Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 601–610 ENTRIES
601
OCT 9, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - October 9, 2024

The San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee met on October 9, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Myrna Melgar. The committee reviewed eleven agenda items covering a temporary library lease, retroactive state grants, the Potrero Yard predevelopment amendment, bus procurement, security contracts, homeless housing and services agreements, and property management agreements. Eight items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendation, and two items were continued to the call of the chair. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 10: No public comment was offered. - Items 8 & 9: Keith Hall, a resident near the Folsom Street properties, urged support, noting that over 8,300 people are unhoused in San Francisco and that permanent supportive housing has been proven effective. - Item 11: Aurora Alvarado, Chief Program Officer of Mission Neighborhood Centers, and two program staff members expressed support for the grant amendment, describing the rental assistance program's impact and the increasing number of applications. Discussion Items - Item 1 — Real Property Lease, 950 Grant Street: Approved a resolution authorizing a 30-month lease with JQ Properties LP for a temporary Chinatown branch library during the $37 million renovation of the Chinatown branch. The 4,200-square-foot site has an annual base rent of $168,000, increasing by $10,500 in year two and an additional $1,200 in the final six months, with a one-year extension option. The library expects to open the temporary site in early spring 2025. - Items 2 & 3 — PATH CITED Grants: Approved two retroactive grant resolutions from the California Department of Health Care Services totaling $3,862,929.40 (PATH CITED 1B) and $1,612,839.48 (CITED IGT) for CalAIM enhanced care management and community supports, including retroactive salary reimbursement and IT implementation. Department staff explained the delays in bringing the grants forward. - Item 4 — Potrero Yard Predevelopment Agreement Amendment: Approved a second amendment increasing the potential termination payment from $9,990,000 to $15,546,566 and extending the predevelopment agreement through July 31, 2025. The project includes a new bus yard and up to 465 affordable and workforce housing units. The BLA recommended approval. - Item 5 — New Flyer Hybrid Bus Purchase: Approved a contract with New Flyer of America, Inc. to purchase 94 40-foot low-floor hybrid electric buses for $117,751,398, replacing buses at the end of their useful life. The BLA noted that the procurement used a Washington State cooperative agreement and that New Flyer was the second-highest scorer behind Gillig, but Gillig could not agree to contract terms. Transit Director Julie Kirschman explained that maintenance familiarity made New Flyer the best option for this procurement. - Items 6 & 7 — Security Guard Services Contract Amendments: Approved increases to two citywide security guard umbrella contracts: A1 Protective Services increased by approximately $26 million to a total of $34,767,000, and Tree Line Security increased by approximately $30.2 million to a total of $38,977,000. Contract terms remain unchanged through July 2028. - Items 8 & 9 — Abode Property Management Agreements: The Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing requested a continuance to the call of the chair for the property management grant agreement and ground lease for 1174-1178 Folsom Street and 663 Clementina Street. - Item 10 — 685 Ellis Street Homekey Grant: Approved a resolution accepting $18,266,702 in state Project Homekey funds for the acquisition and operation of 685 Ellis Street as permanent supportive housing. The city will contribute $4.1 million in matching funds and 15 years of operating subsidy. HSH reported that over 5,000 people were moved out of homelessness in the first year of the Home by the Bay plan. - Item 11 — Mission Neighborhood Centers Grant Amendment: Approved a first amendment extending the homelessness prevention grant by 36 months through June 30, 2028, and increasing funding by approximately $13.1 million to a total not to exceed $20,633,600. The program served 364 households last fiscal year, with 30% Black, 28% Latinx, and 34% aged 50 or older. The amendment also includes $1.28 million in one-time funding for permanent supportive housing tenants behind on rent. Key Outcomes - All items except 8 and 9 were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendation by a vote of 3-0 (Chair Chan, Vice Chair Mandelman, and Supervisor Melgar). - Items 8 and 9 were continued to the call of the chair by a vote of 3-0.

PROCUREMENT 20% · PROCEDURAL 16% · TRANSPORTATION 14% · HOMELESSNESS 13%
602
OCT 9, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - October 9, 2024

