirements with unit size limits (3,000 sq ft) in the Corona Heights and Central Neighborhoods special use districts to prevent monster homes. The committee agreed to create a duplicate file, amend it with Mandelman's proposals, and continue that duplicate to the call of the chair. The original file was continued to November 27, 2023. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to amend (excluding one finding) passed unanimously. Motion to continue as amended to November 27, 2023, passed unanimously. - Item 2: Motion to continue to November 27, 2023, passed unanimously. - Item 3: Motion to adopt amendments (including two late additions) passed unanimously. Motion to continue as amended to November 27, 2023, passed unanimously. - Item 4: Motion to amend the duplicated file (Mandelman's monster home amendments) passed unanimously. Motion to continue the original file to November 27, 2023, passed unanimously. Motion to continue the duplicated amended file to the call of the chair passed unanimously.

PUBLIC COMMENT 19% · PERMIT PROCESS 18% · PROCEDURAL 14% · LAND USE 7%
890
OCT 26, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Regular Hearing - October 26, 2023

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular hearing on Thursday, October 26, 2023, at approximately 1:00 PM Pacific Time. The meeting covered a wide range of items, including continuances, a consent calendar, commission matters, department reports, general public comment, and a lengthy regular calendar with multiple pieces of housing legislation, conditional use authorizations, and discretionary reviews. Commissioners heard from city staff, supervisors, project sponsors, and members of the public. Key topics included the Family Housing Opportunity Special Use District (SUD) amendment, removal of residential density limits in neighborhood commercial districts (NCDs), exceptions to conversion limits for production, distribution, and repair (PDR) uses, renewal of the Mission and 9th Street SUD, design standards for security gates, and several individual project approvals. Votes were taken on most items, with the majority passing 6-0 or 5-1. Consent Calendar - Item 3 (201 2nd Street, CUA): Approved unanimously (6-0) without discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 8 (Family Housing Opportunity SUD): Speaker Jake Price (Housing Action Coalition) expressed support, showing examples of six-story buildings in low-density areas. Jane Matoli (MB Action) supported the proposal. Georgia Shudish raised concerns about displacement and demo calcs. Eileen Bulkin urged returning the bill without recommendation. Felicia Neito (mom and business owner) supported higher height limits. Jessica Polo (real estate agent) supported the bill for more housing on the west side. Steve Marza (Engleside resident) supported domicity. Coley Zentel (Sunset homeowner) supported. Jeremy Schaub (Shotley Architect) strongly supported. - Item 9a/9b (Removing Density Limits): Jake Price and Jane Matoli supported consolidation of the two ordinances. Georgia Shudish noted a contrast between unit mix requirements. A remote caller supported density decontrol. - Item 10 (PDR Conversion Exceptions): No public comment. - Item 11 (Mission & 9th Street SUD): Jim Abrams (project sponsor counsel) requested extension. - Item 12 (Security Gates): No public comment. - Item 13 (401 South Van Ness): Four speakers (carpenters) expressed support for the project to create jobs and housing. - Item 14a/14b (31A Coleridge): No public comment. - Item 15 (170 Sea Cliff): No public comment. - Item 16 (725 Sanchez): Liz Clark (adjacent neighbor) requested plans and a liaison. Joanna Illing (neighbor) supported the project. - Item 17 (2100 Bryant): No public comment. - Item 18a/18b (770 Woolsey): Bonnie Ridges (DR requester) opposed stair penthouses. Kelly Torres (community member) opposed the updated plans and affordable housing switch. - Item 19 (1900 Mission): Paul O'Drisco (project sponsor) requested tenure change for BMR unit. Discussion Items - Item 1-2 (Continuances): Items continued to November 30 and December 14, 2023, respectively. Approved 6-0. - Item 4 (Land Acknowledgement): Read by staff. - Item 5 (Commission Comments): President Tanner acknowledged violence in Maine and COVID season. Commissioner Moore requested fewer legislative items per calendar. Commissioner Diamond echoed the request. - Item 6 (Director's Announcements): Director Hillis noted upcoming HCD report and state legislation briefing, and