The San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Tuesday, October 22, 2024, at 10:15 AM, with all 11 supervisors present. The meeting included a consent calendar, a special order at 3:00 PM on the Bayview Hunters Point and Candlestick Point redevelopment plan amendments, commendations for community leaders and Assemblymember Phil Ting, and general public comment. Key decisions included approving a fee waiver for a mosaic stairway, eliminating the public art requirement for 100% affordable housing, adopting a street teams reporting ordinance, and continuing the redevelopment plan amendments to a future meeting. Consent Calendar - Items 1–9 were adopted unanimously. Notable resolutions include: a lease of 950 Grant Avenue for the Public Library ($168,000 annual base rent), a grant amendment with Mission Neighborhood Centers for homelessness prevention (not to exceed $20,633,600), a Homekey grant for 685 Ellis Street (not to exceed $18,226,702), contract amendments for security guard services with A1 Protective Services (not to exceed $34,767,000) and Treeline Security ($38,977,000), an agreement to purchase 94 hybrid electric buses from New Flyer of America (not to exceed $117,751,398), retroactive health grants from the California Department of Health Care Services ($3,862,929.40 and $1,612,839.48), and a predevelopment agreement amendment with Potrero Neighborhood Collective LLC (potential termination payment not to exceed $15,546,566). Public Comments & Testimony - On the 3:00 PM Special Order (Items 22–25): Dozens of speakers offered public comment. Many community members, union representatives, and local contractors expressed support for the Candlestick Point redevelopment amendments, citing the need for affordable housing (32% affordable overall, 41% in the first phase), local hiring, and economic development. Several speakers urged accountability, including demands for Five Point/Lennar to release community benefit dollars, ensure local black contractor participation, and maintain artist studio space at Hunters Point Shipyard. Some opposed the timeline extensions and called for shorter schedules and stronger performance milestones. Speakers also raised concerns about environmental contamination, sea level rise, and the need for deeply affordable units and child care facilities. - General Public Comment: Speakers raised issues including: a labor dispute over the Department of Human Resources’ failure to honor a six-month probationary period for promoted employees as negotiated in the IFPTE Local 21 contract; support for Proposition 6 to end forced labor in state prisons; pedestrian safety following a fatal crash that morning; and requests for city support for the Special Police Officers Association (SPOA) training program for formerly incarcerated individuals. Discussion Items - Item 11 – Fee Waiver for Vicha Ratanapakdee Mosaic Stairway: Supervisor Stefani introduced an ordinance to waive major encroachment permit fees and planning code referral fees for a community-driven mosaic tile stairway project on Vicharatanapakdee Way in the Anza Vista neighborhood. The ordinance passed unanimously on first reading. - Item 12 – Eliminating Public Art Requirement for 100% Affordable Housing: Supervisor Dorsey presented an ordinance to remove the 1% public art fee from the Planning Code for 100% affordable housing projects in the C-3 district, as required by the Housing Element and HCD’s policy review. The ordinance passed 10–1, with Supervisor Peskin voting no. - Item 16 – Street Teams Reporting Ordinance: Supervisor Preston introduced an ordinance requiring regular reports from the Department of Emergency Management, Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing, Department of Public Health, and Fire Department on the efficiency and effectiveness of city street teams. The ordinance passed unanimously. - Item 27 – Interim Zoning Controls for Legacy Businesses: A resolution imposing 18-month interim zoning controls requiring conditional use authorization before replacing legacy businesses in neighborhood commercial districts was adopted without objection. Special Order: Committee of the Whole – Bayview Hunters Point and Candlestick Point Redevelopment Plan Amendments (Items 22–25) - At 3:00 PM, the Board reconvened as a Committee of the Whole to hear a presentation from OCI Director Thor Kaslofsky and Senior Project Manager Laila Huston. They outlined amendments to the Bayview Hunters Point Redevelopment Plan and the Hunters Point Shipyard Redevelopment Plan, along with a related tax pledge resolution. Key changes include: extending the timeline to incur debt to 30 years from approval and repayment to 45 years plus 15 additional years to account for Navy cleanup delays; increasing the bonded indebtedness limit to $5.9 billion combined; and transferring 2,050,000 square feet of research and development entitlement from the shipyard to Candlestick Point to allow development to proceed independently. The total planned housing is 10,672 units (32% affordable), with 7,218 units at Candlestick and 3,454 at Shipyard, plus 4.9 million sq ft of commercial space and 300 acres of open space. - Budget Legislative Analyst Nick Menard noted that only 4.5% of planned housing has been delivered since 2010, and suggested the board could consider alternatives such as reprocuring the developer or deferring approval of the shipyard amendments. - Public comment was extensive (over 30 speakers). Many supported the project but called for stronger accountability measures, local hiring, and community benefit enforcement. Several artists urged preservation of existing studio buildings at the shipyard. A few speakers opposed the timeline extensions without performance guarantees. - Supervisor Walton, who represents District 10, expressed support for moving forward but moved to continue Items 23, 24, and 25 to the next board meeting (October 29, 2024) to allow time for OCI to respond to written objections as required by state law. The hearing was filed. Commendations - The Board recognized Assemblymember Phil Ting with a resolution declaring October 22, 2024 as Assemblymember Phil Ting Day, honoring his service as budget chair and his advocacy for San Francisco, including funding for affordable housing, transportation, and community projects. Additional commendations were presented to Anne Diacampo (West Bay Filipino Multi-Service Center), the Interfaith Movement for Human Integrity (led by Rev. Deborah Lee), Carol Anderson (SFPD clerk typist, retiring after 39 years), and Doug Shoemaker (retiring President of Mercy Housing California). Key Outcomes - Items 1–9 (Consent Calendar): All adopted unanimously. - Item 11 (Mosaic Stairway): Passed on first reading unanimously. - Item 12 (Public Art Fee): Passed 10–1 (Supervisor Peskin opposed). - Items 13–15 (Liquor Licenses): Approved 11–0. - Item 16 (Street Teams Reporting): Passed unanimously. - Items 17–21 (Appointments): Approved, with residency waivers added for three appointees to Assessment Appeals Boards 1 and 2. - Items 23–25 (Redevelopment Amendments): Continued to the October 29, 2024 board meeting; hearing filed. - Item 33 (Resolution Supporting Proposition 6): Adopted without committee reference, endorsing a yes vote on California Proposition 6 to remove involuntary servitude from the state constitution. - Items 30–37 (Adoption Without Committee Reference): Adopted unanimously, including resolutions for Filipino American History Month, Father Michael J. Healy Day, Sister Cities International Day, honoring Assemblymember Ting, supporting Proposition 6, scheduling a committee of the whole on SFUSD, and approving two final maps.