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, October 9, 2024, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included public comment, a consent calendar, the Chief's report on crime trends and public safety, the Department of Police Accountability (DPA) Director's report, commission reports, and a closed session. Commissioners voted unanimously on all actions. Consent Calendar - The consent calendar (Item 2) was received and filed unanimously (5-0). It included the 2023 SFPD Department Awards certification, the Police Commission report of disciplinary actions for the third quarter of 2024, and the SFPD and DPA's SB 1421 and SB16 monthly report. No public comment was made on the motion. Public Comments & Testimony - Malin Kamoya (first speaker) made allegations against DPA Executive Director Paul Henderson, claiming violations of law and mistreatment of his family. He expressed anger and referenced ongoing legal matters. - Chris Ward Klein warned that a scandal involving the Bitfocus system in New York City would spread to San Francisco, leading to resignations and potential unrest. He urged the community to remain calm and supported the police department being involved in any arrests. - Mother of Abre Abracasa (unspecified name) spoke about her son's unsolved homicide from August 14, 2006. She requested more resources for cold cases, mentioned a $250,000 reward with no payouts in a decade, and asked for assistance from the DPA and the commission. She also highlighted the need to solve hate crimes within the Black community. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Item 3): Chief Scott reported on the October 7th one-year anniversary of the Hamas attacks, noting a peaceful demonstration with vandalism at Manny's building and ongoing investigation with good video evidence. He also covered the Hardly Strictly Bluegrass Festival (one arrest), Fleet Week (October 7-14, air show with Blue Angels), and a positive reception from visitors about the city's cleanliness. Crime statistics: overall crime down 32% (13,000 fewer crimes), property crimes down 34% (12,000 fewer), violent crimes down 14% (600 fewer), homicides down 42% (24 this year vs. 42 last year, though one additional death may bring it to 25). Homicide clearance rate at approximately 90%. Auto burglaries down 56% (9,000 fewer). A retail theft grant of $15.3 million funded blitz operations resulting in 17 arrests (13 adults, 4 juveniles) on Mission Street. Incidents: Waymo vandalism on October 5 (four subjects, slashed tires, broken windows, spray paint; passengers had minor injuries) and a hit-and-run suspect targeting Waymo and Zoox vehicles (no arrests). Traffic fatalities: one fatal on Treasure Island (October 6, driver died, passenger rescued), and one pedestrian struck while crossing against a red light (driver in custody, victim in critical condition). A large group of motorcycles (70+) gathered at a gas station but dispersed peacefully within 20 minutes. - DPA Director's Report (Item 4): Executive Director Henderson reported that 554 cases have been opened this year, 204 active, 666 closed, 40 sustained, and 14 mediated. Of 18 cases older than 270 days, 17 are tolled due to pending criminal or civil cases. There are 111 sustained cases pending with the Chief and 9 pending with the Commission. This week, 14 new cases were opened, with the top allegation being inappropriate officer behavior. Central Station had the most complaints. The audit division is finalizing the stop data audit, with an exit conference with SFPD expected this month. DPA conducted outreach at the police academy and met with IT teams to improve information sharing via Benchmark. - Commission Reports (Item 5): Commissioner Benedicto noted October as National Hispanic Heritage Month, Filipino American History Month, and Domestic Violence Awareness Month. He mentioned the stop data audit, a letter from community groups regarding Department General Order 7.01 (juveniles) expected for adoption in November, and thanked the Domestic Violence Consortium for an event at City Hall. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Motion to receive and file passed 5-0. - Closed Session (Items 6-8): The commission voted unanimously (5-0) to hold Item 8 in closed session. - Disclosure of Closed Session (Item 9): Motion to not disclose any items from closed session passed unanimously (5-0). - No other votes or decisions were taken. The meeting adjourned after the closed session vote.

PROCEDURAL 73% · PUBLIC COMMENT 10% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 7% · PUBLIC SAFETY 7%
603
OCT 8, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting: Fisherman's Wharf Term Sheet and Dry Dock Funding, October 8, 2024