that 401 South Van Ness is the first general plan evaluation under new format. - Item 7 (Review of Past Events): Staff reported on Board of Supervisors actions and Board of Appeals continuance. - Item 8 (Family Housing Opportunity SUD): Supervisor Engardio presented amendments to allow six-story buildings on corner lots. Staff recommended modifications. Commissioners debated height (65 vs. 55 feet), group housing, and geographic scope. Motion to approve with modifications (including RM1 zoning, excluding group housing, reducing height to 55 feet) passed 5-1 (Moore opposed). - Item 9a/9b (Removing Density Limits): Two ordinances (Supervisor Safai and Mayor Breed) were combined. Staff recommended approval with modifications. Motion passed 4-2 (Commissioners Imperial and Moore opposed). - Item 10 (PDR Conversion Exceptions): Supervisor Dorsey's legislation to exempt changes between PDR, arts, and institutional uses from conditional use and replacement requirements. Staff recommended approval with modifications. Motion passed 5-1 (Moore opposed) with a recommendation to add a square footage cap. - Item 11 (Mission & 9th Street SUD): Renewal of SUD for 1270 Mission Street. Motion to approve passed 6-0. - Item 12 (Design Standards for Security Gates): Adopted with a modification to clarify transom window language. Motion passed 5-1 (President Tanner opposed? Actually Tanner voted no on the motion? The transcript says Commissioner President Tanner voted No on that motion. So 5-1? Check: On that motion, Commissioner Braun Aye, Commissioner Diamond Aye, Commissioner Imperial Aye, Commissioner Koppel Aye, Commissioner Moore Aye, Commissioner President Tanner No. So 5-1.) - Item 13 (401 South Van Ness): Large project authorization for a 10-story mixed-use building with group housing. Staff recommended approval. Motion passed 6-0 with a finding to reference the MOU with USM. - Item 14a/14b (31A Coleridge): Conditional use and variance to legalize unpermitted reconstruction. Approved 6-0. - Item 15 (170 Sea Cliff): Conditional use to demolish and construct a large single-family home. After debate on density, commissioners continued the item to November 9, 2023, for the sponsor to consider adding an ADU. Motion to continue passed 6-0. - Item 16 (725 Sanchez): Conditional use to demolish and construct a single-family home. Approved 6-0. - Item 17 (2100 Bryant): Conditional use to remove an unauthorized dwelling unit and reactivate commercial use. Approved 6-0. - Item 18a/18b (770 Woolsey): Conditional use to switch affordable housing compliance from on-site to in-lieu fee, and discretionary review on stair penthouses. Conditional use approved 6-0; DR not taken (motion to approve stair penthouses) passed 6-0. - Item 19 (1900 Mission): Discretionary review to change tenure of BMR unit from for-sale to rental. Approved 6-0. Key Outcomes - Item 8: Approved with modifications (5-1). Key changes: height limit reduced from 65 to 55 feet, no group housing, inclusion of RM1 zoning, lot mergers allowed in RH2/3. Board will consider further. - Item 9a/9b: Approved (4-2). The two ordinances will be consolidated at the Board of Supervisors into a single bill removing density limits outside priority equity geographies and adding the Excelsior Outer Mission NCD. - Item 10: Approved (5-1) with a recommendation that the Board include a square footage cap (20,000-25,000 sq ft) on the exemption. - Item 11: Approved (6-0). SUD renewed for five years with clarification on inclusionary reduction eligibility. - Item 12: Adopted (5-1). Design standards for security gate mechanisms, with modification to clarify transom window requirement. - Item 13: Approved (6-0). Large project authorization granted with conditions, including reference to MOU with USM and Carpenters Union. - Item 14a/14b: Approved (6-0). Conditional use and variance granted for legalization of unpermitted work. - Item 15: Continued (6-0) to November 9, 2023, to explore adding an ADU. - Item 16: Approved (6-0). Conditional use granted. - Item 17: Approved (6-0). Conditional use granted. - Item 18a: Approved (6-0). Conditional use to switch to in-lieu fee, with encouragement to consider hybrid approach. - Item 18b: Approved (6-0). Discretionary review not taken; stair penthouses approved. - Item 19: Approved (6-0). Tenure change for BMR unit permitted.

LAND USE 25% · PUBLIC COMMENT 22% · HOUSING 14% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 12%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com