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on October 22, 2024, at 9:30 AM via hybrid format. The Commission elected new officers, approved the consent calendar and several regular agenda items, and heard extensive public comment on water supply, environmental justice, and community benefits. All voting items were approved unanimously (4-0) unless noted. Consent Calendar - 8A-8H: Approved eight consent items including: Amendment No. 1 to the Childcare Lease (modifying scholarship procedures); contract increases for ductile iron pipe ($117,517); water main replacement contract to Mitchell Engineering; security upgrades at Millbrae Campus to Rodan Builders; a greenhouse gas-free energy contract for CleanPowerSF; attestations of veracity for 2023 Power Source Disclosure Reports for Hetch Hetchy Power and CleanPowerSF; and novation of Contract No. PRO.0054.A from Woodard & Curran-Hydroconsult Engineers Inc., JV to Woodard & Curran, Inc. Commissioner Stacy thanked staff for the childcare lease negotiation. Public Comments & Testimony - Dave Warner (private CFO): expressed concerns that long-standing SFPUC practices limit commissioner influence, financial plans are too high given declining demand, and the agency is hoarding water, contributing to ecological disaster in the Tuolumne River. - Francisco De Costa: criticized the SFPUC for challenging the EPA under the Clean Water Act and wasting taxpayer money on lawsuits; urged regional cooperation and public input before litigation. - Mary Butterwick (longtime resident): opposed the city's Supreme Court case against the EPA; urged the Commission to end the lawsuit and focus on upgrading the combined sewer system; questioned the 8.5-year design drought and need for more in-stream flows for salmon. - Brian Eckert (commercial and recreational salmon fisherman): emphasized the value of the salmon resource and urged the Commission to consider the importance of clean water and adequate flows. - Melina Mackie Cabata (WAC SF, Vision Zero Coalition): called on the SFPUC to recommit to Vision Zero and become a leading agency partner to reduce traffic fatalities; noted 20 pedestrians killed in SF in 2024. - Claire Fram (WAC SF board member): supported Vision Zero and asked the SFPUC to be a partner in street safety. - Jason Foster (Outer Richmond resident): opposed the Supreme Court case seeking to unbind the city from water quality laws; asked the Commission to drop the lawsuit. - Martin Gothberg (consumer of Tuolumne water): criticized the design drought as imaginary and arbitrary; alleged staff ignored climate change data; requested the Commission ask for likelihood analyses. - Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust): welcomed new commissioners; urged reinstatement of commissioner request tracking on the advanced calendar; asked for an update on resolutions regarding biological goals and adaptive management for the Tuolumne Voluntary Agreement; later (during item 6B) said he was denied public records and requested a workshop. - John Rose Peppi (commercial/recreational fisherman and former fisheries biologist): concerned about lawsuits filed on behalf of SFPUC that the Commission had no say in; encouraged new commissioners to investigate policies on lawsuits. - Norma Wallace Galvan (Ohlone descendant, senior homeowner): opposed planned 300% rate increase; urged the Commission to engage with outside experts and scientists. - Lane Peugeot (Sierra Club California): supported the Bay Delta Water Quality Control Plan over voluntary agreements; welcomed new commissioners. - Gloria Barry (District 10): questioned whether new commissioners would maintain business as usual; asked about community benefits on projects. - Joyce (District 10 native): expressed frustration about lack of outreach and negative impacts from SFPUC projects on her community. - Additional speakers during item 13 and committees initiated items raised concerns about the social impact program, lack of accountability, and community harm in Bayview. Discussion Items - 3. Annual Election of Officers: After public comment (including a caller urging re-instatement of request tracking), Commissioner Arce nominated Vice President Stacy for president; seconded and approved 4-0. Commissioner Leveroni was nominated for vice president and approved 4-0. President Stacy and Vice President Arce assumed roles. - 4. Approval of Minutes for September 24, 2024: Approved unanimously. - 5. General Public Comment: As summarized above. - 6. Report of the General Manager - 6a. Wastewater Capital Programs Quarterly Report (Q4, April-June 2024): Bessie Tam presented progress on capital projects, including Southeast Plant power feed (72.3% complete), channel force main intertie, and the Biosolids Digester Facilities (71% construction complete). The Biogas Utilization Project transitioned from public-private partnership to city-led design-build. Commissioner Arce praised the team's progress and community inclusion. General Manager Herrera responded to public comments, noting that staff is working diligently on biological goals for the Bay Delta as part of the voluntary agreement process, and that resolutions from 2017-2018 are being addressed. - 6b. Report on Recent SFPUC Activities: GM Herrera welcomed new commissioners and clarified that direction to staff should go through the proper chain of command. - 7. Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA) Report: CEO Nicole Sankula presented, noting SFPUC's 26 wholesale customers serve 1.8 million residents; wholesale revenue requirement is $332 million for FY2024. She introduced incoming CEO Tom Smegel (former CFO of Cal Water), who committed to focusing on reliable, quality water at fair prices. - 9. Accept Work Performed by JMB Construction (Westside Recycled Water Pump Station): Approved final modification and payment (within contingency). Commissioner Stacy approved. - 10. 10-Year Water Service Contract with U.S. Department of Energy for Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory: Angela Chung presented; estimated revenue $66 million over 10 years. Commissioner Stacy asked about water conservation and drought measures; staff confirmed lab is evaluating water efficiency, with a cooling tower replacement saving 6 million gallons/year and a proposed reclamation project saving 35 million gallons/year. Approved. - 11. Amendment No. 3 to Contract No. PRO.0096 (Mountain Tunnel Improvements Project): Lucas Hoffman requested $9.5 million increase (total $34 million) and 6-month extension for construction management services. Project is 62% complete; reasons include extended hours, multiple sites, and increased environmental compliance. Commissioner Stacy noted the 35% increase and acknowledged project complexity. Approved. - 12. Authorize General Manager to Seek Board of Supervisors Approval to Extend and Increase Delegation of Authority for Power Supply Contracts: Julia O'Geen requested extension until June 30, 2030, and increase of purchase authority from $200M to $300M/year and sales authority from $20M to $300M/year due to rising electricity prices and increased demand. Commissioner Arce strongly supported the flexibility. Approved. - 13. Award Contract No. DB-138 to PCL Construction (Biogas Utilization Project): Daniela Brendau presented a $121.5 million design-build contract for converting biogas to renewable natural gas. Commissioner Arce raised concerns about PCL's past PLA compliance at Treasure Island; GM Herrera confirmed issues were addressed in the bid. Commissioner Leveroni asked about revenue and technical details (flare gas, tail gas). Public comment criticized lack of community benefits and outreach. Commissioner Stacy requested a presentation at an upcoming community meeting. Approved. - 14. Increase of $385,000 for Contract No. WW-739 (Large Diameter Sewer Cleaning): Carmen Luke requested increase due to urgent work at Oceanside Treatment Plant. Approved. - 16. Items Initiated by Commissioners: - Commissioner Jamdar requested an update