The Port Commission met on October 8, 2024, to discuss and act on several major items, including a non-binding term sheet for the Fisherman's Wharf Revitalized project, a long-term lease extension for Waterfront Plaza, and emergency funding to stabilize and potentially sell dry docks. The meeting featured extensive public comment from commercial fishermen and business owners, and the commission voted to advance the Fisherman's Wharf term sheet (4-1) and approved the Waterfront Plaza lease and dry dock funding unanimously. Consent Calendar - 11A: Authorization to accept and expend a $2,700,000 FEMA hazard mitigation grant for Piers 94/96 seismic improvements. (Resolution 2442) - 11B: Acceptance of a $159,900 FEMA grant for an Engineering with Nature working group. (Resolution 2443) - 11C: Award of a $2,208,000 construction contract (with 10% contingency of $220,800) to Cazadoro Construction, Inc. for Crane Cove Park Playgrounds and Dog Park. (Resolution 2444) - 11D: Recommendation to the Board of Supervisors to refund the 2013 Certificates of Participation (COPs) up to $23,245,000 at an interest rate not exceeding 5%. (Resolution 2445) - 11E: Acceptance of Mission Bay Park improvements (Bayfront Park) into the Port's park system. (Resolution 2446) - 11F: Lease with Silverado Contractors, Inc. for office, shed, open pier, and submerged space at Pier 96 for five years. (Resolution 2447) - 11G: Lease with Steph Mufson Creations, LLC (The Parade Guys) for approximately 15,042 sq. ft. of shed space at Pier 19 for one year with four one-year extensions. (Resolution 2448) All consent items passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Fisherman's Wharf Revitalized Project (Item 12A): Dozens of commercial fishermen, crab boat owners, and local business owners spoke. Key themes: strong opposition to redeveloping Pier 45 sheds A and C, citing loss of critical gear storage, staging space, and long-term viability of the fishing industry. Speakers included Sarah Bates (Crab Boat Owners Association), Jason Salbado, Michael Rocino, and Larry Collins, who argued the project would drive fishermen away and end San Francisco's working waterfront. Supporters, including the owner of the Franciscan restaurant and a longtime fisherman Steve Leverone, urged moving forward to revitalize the area and fix infrastructure. Rodney Fong (Wax Museum) called for a Request for Proposals (RFP) instead of the sole-source process. Many speakers emphasized that the $548 million project is too large and that the 66-year lease threatens the fishing industry's future. - Other Items: One caller (Rodney Fong) on Item 9 (non-agenda comments) reiterated the call for an RFP. No public comment on Items 12B or 13A. Discussion Items - 12A – Fisherman's Wharf Revitalized Term Sheet: Port staff (Wyatt Donnelly Landall) presented the non-binding term sheet for development of Pier 45 sheds A and C and Seawall Lots 300/301 (the Triangle Lot). The project includes a 66-year lease, $548 million total cost ($186M infrastructure), with a $1.5 million/year rent credit for 15 years, and a CFD/IFD financing tool. The concept has evolved to elevate attractions to the second floor to preserve ground-level fishing storage and industry operations. Commissioners expressed concerns about the impact on the fishing industry and the need for a detailed operations study. Commissioner Adams voted against the term sheet, stating the fishermen's needs were not adequately addressed. The motion passed 4-1 (Brandon, Gilman, English, Lee in favor; Adams opposed). - 12B – Waterfront Plaza Lease Extension (Jamestown): Staff (Ricky) and Jamestown regional director Chris Farber presented a 57-year ground lease extension (from 16 years remaining) for the office complex at Seawall Lots 315-317. The current lease has a $3M base rent that is unsustainable; the new lease reduces base rent to $700,000/year plus percentage rent (6% of gross above base rent) and CPI adjustments every five years. Jamestown commits to a 10-year capital plan of at least $34 million (including $9M in the first 10 years), EV charging, solar, and common area upgrades. The port participates in refinancing/sale proceeds (1.5% of net proceeds). Commissioners questioned the lack of a firm reinvestment commitment, but staff noted the capital plan and reporting mechanisms. The lease passed unanimously after a brief procedural confusion. - 13A – Dry Dock Stabilization and Sale: Deputy Director Nate Cruz presented a request for a $20 million supplemental appropriation from port reserves ($18.5M from rainy day fund, $1.5M from BAE settlement) to stabilize dry docks No. 2 and Eureka at Pier 70, which are in critical condition (holes, failed pumps). The port estimates $5M for immediate stabilization, with the goal of negotiating a sale to Desan Shipyards (Turkey). If sale fails, demolition could cost up to $50M. The commission also authorized advertisement of RFQs for dry dock repair, monitoring, and demolition services. The motion passed unanimously. - New Business (Item 14): Commissioner Adams requested a written update on Hornblower's compliance with the Park Service agreement regarding the IBU, to be provided within the next week. Key Outcomes - Fisherman's Wharf Term Sheet: Adopted Resolution 2449 endorsing the non-binding term sheet (4-1). The term sheet will now go to the Board of Supervisors for endorsement and fiscal feasibility finding. Further environmental review and transaction documents are expected to take 12+ months. - Waterfront Plaza Lease: Approved Resolution 2450 (unanimous) for a 57-year ground lease with Jamestown, including reduced base rent, percentage rent, and $34+ million capital plan. The lease will be forwarded to the Board of Supervisors. - Dry Dock Funding: Adopted Resolution 2451 (unanimous) authorizing a $20 million supplemental appropriation and RFQ advertisement for dry dock services. Staff to negotiate sale terms with Desan Shipyards and report back. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned in memory of Reverend Arnold Townsend.

PROCEDURAL 26% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · FISHERIES MANAGEMENT 12% · PUBLIC FINANCE 9%
604
OCT 8, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting – October 8, 2024

The Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on Tuesday, October 8, 2024, commencing at 10:15 AM. The agenda included a special appearance by Mayor London Breed, adoption of consent items, several ordinances and resolutions, a Committee of the Whole hearing on the state of the hotel industry, and public comment. Notable actions included expanding rent control to buildings built through 1994 and urging mediation in the Clean Water Act lawsuit. Consent Calendar - Items 1–4 were approved unanimously (11 ayes). These included a retroactive grant acceptance of $14,000,000 from the California Jobs First Catalyst Program, zoning code amendments for the 555 9th Street Special Sign District, building code changes, and an administrative code update for the SFPUC Social Impact Partnership Program. - Meeting minutes from September 3, 2024 were approved. Public Comments & Testimony - Taxi medallion crisis: Numerous taxi drivers and advocates (e.g., Mark Gruberg, Marcelo Fonseca, Renata Vimirkevich) testified about the financial hardship caused by the 2010 medallion sales program, which required drivers to pay $250,000 for medallions while Uber, Lyft, and Waymo operate without similar fees. They urged the city to provide relief or buy back the loans. - Polyamory discrimination: Dave Dorshaw requested a law prohibiting discrimination against people in polyamorous relationships, noting that Berkeley and Oakland have passed similar protections. - Hotel workers' strike: During the 3:00 PM special order, dozens of members of Unite Here Local 2 spoke about the ongoing strike at Hilton Union Square, Grand Hyatt Union Square, and Westin St. Francis. Workers cited unsustainable workloads, inadequate wages, and threats to union-sponsored health insurance. The strike, in its 17th day, involved 1,500 workers. Discussion Items - Mayor's Appearance (2:00 PM): Mayor Breed addressed the SFUSD budget crisis, announcing a city-led stabilization team to prevent a state takeover. She emphasized the need for community engagement and a balanced budget to avoid a state loan that would require interest payments and additional cuts. - Item 15 – Rent Control Expansion: Supervisor Peskin introduced an ordinance to expand rent control to buildings constructed before June 13, 1994 (amended from the original 1979 date). After extensive debate, the board rejected a motion to continue the item (4 ayes, 7 noes) and passed the amendment (11-0). The ordinance will take effect if Proposition 33 passes or if state law changes. - Item 22 – Clean Water Act Lawsuit: Supervisor Melgar proposed a resolution urging the city attorney and SFPUC to resolve litigation with the EPA. Supervisor Preston offered a friendly amendment to also urge the EPA to participate in mediation. The resolution passed 8-2, with Supervisors Mandelman and Dorsey dissenting. Debate centered on the risk of a conservative Supreme Court undermining the Clean Water Act versus respect for the city attorney's legal strategy. - Item 16 – Office of Victim and Witness Rights: An ordinance to strengthen the Office of Victim and Witness Rights (OVWR) and merge the Office of Sexual Harassment and Assault Response and Prevention (SHARP) into it. Passed on first reading (11-0). - Item 20 – Entertainment Zones: Ordinance establishing two entertainment zones (Mid-Market and Arena). Passed on first reading (11-0). - Item 21 – Building Code for Gas Infrastructure: Allowed gas infrastructure in new buildings that comply with electric-ready design guidelines. Passed on first reading (11-0). - Item 31 – Committee of the Whole: Convened a Committee of the Whole to hear about the state of the hotel industry. Approved (9 ayes, with Safai and Chan absent). Key Outcomes - Rent control expansion: Ordinance amended to cover buildings built through June 13, 1994, passed on first reading (11-0). Second reading scheduled for the special meeting of October 15, 2024. - Clean Water Act resolution: Passed with amendment (8-2). The board urges both the city attorney and the EPA to mediate. - Victim support office: Passed on first reading (11-0). - Entertainment zones & building code: Both passed on first reading (11-0). - Subpoenas for SF SAFE: Motion to issue subpoenas to Daniel Lawson and Tom Yeh for failing to appear at a Governmental Audit and Oversight Committee hearing passed unanimously. - Domestic Violence Awareness Month: Resolution recognizing October 2024 as Domestic Violence Awareness Month passed unanimously. - Prop 36 support resolution: Introduced by Supervisor Dorsey (to be considered at a future meeting). - Hotel industry hearing: Filed after testimony; board members expressed support for striking workers. Supervisor Ronin announced she will introduce legislation to license and inspect hotels.