on community benefits outcomes; Assistant GM Masood Ordokhani described a public dashboard and new self-registration registry for nonprofits. - Commissioner Arce expressed support for the agency, PLAs, CleanPowerSF, and addressing housing crisis. - Commissioner Stacy requested a future agenda item on the Bay Delta Water Quality Control Plan update. - 18-21. Closed Session: The Commission asserted attorney-client privilege, then in closed session recommended settlements in two cases (Arthur Bailey Jr. v. City and County of San Francisco; Stern Grove Festival Association v. City and County of San Francisco). After reconvening, the Commission voted not to disclose discussions. Key Outcomes - Elections: President Stacy and Vice President Arce elected unanimously. - All consent calendar items (8A-8H) and regular calendar items (9-14) approved unanimously (4-0). - Directives: - Staff to provide an update on Bay Delta Water Quality Control Plan at a future meeting. - Community benefits program transparency: Assistant GM described dashboard and self-registration process; commissioners noted public concerns. - Closed Session: Settlements recommended for two pending cases; discussion not disclosed. - Next Steps: The Commission will hold future meetings as scheduled; community meeting on Biosolids/Biogas project announced for October 23 in Bayview.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on October 21, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Myrna Melgar, with President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston present. The committee considered four items: acceptance of DeLong Street right-of-way, interim zoning controls for legacy businesses, a commemorative street name for Joe Rosenthal Way, and an e-bike incentive fund. All items were unanimously recommended to the full Board of Supervisors. Item 1: DeLong Street Public Right-of-Way Acceptance Esther Lee from Supervisor Safai's office presented an ordinance to accept a segment of DeLong Street for city maintenance, establishing official sidewalk widths and street grades. The process began in 2006 when Habitat for Humanity developed homes; BART offered the property with $75,000 for surveying, and the CTA allocated $350,000 from a Prop K grant (approved September 24, 2024) for construction. Non-substantive amendments were made to reflect a letter of support from the Director of Public Works. No public speakers. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to amend and recommend the ordinance to the full board. Item 2: Interim Zoning Controls – Legacy Businesses President Peskin introduced a resolution imposing 18-month interim zoning controls requiring conditional use authorization before replacing a legacy business in neighborhood commercial districts. He cited threats from upzoning, noting the closure of Sushi Tenichi (46 years) and risk to Cafe La Méditerranée on Upper Fillmore after a billionaire landlord purchased multiple properties. The resolution was co-sponsored by supervisors Chan, Walton, Ronen, Preston, and Melgar. Public comment included: - Vanik Der Bedrosian (2nd generation owner, La Méditerranée) expressed support, saying the legislation would "level the playing field." - Sean Keem (owner, Joe's Ice Cream, 65 years) and his daughter Ari Kim spoke of uncertainty due to a developer-owned building with plans for a 40–60 unit project. - Kristen Evans and Yolanda Prada (Small Business Forward) supported but urged expansion to neighborhood-serving businesses. - Monica Morse, Art Persico, and Peter Papadopoulos (MEDA) also supported. - Richard Carrillo (Legacy Business Program staff) remained neutral. Supervisor Preston criticized the planning department for not bringing protections alongside upzoning, calling it "reckless disregard for known risks." Supervisor Melgar noted her request for a BLA study on upzoning impacts and stressed the need for broader support. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend the resolution as a committee report to the full board. Item 3: Commemorative Street Name – Joe Rosenthal Way President Peskin presented a resolution to name the 600 block of Sutter Street (outside the Marines Memorial Club) as "Joe Rosenthal Way," honoring the Associated Press photographer who captured the iconic Iwo Jima flag-raising in 1945. Rosenthal later worked 35 years at the San Francisco Chronicle. Letters of support from AP archives were noted. Speakers included: - Former State Senator Quentin Kopp urged adoption. - Tom Graves (idea originator) said the photo is "the most reproduced photograph in history." - Retired Lt. Gen. Mike Rocco (CEO, Marines Memorial) emphasized the mission to educate and commemorate. - Don Reed (Korean War Marine) and Maj. Gen. Mike Myatt shared personal recollections. An amendment corrected the bond amount from $2 billion to $26 billion. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to amend and recommend. Item 4: E-Bike Incentive Fund President Peskin introduced an ordinance to establish an e-bike incentive fund administered by the Department of the Environment, modeled after programs in Denver, Austin, and Atlanta. Luke Bornheimer (Streets Forward) presented slides showing e-bikes can reduce car vehicle miles traveled by 44% and noted Denver had 15,000 applicants. The program prioritizes low-income residents, families, cargo bikes, and accessible bikes. Public comment included: - Kyle Woodward (District 7 resident) said e-bikes made his family more active and civically engaged. - Trevor Burke (Richmond resident) supported for climate benefits. - Claire Moblane (SF Bicycle Coalition) supported but raised concerns about safe parking, education, and infrastructure. Supervisors Melgar and Preston voiced support, linking to delivery bike incentives and safe routes to school. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend the ordinance to the full board. Key Outcomes All four items passed unanimously and were recommended to the Board of Supervisors for the October 29, 2024 meeting. Amendments were adopted for Items 1 and 3. The committee expressed intent to continue developing broader small business protections and funding for the e-bike program.
The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, October 17, 2024, starting at 12:00 p.m. and concluding after 7:30 p.m. The agenda included 17 items, covering consent calendar approvals, conditional use authorizations, planning code amendments, informational presentations, and discretionary reviews. The Commission approved several projects and continued controversial items to future dates. Consent Calendar - Item 2 (5214 Diamond Heights Blvd): Approved with conditions unanimously (6-0) for a change of use from a Laundromat to a Formula Retail Gym (Club Pilates). - Item 3 (1337 Mission Street): Pulled from consent due to a request from Teamsters Joint Council 7 seeking a continuance; continued to October 24, 2024 unanimously (6-0). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Speaker criticized Planning Department’s implementation of Section 317 regarding soundness and demolition calculations, urging a public hearing to adjust values. Another speaker requested city consideration of purchasing a parking lot at Cosmo Place for public green space in Lower Nob Hill. - Item 8 (BMR Price and Income Limits): Supervisor Melgar and MOHCD staff explained the ordinance to address discrepancies in older BMR units. Public comment included support from the Jansook family (affected homeowners), opposition from Tenant Union representatives urging strict limits, and concerns from the Council of Community Housing Organizations about preserving affordability. - Item 9 (Unauthorized Dwelling Units): Supervisor Melgar presented the ordinance. Architects and the American Institute of Architects (AIA) expressed concerns about liability and standard of care, requesting a continuance. Tenant advocates and community members supported the ordinance as written. - Item 11 (777 Sutter Street): Multiple residents from Lower Nob Hill opposed the 26-story project, citing out-of-scale height, loss of light, and incompatibility with the historic district. The Building Trades Council supported the project for its labor protections and affordable units. - Item 12 (3333 California Street): Supporters included the Jewish Community Center, neighbors, and labor representatives who highlighted the need for housing and the EIFD financing mechanism. The Laurel Heights Improvement Association raised concerns about open space depictions in the amended development agreement. - Item 14 (229-233 Whitney Street): Neighbors testified against the project, citing loss of light and privacy from new construction, and alleged bad faith negotiations and illegal demolition of three rent-controlled units. - Item 15 (1310 Junipero Serra Blvd): St. Thomas More School parents, faculty, and community members opposed the maintenance facility’s proximity (20 feet) to the preschool, citing health, safety, and noise concerns. SEIU supported the project for improved working conditions. - Item 16 (5114-5116 3rd Street): Supporters from the Bayview community praised the owner’s commitment to revitalization and the project’s enhancement of family housing. - Item 17 (1329 Bay Street): Neighbors raised concerns about property line windows and loss of light, but did not assert exceptional circumstances. Discussion Items - Item 1a/1b (Central Soma Commercial Development): Continued to October 24, 2024. - Item 8 (BMR Price and Income Limits): After debate on AMI increases and delegation of authority, the Commission approved with modifications including a 10-unit trigger for report-back and delegation to staff. Vote: 5-1 (Moore opposed). - Item 9 (Unauthorized Dwelling Units): Approved with modifications recommended by staff, including use of DBI’s ECC program, 10-year UDU definition, and significant misrepresentation standard. Vote: 6-0. - Item 10 (915 Bryant Street): Informational presentation for a 10-unit SB 423 project. No action taken. - Item 11 (777 Sutter Street): Informational presentation for a 36-unit SB 423 project with 25% affordable units. Commissioners expressed concerns about height and design but acknowledged state streamlining. - Item 12 (3333 California Street): Approved modifications to the development agreement, including an EIFD, reduced affordable senior units (125 units), and fee reductions. Vote: 6-0. - Item 13 (700 Innes Avenue - India Basin): Approved amendments to Design Standards and Guidelines to allow small lot homes (150 units) in the flats, accelerating infrastructure and affordable housing. Vote: 6-0. - Item 14 (229-233 Whitney Street): Motion of intent to disapprove and continue to October 24, 2024, with direction to address neighbor concerns on light, privacy, and setbacks. Vote: 6-0. - Item 15 (1310 Junipero Serra Blvd): Continued to January 9, 2025, to explore alternative locations or greater setbacks, with direction to include school stakeholders. Vote: 6-0. - Item 16 (5114-5116 3rd Street): Approved conditional use authorization and variance to legalize a replacement accessory building after unauthorized demolition. Note: Zoning Administrator will issue a separate variance decision. Vote: 4-2 (Moore and So opposed). - Item 17 (1329 Bay Street): Did not take discretionary review and approved the building permit for a fourth-story addition with property line windows. Vote: 6-0. Key Outcomes - Item 2: Approved with conditions. - Item 3: Continued to October 24, 2024. - Item 8: Approved with modifications (5-1). - Item 9: Approved with modifications (6-0). - Item 12: Approved (6-0). - Item 13: Approved (6-0). - Item 14: Motion of intent to disapprove, continued to October 24, 2024. - Item 15: Continued to January 9, 2025. - Item 16: Approved (4-2); variance under advisement. - Item 17: Did not take discretionary review; project approved. - General: All continuances and motions passed unanimously unless noted.
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee met on October 17, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston. The committee considered three major items: a pilot program offering cash incentives for sobriety, a grocery store closure notification ordinance, and a hearing on oversight failures in city departments. Consent calendar items covering litigation settlements were also approved. Cash Not Drugs Sobriety and Recovery Pilot Program (Item 240799) Supervisor Dorsey introduced an ordinance authorizing a three-year voluntary pilot program called "Cash Not Drugs." The program would offer eligible CAP (County Adult Assistance Program) recipients up to $100 per week for testing negative for illicit drugs, as a contingency management strategy for substance use disorder treatment. The Human Services Agency (HSA) and Department of Public Health (DPH) would implement the program after a six-month planning period. Public Comments & Testimony: - Zach Fournette (Episcopal Community Services) expressed full support based on lived experience. - H. Brown advocated for drug legalization and criticized punitive approaches. - A black community member called for inclusivity and representation in program design. - Dennis Williams (Fillmore CDC) supported the program, citing past negative impacts of "Care Not Cash." - Billy Lemon (Castro Country Club) shared personal success with contingency management, crediting it for his sobriety. - Other speakers emphasized the need for spiritual and trauma-informed approaches. Discussion: Susie Smith (HSA) explained the program's integration with Prop F, which requires CAP recipients to engage in treatment. The Budget Legislative Analyst (BLA) estimated costs between $220,000 and $1.2 million per year based on scale (50-150 participants, 12-24 week durations). The program is contingent on funding, with potential sources including general fund, Prop C mental health funds, or Medi-Cal (limited to stimulant use disorders). Supervisor Dorsey noted the legislation intentionally avoids over-prescription, leaving design to experts. He confirmed the $100 weekly maximum was aspirational and aligned with existing DPH contingency management programs ($300-$599 per cycle). Key Outcomes: Chair Preston added as co-sponsor. The committee voted 2-0 to forward the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Neighborhood Grocery Protection Act (Item 240333) Supervisor Preston introduced an ordinance requiring large supermarkets (20,000+ sq ft with food preparation) to provide six months' notice before permanent closure, hold community meetings, and explore replacement markets. The legislation responds to Safeway's abrupt closure announcement at Fillmore and Webster Street. Public Comments & Testimony: - Alice Kawahat (Japan Town Task Force) applauded the ordinance but noted it came too late for the Safeway closure, urging community outreach from developers. - Jeremy Chan (Japan Town Task Force) emphasized the store's role in festivals and daily needs. - Multiple speakers criticized the closure and lack of community engagement, with some demanding affordable housing and grocery services on the site. - Others called for inclusive development and support for black businesses. - Howard Smith urged collaboration between the mayor and board. Discussion: Supervisor Preston circulated amendments adding HSA to notification recipients and clarifying enforcement provisions. Deputy City Attorney Ann Pearson was thanked for drafting. OEWD's memo raised concerns about definition scope, but DPH Assistant Director Jen Calahor confirmed the ordinance targets supermarkets with food preparation, excluding retailers like movie theaters. Preston rejected OEWD's suggestion to tie formula