LABOR RELATIONS 19% · RENT STABILIZATION 12% · CLEAN WATER ACT LITIGATION 11% · PROCEDURAL 9%
605
OCT 7, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Street Teams Report and Appointments - October 7, 2024

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee, chaired by Supervisor Shamann Walton and joined by President Aaron Peskin and Supervisor Ahsha Safai, convened on October 7, 2024. The committee considered legislation to improve transparency and data sharing for city street teams and approved a full slate of appointments to commissions, including the PUC and Sunshine Task Force. Public Comments & Testimony - Street Teams (Item 1): Leah McGeever, a District 6 resident, requested the tracking system capture instances where housing scores prevent shelter acceptance. - PUC Appointments (Items 3-5): Multiple speakers endorsed the nominees. Keita Round (Enterprise Community Partners) and Sarah Treuhaft (Institute on Race, Power, and Political Economy) backed Avni Jamdar. Randall Martini (Salesian Boys and Girls Club) supported Stephen Leveroni. James Richards (ABU), Roberto Hernandez, and others endorsed Joshua Arce for his extensive community engagement. - Assessment Appeals Board 3 (Item 9): Appointee Luisa Mendoza spoke in support of Mark Dickow. Discussion Items 1. Street Teams Reporting Ordinance (File 240805) Supervisor Dean Preston introduced an ordinance requiring regular reports from DEM, HSH, DPH, and the Fire Department on street team effectiveness, incorporating audit recommendations on data sharing and shelter tracking. DEM Director Mary Ellen Carroll and Coordinator Lauren Bell presented the first annual Coordinated Street Response Report. Key statistics included nearly 80,000 client encounters, over 6,000 transports, and over 6,000 links to shelter/housing. A new All Street Teams Client Database and Outreach Worker Tool were detailed to improve inter-department coordination. A new analysis on shelter preferences showed non-congregate shelter had an acceptance rate between 56% and 120% , while congregate shelters had rates between 7% and 28% . Supervisor Preston praised the progress but expressed concern about the top-tier goal, which he felt removed language “ensuring a path to stable health and housing.” He argued the current framing centered public behavior over client needs. Departments agreed to revisit the goal. The committee adopted minor amendments (switching to annual reports, removing duplicative sections) and forwarded the ordinance unanimously. 2-9. Appointments All nominees were unanimously approved and forwarded to the full board. - Sunshine Ordinance Task Force (Item 2): Dean Schmidt (Seat 1), Lila Lahood (Seat 2), Saul Sugarman (Seat 3), Maxine Anderson (Seat 5), Laura Stein (Seat 6), Matt Yankee (Seat 7), Chris Hyland (Seat 8), David Pilpel (Seat 9), Bruce Wolf (Seat 11). - Public Utilities Commission (Items 3-5): Avni Jamdar (Environmental Justice), Joshua Arce (Ratepayer Advocate), Stephen Leveroni (Project Finance) were confirmed. Questions focused on community benefits and ratepayer affordability. - Treasury Oversight Committee (Item 6): City Controller Greg Wagner was appointed. - Assessment Appeals Board 1 (Item 7): Adina Gilbert, Hilary Winslow (absent), Karina Mitchell (alt), Paul Bellar (alt). - Assessment Appeals Board 2 (Item 8): Luisa Mendoza, Nicholas Goldman, Michaela Domingo (alt), Joyce Lewis (alt), Claire Irvin Lee (alt). - Assessment Appeals Board 3 (Item 9): Mark Dickow was reappointed. Key Outcomes - Ordinance 240805 was amended and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors for a vote on October 22. - All appointment motions carried with unanimous support from members present. Supervisor Peskin was excused from final votes on Items 3-9.

PUBLIC HEALTH 20% · PUBLIC UTILITIES 17% · HOMELESSNESS 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11%
606
OCT 7, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting - October 7, 2024