retail restrictions to this ordinance, stating it is outside scope. The mayor's office was criticized for reportedly blocking a Community Opportunity to Purchase Act request for the site. Key Outcomes: The committee voted 2-0 to adopt the amendments and forward the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Hearing on Lack of Oversight of Fraudulent Activities (Item 240914) President Peskin convened a hearing to examine oversight failures in executive branch departments (SFPD, HRC) and the Dreamkeeper Initiative (DKI). The hearing focused on allegations of mismanagement at the Human Rights Commission (HRC) and systemic reforms needed. Public Comments & Testimony: - Numerous speakers defended Dr. Sheryl Davis and the Dreamkeeper Initiative, highlighting its positive impact on black-led organizations, arts, workforce training, and mental health services. - Many urged the release of paused funds, citing severe disruptions to services and potential layoffs. - Some speakers criticized the hearing as a political attack during an election year. - A few speakers raised concerns about exclusion of African immigrants and lack of a designated bereavement center. - Latinx leaders (Latino Task Force) expressed solidarity with the black community. Discussion: - Controller Greg Wagner reported the controller's office is conducting audits of HRC's Prop Q purchases and grant agreements with collective impact. Prop Q delegation has been rescinded. He noted a 2023 post-audit identified seven high-risk findings, including payments without sufficient documentation, and HRC had responded with corrective actions but lacked segregation of duties. - Dr. Paula Jones (DPH) described DKI-funded programs: 200 individuals in birthing justice, 358 perinatal appointments, 69 lactation trainees, mental health services for 1,000 clients, and life coaches for 79 individuals. DPH's funding dropped from $15 million to $1.7 million in FY24-25 after funds were reallocated to HRC. She confirmed prior year funds were returned to the general fund. - Sarah Dennis Phillips (OEWD) reported workforce training (592 enrollments, 558 completions, 94% rate) and small business support (300 new entrepreneurs, 193 businesses). OEWD is delaying its RFP until winter 2025 pending an impact report and implementing a performance improvement notification process. No irregularities were flagged with collective impact contracts. - Mawoli Togbenyo (Acting Director, HRC) outlined reforms: suspending discretionary spending, retraining staff on Prop Q, restructuring financial division, and pausing new contracts. He stated active contracts continue. He could not provide a timeline for lifting the pause but emphasized urgency. The mayor appointed him after Dr. Davis's departure. He confirmed the CFO role was filled only seven months ago; previous requests for more oversight resources are unknown. - President Peskin pressed for answers on the mayor's oversight of Dr. Davis and asked to continue the hearing. Key Outcomes: The committee voted 2-0 to continue the hearing to the call of the chair. No further action was taken pending ongoing audits and investigations. Consent Calendar: Litigation Settlements (Items 4-13) The committee considered closed session items for settlements and claims, including: - Settlement with San Francisco Apartment Association et al. - $93,000 - Three settlements with Park Hotels & Resorts Inc. - stipulated assessed values and refunds totaling approximately $3.4 million - Settlement with Maplebear, Inc. (unlitigated) - $8,250,342.21 - Settlement with Bechtel Group, Inc. (unlitigated) - $43,235.10 - Settlement for stolen property claim - Brian McSharry - not to exceed $2,117.88 - Settlements of lawsuits: Yulanda Williams - $625,000; Jane Doe - $200,000; Barnard Jones and Patricia Farrell - $475,000 Chair Preston determined that a closed session was unnecessary after questions were answered, and public comment yielded no speakers. The committee voted 2-0 to forward items 4-9 and 11-13 with positive recommendations to the Board of Supervisors, and item 10 (Bechtel) as a committee report for the October 22 board meeting. Key Outcomes - The committee forwarded two ordinances to the full board with positive recommendations (Cash Not Drugs and Neighborhood Grocery Protection Act). - The hearing on oversight failures was continued to the call of the chair. - Settlement and litigation items were approved as consent calendar. - The committee adjourned.
The San Francisco Police Commission met on October 16, 2024, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included an In Memoriam tribute, public comment, approval of a consent calendar, reports from the Chief and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), commission reports, a presentation on DPA’s DataSF transparency initiative, and a detailed discussion regarding the dissolution of SF SAFE and the status of its former programs. The meeting also included a closed session (Item 11) and a vote on disclosure of that session. Consent Calendar - Donations accepted: The Commission voted unanimously to receive and file three donations from the San Francisco Police Community Foundation: $10,000 for Tenderloin District Station, $20,000 for Northern Station, and $25,000 for Southern Station. Public Comments & Testimony - In Memoriam Public Comment: Jeannie Nielsen, widow of Sergeant Rennie Nielsen, spoke about her husband’s mental health struggles and suicide, urging the department to provide proactive mental health support and reconsider the practice of immediately disarming officers in crisis. - General Public Comment (Item 2): - Chris Sword Klein raised concerns about the BitFocus/One System homeless management information system, alleging it could be used to manipulate individuals and influence police interactions. He requested that the city investigate its use in every DPA case and shooting incident. - A mother of a murdered son (Aubrey Abacasa) expressed frustration over lack of progress in her son’s case and named individuals she believes are involved. She also criticized the city’s handling of mental health issues for victims’ families. - Public comment on Chief’s Report: The same mother reiterated her frustration and asked for help. - No public comment on other items (DPA report, Commission reports, DataSF presentation, SF SAFE presentation). Discussion Items - Chief’s Report (Item 4): Chief Bill Scott reported a 32% decrease in all Part 1 serious crimes year-to-date compared to the previous year (about 14,000 fewer crimes). Violent crime was down 14%, property crime down 34%, and car break-ins down 57% (nearly 10,000 fewer incidents). Gun-related homicides were down 38% (18 year-to-date vs. 29 last year), and total homicides were down 42% (25 vs. 43). He also noted: - A new homicide ruling from an August 11 incident (victim died October 4) – suspect punched victim, causing fatal fall; investigation ongoing. - Homicide arrests made in a earlier case at 16th and Mission. - A non-fatal shooting on October 12 (victim uncooperative). - Significant narcotics and firearms arrests by the narcotics unit. - A Union Square incident where a car was driven into the Dior store (October 11); suspects fled, leads being pursued. - Fleet Week had no critical incidents. - A fatal traffic collision on October 15 involving a motorcyclist. - DPA Director’s Report (Item 5): Acting Executive Director Diana Rosenstein reported that the DPA opened 16 new cases and closed 13. Year-to-date, they have sustained 46 cases, with 118 sustained cases pending before the Chief and 9 pending before the Commission. The Stop Data Audit exit interview is scheduled for October 28. - Commission Reports (Item 6): - Commissioner Walker noted concerns from the Candlestick Community Alliance and Hunters Point Shipyard artists about coordination between SFPD, the Port, and other agencies regarding security and parking restrictions. She will investigate and report back. - Commissioner Yanyez discussed the juvenile DGO (Department General Order) 701, noting community organizations submitted recommendations. Chief Scott said the department is reviewing legal issues and language nuances, with a focus on consistency with state law. Commissioner Yanyez also requested metrics for community policing, referencing the 2018 strategic plan, and will work with the Community Engagement Division to develop a plan before the DGO vote. - Presentation of DPA’s DataSF Charts (Item 7): Nicole Armstrong (Director of Operations) and Eric Ho (IT Director) presented the DPA annual report and a new public data sharing initiative. The data portal, launching Friday, will provide weekly updates on case openings, closures, allegations, findings, and demographics, with interactive dashboards. The DPA also highlighted its award-winning audit work, policy recommendations, and successful internship program (12 field trips, 22 guest speakers in 2023). - Presentation on SF SAFE and Neighborhood Safety Team (Item 8): - Captain Aaron Perry (Community Engagement) presented the new Neighborhood Safety Team (NST), which took over from SF SAFE in February 2024. Services include neighborhood watch, security surveys, safety presentations, community policing events (e.g., National Night Out, victim walks). The team currently has one sergeant and four officers, with a full-time professional hire expected soon. Cameras previously handled by SF SAFE are now owned by vendor Applied Video Solutions (AVS); SFPD is evaluating whether to purchase or subscribe to the service. - Director Ryan Cow (Crime Strategies) confirmed that AVS owns the cameras and SFPD is assessing the proposal alongside other Prop E technology commitments. - Commissioner Carter-Oberstone led extensive questioning about the SF SAFE scandal: He noted that SF SAFE’s board was half SFPD employees, that the department was unaware of red flags despite internal audits, that SFPD attended lavish parties (e.g., $228,105 on gift boxes for a February 2022 event), and that the department did not request receipts for reimbursements. Chief Scott stated that SFPD had no role in hiring or vetting SF SAFE staff, that they first learned of nonpayment in early 2023, and that they requested the controller’s audit in June 2023 after meeting with a vendor. He said the department has implemented safeguards: working with the controller’s office, joint monitoring visits, and new grant management staff. However, he resisted committing to seek documents from the District Attorney or court enforcement to recover financial records, citing the ongoing criminal investigation. Commissioner Clay and Commissioner Walker emphasized the need for oversight and accountability. Commissioner Vice President Carter-Oberstone expressed frustration that the department appeared hesitant to fully investigate the $5.3 million in grants. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar approved (unanimous vote). - No votes on other discussion items; they were for discussion and presentation only. - Closed Session (Item 11): The Commission voted to hold Item 11 in closed session (Item 10) and later voted not to disclose any discussion from that closed session (Item 12). - Next Steps: - Commissioner Walker will investigate security coordination at Candlestick/Hunters Point. - Commissioner Yanyez will work with the Community Engagement Division on metrics for community policing before the DGO vote (expected in November). - DPA’s DataSF portal will go live on Friday, October 18, 2024, with weekly updates. - SFPD will continue evaluating the AVS camera proposal and will implement grant monitoring safeguards as discussed.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a special meeting on Tuesday, October 15, 2024, at 10:15 AM. The meeting was called to order with a roll call showing 10 supervisors present (Supervisor Stephanie was excused). The board voted on five ordinances and heard public comments on each. Introductions included new legislation and resolutions. All items passed unanimously. Public Comments - Item 1 (Operational Elevators): Amina Rubio (District 3 resident) supported the ordinance, citing safety concerns for elderly residents trapped in buildings with broken elevators. - Item 2 (Entertainment Zones): Leah McGeever (District 6) opposed, criticizing the city's priorities toward entertainment over housing and basic needs. Andrew Bennett (President of IATSE Local 16) supported, noting the need for a vibrant city and asking that workers be included in planning. - Item 3 (Gas Infrastructure for EPCA Appliances): Amina Rubio spoke in favor but asked that tenants not bear the costs of new appliances, noting unequal access between market-rate and non-market-rate units. - Item 4 (Rent Control Exemption): Multiple speakers supported the expansion: Fred Sherburn Zimmer (Housing Rights Committee), Keen Chiquinetta (Jobs with Justice SF), Teresa Dulales (SomCAN), and others argued rent control protects tenants from displacement. One speaker, Richard S.D. Peterson, opposed, citing difficulties evicting non-paying tenants under current rent control. - Item 5 (OVWR & SHARP): Leah McGeever expressed distrust of the board's ability to handle sexual assault legislation. Joy Zann (San Francisco Youth Commission) supported the ordinance, emphasizing confidentiality and youth access. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Housing Code – Operational Elevators: Ordinance to require R1 and R2 buildings to maintain at least one elevator for resident use. Passed 10-0. - Item 2 – Administrative Code – Entertainment Zones: Created two entertainment zones: Mid-Market (Market Street between 5th and 6th Streets) and Arena (near Chase Center). Passed unanimously. - Item 3 – Building Code – Gas Infrastructure for EPCA Appliances: Allowed new construction meeting electricity-ready guidelines to install gas infrastructure for appliances covered by the Energy Policy and Conservation Act. Passed unanimously. - Item 4 – Administrative Code – New Construction Exemption from Rent Control: Provided that new units built between June 14, 1979, and June 13, 1994, would be subject to rent control if Costa Hawkins is repealed or modified. Passed unanimously. - Item 5 – Administrative Code – Clarifying Duties of OVWR; Moving SHARP to OVWR: Consolidated the Office of Victim and Witness Rights and the Office of Sexual Harassment and Assault Response and Prevention, adding trauma-informed assistance requirements. Passed unanimously. Legislation Introduced & Resolutions - Supervisor Melgar: Introduced a formal request for a performance and management audit of the San Francisco Zoo (citing concerns about conditions and animal/worker safety) and an ordinance to allow more flexible window replacement standards for homeowners. - Supervisor Preston: Introduced a resolution in support of Proposition 6 (ending forced labor in California prisons). - Supervisor Ronan: Introduced legislation requiring the city's Chief Information Officer to create a public inventory of AI systems used by the city, conduct AI impact assessments, and establish procurement standards. The aim is to increase transparency and regulate AI before harms occur. - Supervisor Safai: Added his name as co-sponsor of the zoo audit. Key Outcomes - All five ordinances were finally passed. Item 1 had a recorded roll call vote of 10-0; items 2–5 were passed on a single roll call vote (same house, same call). - The board accepted the introductions, which will proceed to committee. - No public comments were made on introductions. - The meeting adjourned.