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, October 7, 2024, at 9:45 AM. Chair Supervisor Miranda Melgar presided, joined by President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston. The committee considered five agenda items, including two called out of order, and heard extensive public testimony on a resolution urging the city to resolve a Clean Water Act lawsuit with the EPA. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Entertainment Zones): Yoya Murphy (Chase Center/Thrive City), Aaron Bilbo (Golden Voice/Warfield Theater), and Wes Wakeford (Red Tail Beer and Wine Bar) all expressed strong support for creating the two entertainment zones, citing economic revitalization and community benefits. - Item 2 (Gas Infrastructure): Susan Green (District 8) and Nancy Haber (District 7) thanked the committee for bulletproofing the all-electric ordinance and urged continued progress on electrification. - Item 5 (Public Art Requirement): Corey Smith (Housing Action Coalition) supported the fee elimination to reduce costs. Charlie Shawnless (Council of Community Housing Organizations) expressed concern about losing a vital source for community art, noting HCD provided no flexibility, and encouraged alternative funding streams. - Item 4 (EPA Lawsuit): Over 20 speakers uniformly urged the committee to pass the resolution and drop the lawsuit. Speakers included Ariane Harrison, Tanya Randell, Bill Martin (Sierra Club), Scott Webb (Sierra Club/Resource Renewal Institute), Casey Chorrens, Mishualee, Geraldine Masson (Surfrider Foundation), Justin James, Ella Jackson, Benick Robertson, Kate Roberts, Mo Ball, Liz Stebbins, Christopher Bennham, Sarah Gao, Ben Eichenberg (San Francisco Baykeeper), Tim Eichenberg, Susan Green, Nancy Haber, Adelaide Esposito, Tiffany Pfeiffer, Mark McKee (Baykeeper), Carolyn Chang (Sierra Club), Jason Foster, Nina Atkind (Surfrider Foundation), Martha Krieger (Sierra Club), Sarah Greenwald, John Anderson, and others. They argued that the lawsuit risks weakening the Clean Water Act, threatens public health and the environment, and aligns San Francisco with polluters. Discussion Items - Item 1: Administrative Code – Entertainment Zones – Ben Van Houten (OEWD) presented the ordinance to create two zones (mid-market and arena). The committee heard public comment and voted unanimously to send it as a committee report to the full board. - Item 2: Building Code – Gas Infrastructure for EPCA Appliances – Supervisor Mandelman and Cindy Cummerford (SF Environment) explained the amendment to comply with the Ninth Circuit ruling. The committee voted unanimously to recommend as a committee report. - Item 3: Public Works Code – Fee Waiver for Vicha Ratanapakdee Mosaic Stairway – Mick Del Rosario (Supervisor Stephanie’s office) presented the ordinance to waive $7,800 in fees. Audrey Merloni (Planning) noted unanimous commission approval. The committee voted unanimously to amend and recommend as amended. - Item 5 (called out of order): Planning Code – Eliminating Public Art Requirement for 100% Affordable Housing – Madison Tam (Supervisor Dorsey’s office) presented the required change to comply with HCD. Chair Melgar expressed regret but supported the action. The committee voted to adopt non-substantive amendments and send the ordinance to the full board without recommendation. - Item 4: Resolution Urging Resolution of SFPUC/EPA Lawsuit – Chair Melgar introduced the resolution. Professor David Owen (UC Law SF) explained the risks of continuing the lawsuit, including potential harm to the Clean Water Act and California nuisance law. Deputy City Attorney Sarah Crowley confirmed mediation was attempted in 2021 but unsuccessful, and no mediation is currently scheduled. The committee discussed the city attorney’s public memo and the need for immediate mediation. Chair Melgar and President Peskin denounced recent political weaponization of the issue. Supervisor Preston called for urgent mediation. The committee voted unanimously to amend (adding states) and send as a committee report. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Entertainment Zones): Motion to send as committee report passed 3-0 (Preston, Peskin, Melgar). - Item 2 (Gas Infrastructure): Motion to send as committee report passed 3-0. - Item 3 (Fee Waiver): Motion to amend and recommend as amended passed 3-0. - Item 5 (Public Art Requirement): Motion to amend and send without recommendation passed 3-0. - Item 4 (EPA Lawsuit): Motion to amend (add states) and send as committee report passed 3-0. - All items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on October 22, 2024, except Item 1 and 2 which may appear on October 8, 2024. - The committee urged the city attorney and SFPUC to immediately engage in mediation and drop the Supreme Court case.

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW 22% · PUBLIC COMMENT 20% · CLEAN WATER ACT LITIGATION 19% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 8%
607
OCT 2, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Regular Meeting, October 2, 2024