This special meeting of the Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors was held on October 11, 2024, at 6:15 PM. Chair Dean Preston and Supervisor Connie Chan were present; Vice Chair Stephanie was excused. The committee considered two agenda items: a resolution to extend the behested payment waiver for homeless services fundraising, and a hearing on the Controller's assessment of invoices for the San Francisco Police Department's contract with SF SAFE. Public Comments & Testimony On Item 1 (Behested Payment Waiver): - Daniel Jeremiah Hoffman expressed support for public housing but opposed the use of homeless individuals as leverage to coerce private donations, arguing that funds should come from taxation. He also criticized the lack of outcomes in homeless programs. - A speaker named Ace (self-identified as a former homeless individual) questioned whether homeless individuals are from other cities and expressed concern about the city's open-door policies. - Dennis Williams supported the waiver but called for better conditions in temporary shelters and more involvement of local grassroots organizations and contractors. On Item 2 (SF SAFE Invoice Assessment): - Ace reiterated calls for community reform and criticized corruption within city government. - Another speaker urged the committee to direct funding to Black-led community organizations and noted that many nonprofits had misrepresented their work. - Daniel Jeremiah Hoffman referenced his recent article on the topic and argued that police-community partnerships can lead to discrimination and concentration of poverty; he offered his expertise to help address corruption. Discussion Items Item 1: Temporary Shelter and Homeless Services - Behested Payment Waiver - Director Shereen McSpadden of the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH) requested a six-month extension of the waiver (current waiver expires October 17, 2024). She reported that since the previous waiver, the city had engaged with several foundations (Crankstart, Tipping Point, U.S. Aging, Schwab Foundation, Keith Geislin) but only one concrete donation had been secured: $350,000 from Crankstart for Raphael House, a family shelter that had never before received city funds. McSpadden noted that the waiver enables relationship-building and future grants. She also highlighted that the 2024 point-in-time count showed 8,323 homeless individuals, 52% unsheltered, and that HSH has 3,610 shelter/crisis slots at 92% occupancy. The waiver is needed to support the city's strategic goal of adding 1,075 new shelter beds. - Supervisor Preston expressed disappointment that only $350,000 had been raised given the wealth of the entities listed, and questioned the lack of an overall fundraising goal. He stressed the importance of transparency and conflict-of-interest oversight. He suggested that future renewals should include clearer goals and metrics. - Supervisor Chan asked about efforts to bring in private money for permanent affordable housing, not just shelters; McSpadden replied that conversations with Schwab about transitional housing could flow to permanent housing. Chan indicated her support for the extension but asked for more transparent reporting. - The committee adopted an amendment adding a "whereas" clause to reference a memo on philanthropic engagement. Item 2: Hearing - Assessment of Invoices for San Francisco SAFE - President Peskin, the lead sponsor, opened the hearing by noting that the Controller's January 2024 audit had found widespread problems in the SFPD's oversight of its grant with SF SAFE. He criticized the city's culture of tolerating corruption and emphasized the need for robust internal controls and accountability. He stated that subpoenas had been authorized for former SF SAFE board members (Dan Lawson and Tom Yee) and that the hearing would be continued to allow for their testimony. - Mark Delarosa (Controller's Office, City Services Auditor) summarized the audit's scope (July 2022 – March 2024) and the single recommendation: that SFPD conduct a forensic look-back at all invoices prior to that period. He confirmed that the six-month follow-up was due October 2, 2024, but that SFPD had not yet submitted a response as of the hearing date. - SFPD representatives (Assistant Chief Lazar, Executive Director Catherine McGuire, new CFO Kimmy Wu, and Director of Policy Diana Roche) described the department's internal reorganization after the scandal. They stated that they had requested a full audit from the Controller but only received a limited assessment; that they have since hired a new CFO and are creating a Neighborhood Safety Team to continue the legitimate work SF SAFE had performed. They admitted to staffing shortages in fiscal oversight previously. McGuire claimed that an extension to respond to the audit recommendation had been granted until October 11, 2024, and that the response would be submitted after the hearing. President Peskin challenged this, noting that the Controller's office had not been informed. The department outlined new internal policies: using Controller standards, requiring detailed documentation, and implementing joint monitoring for multi-agency nonprofits. - OEWD Executive Director Sarah Dennis Phillips explained that OEWD had two contracts with SF SAFE, that their review found no fraudulent invoices, but that SF SAFE had failed to pay about $78,000 to employees and two sub-consultants. She confirmed that OEWD had withheld $83,000 in payment and is seeking a legal mechanism to compensate workers. - Supervisor Chan requested copies of the grant agreements, amendments, RFP scoring sheets, and performance audit reports to understand the history of the contract and how SF SAFE repeatedly won bids. - Supervisor Preston asked about the status of the crime prevention services previously provided by SF SAFE; SFPD confirmed they are now handled in-house by a single retired officer and an email (neighborhoodsafety@sfgov.org), and plan to hire more staff if budget allows. Preston requested periodic reports on service delivery. - President Peskin made impassioned remarks about the need to change the culture of corruption and called for all departments to proactively address red flags. He noted that the District Attorney's complaint (July 2024) showed that SF SAFE's board had been warned by three different auditors since 2019, yet SFPD and OEWD did not act. Key Outcomes - Item 1: The committee voted 2–0 (with Vice Chair excused) to adopt the amendment and forward the resolution to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Item 2: The committee voted 2–0 to continue the hearing to the November 7, 2024, GAO meeting, at which time subpoenas for former SF SAFE board members Dan Lawson and Tom Yee will be returnable. The Controller's Office and SFPD will provide status updates on the delayed audit recommendations. The City Attorney's office was directed to issue the subpoenas.