The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on October 2, 2024, to consider seven agenda items: a grant acceptance for coastal resilience, four contract amendments (engineering services, jail food services, refuse collection, industrial supplies), and two fuel contract extensions. All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. The committee also discussed a systemic oversight issue in the city's financial system identified by the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA). Discussion Items - Item 1 (240886): Southern Embarcadero Resilience Grant – The Port of San Francisco presented a resolution to accept and expend a $7.8 million grant from the California Coastal Conservancy's Climate Ready Program for the Southern Embarcadero Resilience and Enhancement Project. The grant, requiring no matching funds, will address projected sea-level rise of 3–7 feet and protect the South Beach neighborhood. Detailed designs and coordination with city agencies are planned through 2026. Chair Chan expressed interest in learning more about overall resilience needs. The item passed 2–0 (Vice Chair Mandelman absent). - Item 2 (240827): AECOM Dams and Reservoirs Contract Amendment – The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) requested a $9 million increase (from $11M to $20M) for engineering services on dam and reservoir improvements, triggered by post-Oroville spillway failure requirements. The amendment continues planning and design for facilities including San Andreas Dam, Turner Dam, and Sunset Reservoir. BLA noted the increase aligns with an updated capital budget of $208.9 million. The item passed 2–0 (Vice Chair Mandelman absent). - Item 3 (240862): Aramark Jail Food Services Extension – The Sheriff's Office exercised the final one-year option extending the Aramark contract through October 2025, adding $4.7 million for a total not-to-exceed $24.8 million. The Sheriff's Office stated it will release an RFP by end of 2024 for a new contract. The item passed 2–0 (Vice Chair Mandelman absent). - Item 4 (240863): Recology Refuse Collection Amendment – The Office of Contract Administration (OCA) requested a sixth amendment extending the contract two months through December 31, 2024, and increasing spending authority by $1.5 million to $45.3 million, with a 3.77% CPI-based rate increase. This extension allows OCA to finalize negotiations with Recology after Allied Waste withdrew. The item passed 3–0. - Item 5 (240838): WW Grainger Industrial Supplies Contract Amendment – OCA requested an increase from $7 million to $32 million for this citywide contract, with no term change. Spending has remained concentrated on Grainger despite OCA awarding four additional contracts from a cooperative solicitation. OCA will encourage departments to use multiple vendors. The item passed 3–0. - Items 6 & 7 (240864 & 240865): Fuel Contracts – Renewable Diesel and Gasoline – OCA presented amendments for Golden Gate Petroleum (diesel) and Mansfield Oil (gasoline) to extend both contracts through June 30, 2025, with optional further extensions through October 31, 2025. The diesel amendment seeks up to $102.3 million (with potential to $108.6 million); the gasoline amendment seeks up to $17.5 million (with potential to $20.8 million). OCA plans a combined fuel procurement RFP by end of fiscal year. BLA noted that the city's financial system lacks automatic controls to prevent spending above Board-approved amounts, citing that the diesel contract had $92 million encumbered against an $86.8 million approved limit. The Controller's Office is developing a dashboard to improve oversight. Both items passed 3–0. Key Outcomes - All seven agenda items were approved and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Votes were 2–0 for items 1–3 (Supervisors Chan and Melgar in favor; Vice Chair Mandelman absent) and 3–0 for items 4–7 (all members present). - The BLA recommendation accompanying each item was accepted. - The committee acknowledged the financial system oversight issue raised by the BLA regarding contract spending limits; the Controller's Office committed to implementing a tracking dashboard by year-end. - OCA will re-encourage city departments to diversify industrial supply vendors and will continue negotiating a new refuse collection contract, expected to be presented in December 2024.

PROCUREMENT 45% · PROCEDURAL 19% · ENGINEERING AND INFRASTRUCTURE 18% · INFRASTRUCTURE 9%
608
OCT 2, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Regular Meeting - October 2, 2024