The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, October 10, 2024, to consider continuances, consent calendar items, commission matters, department reports, general public comment, and three regular calendar items. Commissioner Braun was absent; all other commissioners were present. The meeting covered a BMR homeownership policy amendment, a conditional use for demolition and new construction at 613 Wisconsin Street, and a cannabis cultivation facility at 1719 Wallace Avenue. Consent Calendar - Items 3 and 4 were approved unanimously (6-0). - Item 3 (100 California Street) requested Conditional Use Authorization to change the ground floor and basement from a gym to office use. - Item 4 (135 Kissling Street) requested Conditional Use Authorization to convert an approximately 12,000-square-foot warehouse into a vehicle storage garage. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Georgia Shootish spoke about a recently sold property on Diamond Street, alleging it was a de facto demolition that bypassed Section 317 review. They urged adjustments to demolition calculations and cited Noe Valley as an "epicenter of de facto demolition." - Item 10 (BMR ordinance): Simon and Emmy Jansuk, owners of a below-market-rate (BMR) condominium at 270 Valencia Street Unit 201, described their two-year struggle to sell their unit, stating they bought in 2018 without disclosure of the affordable resale price. They supported the ordinance, noting they would suffer financial ruin without it. Jennifer Rosdale, their real estate agent, also supported, noting they were selling $65,000 above the affordable price to avoid a short sale. Calvin Welch, a former member of the inclusionary zoning task force, opposed, arguing that increasing AMI limits makes the program less affordable and undermines the original intent. - Item 11 (613 Wisconsin Street): Neighbors opposed the project, including Noel and Jeannie McMichael (615 Wisconsin), who cited scale and privacy concerns; Jacques Rossetti (611 Wisconsin), who raised groundwater and flooding risks; and Bill Baldavich and Janice Lipson (522 Arkansas), who opposed the massing, environmental impacts, and loss of neighborhood character. - Item 12 (1719 Wallace Avenue): Multiple community members opposed the cannabis cultivation, citing safety concerns, oversaturation of cannabis facilities in Bayview, lack of community benefit, and distrust of the process. One speaker noted that nearly 400 neighbors opposed the project. Discussion Items - Item 5 (Land Acknowledgement): The commission read the Ramaytush Ohlone land acknowledgement. - Item 6 (Minutes): Draft minutes for September 19 and September 26, 2024 were adopted unanimously (6-0). - Item 7 (Commission Comments/Questions): Commissioner Williams read a letter from community organizations requesting that the hearing for 2588 Mission Street be held in the Mission community to allow meaningful participation. Commissioner Moore announced Governor Newsom's plan for 100% affordable housing (375 units) on the DMV site. Discussion also involved a 311 notification letter; commissioners requested to be copied on future notifications. - Item 8 (Director's Announcements): None. - Item 9 (Review of Past Events): Aaron Starr reported on the Board of Supervisors' Land Use Committee: an ordinance to waive fees for the Mosaic Stairway advanced, and an ordinance to eliminate the 1% public art requirement for 100% affordable housing moved forward. Corey Teague reported that the Board of Appeals approved updated findings for the Irish Cultural Center's coastal permit. - Item 10 (BMR Ordinance): Staff and MOHCD presented a proposed ordinance to allow a waiver for BMR units purchased above the affordable resale price, increasing the resale price up to 130% of AMI and expanding the buyer pool up to 150% of AMI. Concerns were raised about affordability and the need for sunset provisions. An initial motion to approve with modifications failed 3-3; a subsequent motion to continue the item to the next week passed 5-1. - Item 11 (613 Wisconsin Street): The project sponsor and architect presented a proposal to demolish a two-story single-family residence and construct a four-story home. The project would be below the 40-foot height limit. The sponsor agreed to a two-foot height reduction. Concerns about sound housing demolition and neighborhood impacts were discussed. The commission approved the project with conditions. - Item 12 (1719 Wallace Avenue): Staff and the project sponsor presented a proposal for cannabis cultivation in an industrial warehouse. The project includes carbon filtration for odor control and 24/7 security. Public opposition cited oversaturation and safety. The commission approved with conditions. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Unauthorized and Rent-Controlled Dwelling Units) was continued to October 17, 2024. - Item 2 (1101-1123 Sutter Street) was continued to November 7, 2024. - Item 13 (428 Collingwood Street) was withdrawn. - Items 3 and 4 were approved unanimously on the consent calendar. - Minutes for September 19 and September 26, 2024 were adopted unanimously. - Item 10 (BMR Ordinance) was continued to the October 17, 2024 hearing by a vote of 5-1. - Item 11 (613 Wisconsin Street) was approved 5-1, with a condition requiring a two-foot reduction in overall building height. - Item 12 (1719 Wallace Avenue) was approved 5-1, with conditions including carbon filtration and security measures. The commission agreed to take up the Mission Street hearing request in an officers' meeting and to add commissioners to 311 notification lists.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, October 10, 2024, at 6:00 PM. Chair Supervisor Catherine Stephanie presided, joined by Vice Chair Guardio and Supervisor Dorsey. The committee considered three liquor license applications (one transfer and two issuances), all of which received no public comments and were unanimously approved with conditions. An additional item under the 30-Day Rule (Police Code – Public Bath Houses, File 240966) was listed on the agenda but was not discussed. Discussion Items Item 1: Liquor License Transfer – Neck of the Woods (406 Clement Street) - The San Francisco Police Department ABC Licensing Unit reported the application from Urban Life Inc. for a Type 90 on-sale general music venue license. The premises are in a high-crime area (plot 722B) and high-concentration census tract 401.00. There were zero letters of protest or support. The ALU recommended approval with conditions: noise must not be audible beyond the premises, active monitoring to prevent loitering, litter maintenance, and two uniformed security guards during live entertainment. The District 1 office expressed no opposition. The committee voted 3-0 to forward a positive recommendation to the full Board. Item 2: Liquor License Issuance – Eve Nightclub (1535 Folsom Street) - The application from Goth Inc. for a Type 90 on-sale general music venue license was presented. The premises are in a high-crime area (plot 204B) and high-concentration census tract 177.00, with zero letters of protest or support. Southern Station had no opposition. The ALU recommended the same set of conditions as Item 1. Applicant representative Gemma Jarell Lester explained the owner seeks to transition from a Type 48 license to serve all-ages events, corporate functions, and college organizations. Supervisor Dorsey (District 6) expressed strong support, citing the corridor’s nightlife history and streetscaping plans. The committee voted 3-0 to forward a positive recommendation. Item 3: Liquor License Issuance – The Nosh Box (1116 Folsom Street) - The application from Lamont Juiced LLC for a Type 42 on-sale beer and wine license was presented. The premises are in a high-crime area (plot 232A) and high-concentration census tract 178.04, with zero letters of protest or support. Southern Station had no opposition. One condition was noted (presumably identical to the standard set). Co-owner Stephen Wade, also a District 6 resident, emphasized collaboration with the Leather Cultural District, SoMa West CBD, and neighborhood safety efforts. Supervisor Dorsey affirmed support and noted upcoming safety ambassador plans. The committee voted 3-0 to forward a positive recommendation. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public spoke on any of the three agenda items. Key Outcomes - Item 240857 (Neck of the Woods): Motion passed 3-0 to send a resolution of public convenience or necessity to the full Board of Supervisors on October 22, 2024. - Item 240858 (Eve Nightclub): Motion passed 3-0 to send a resolution of public convenience or necessity to the full Board. - Item 240917 (The Nosh Box): Motion passed 3-0 to send a resolution of public convenience or necessity to the full Board. - All approvals are subject to the conditions outlined by the SFPD ABC Licensing Unit.