The San Francisco Police Commission held its regular meeting on Wednesday, October 2, 2024, starting at 1:45 PM UTC. The meeting was called to order by President Cindy Elias, with Commissioners Clay, Walker, Benedicto, Yanyez, and Yee present, and Vice President Carter Oberstone arriving later (a quorum was established). Chief Bill Scott and Executive Director Paul Henderson of the Department of Police Accountability (DPA) were also in attendance. The meeting covered routine approvals, reports from the Chief and DPA Director, a quarterly policy report (Sparks Report), a detailed presentation on SFPD's drone program and AB 481 compliance, and approval of two revised Department General Orders (DGOs). The meeting also included a closed session, after which the Commission voted not to disclose any discussions. Consent Calendar - Item 3: The Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to receive and file the SFPD Live Monitoring Report for Q1 2024 and the 2023 SFPD Department Awards Certification. - Item 4: The Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to adopt the minutes from the meetings of September 4, September 11, and September 18, 2024. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 2 (General Public Comment): - Milena Maki Cabata (Walk SF, campaign associate) urged the SFPD to recommit to Vision Zero and to create an annual Vision Zero plan focused on speeding drivers. She provided a copy of the Vision Zero Coalition's recommendations to the Commission. - A second public speaker (self-identified as an older resident) expressed increasing discomfort walking in the city due to heavier, faster, and less law-abiding traffic. They cited a lack of enforcement of red-light and stop-sign violations and questioned the number of traffic enforcement officers (allegedly eight) relative to the 400,000+ cars in San Francisco. - A speaker praised SFPD's drone use and warned that the Commission must follow voter-passed propositions (including Prop E) or face further ballot measures. They also mentioned drafting a new ballot proposition. - A mother of a homicide victim (Arbory Arcassow, murdered August 14, 2006) described her experience with a DPA investigator who asked if she was "affiliated" with a family in a court case, which she found triggering. She called for better tipster payment programs and support for families. - Item 5 (Chief's Report): A speaker alleged that a sitting police commissioner and his public defender wife were "scoping out" a residence's camera and called for an investigation. Another speaker (the mother of a homicide victim) again asked for help solving her son's case and for increased tipster rewards. - No public comment was made for items 1, 3, 4, 6, 7, 8, 10, and 11. - Item 9 (Drone Program): One speaker expressed support for the drone program, citing Prop E's 54% voter approval (120,529 votes) and arguing that voters had the authority to approve the program. Discussion Items Item 5: Chief’s Report Chief Scott reported a 32% decrease in Part I crimes year-to-date (approximately 13,000 fewer crimes), with property crime down 34%, violent crime down 14%, homicides down 40% (24 this year vs. 40 last year), and car break-ins down 57% (7,181 vs. 16,586 last year). Firearm seizures totaled 894 (including 74 ghost guns, down from 117). No homicides occurred in the past week; one non-fatal shooting occurred (September 28, Ingleside). Significant incidents included an armed robbery arrest (September 22, Bayview), an ICAC investigation leading to the arrest of a 56-year-old for child pornography possession/distribution, and a February assault case with a stunt driving-related arrest. Chief Scott said a body-worn camera video would be released either that evening or the next day, and SFPD was preparing for his stakeholder meeting. He also provided updates on bilingual testing (scheduled for October 7, 11, 17, and 18) and addressed Commissioner Benedicto's question about sealed officer files. Commissioner Carter Oberstone asked about the video release process and raised concerns about lateral officers hired from jurisdictions with sealed records; Chief Scott stated there is no evidence of such cases in SFPD. Item 6: DPA Director’s Report Executive Director Henderson reported: 542 cases opened year-to-date, 224 open investigations, 635 cases closed, 14 mediations, 18 cases older than nine months (17 of which are “told”), 120 sustained cases pending with the Chief, and 13 sustained cases pending with the Police Commission. The most common complaint allegation was officers behaving or speaking inappropriately. He also acknowledged National Hispanic Heritage Month and Domestic Violence Awareness Month. The DPA is addressing comments from the Controller’s office and will have an exit conference with SFPD later in the month. Item 8: Sparks Report Q2 2024 This quarterly report (sponsored by former Commissioner Sparks) covers policy development from April-June 2024. Presenters included Aja (SFPD) and a DPA representative. - SFPD reported updates on 25 DGOs and 57 department notices, including Prop E-related DGOs (501, 503, 504, 505, 506) adopted by the Commission. Several DGOs were in various stages: sent to Commission for calendaring (301, 310, 704, 1011), moving out of stage two (316, 610, 612, 613, 809, 812, 1102), and in post-concurrence (518, 701, 906). The 2024 DGO work plan included several items now in public review (302, 316, 607, 613, 615), and working groups for DGO 616 (sexual assault) and 520 (language access) were progressing. - DPA highlighted 28 recommendations for DGO 6.10 (missing persons), which SFPD has partially incorporated; this DGO was last updated in 1999 (prior to the creation of Amber Alerts). DPA also noted difficulties tracking paper citations (which go directly to Superior Court) compared to e-citations, impacting stop data audits. DPAA also praised the EVOC training. Commissioner Carter Oberstone inquired about the status of DGOs 1.06 and 1.07; it was revealed that the revision process intended to combine them but failed to incorporate 1.07 content, requiring a reset. Commissioner Yanyez requested a red-line version of DGO 520, stating it had not been provided to the working group; SFPD said it was posted online, but Commissioner Yanyez insisted it was not. Director Henderson suggested publishing policy calendars as part of the consent calendar and revisiting DGO 3.01 to clarify deadlines. Item 9: SFPD Drone Program and AB 481 Compliance Director Kara Lacy (Constitutional Policing) presented SFPD's drone program. She outlined that Prop E (passed March 5, 2024) authorized drone use for vehicle pursuits and active investigations. SFPD acquired six pilot drones in May 2024, and the Board of Supervisors approved a drone policy on September 24, 2024 (9-2 vote), authorizing 22 additional drones, with enactment expected October 4, 2024. Director Lacy stated that SFPD consulted with the City Attorney's office and believes the purchase was lawful, arguing that Prop E stood in for Board approval under AB 481. Commissioner Carter Oberstone sharply criticized this position, reading AB 481 requirements (approval by board of supervisors, ordinance, regular meeting, specific content in the military use policy) and stating that Prop E satisfied none of them. He called the legal rationale “deeply unserious” and asked Chief Scott if he believed the purchase was lawful; Chief Scott said yes. Deputy City Attorney Alice Cabrera confirmed the City Attorney's position that the purchase was lawful but declined to provide public legal reasoning. Commissioner Walker sought to clarify that SFPD followed the advice of lawyers and noted that no lawsuit had been filed. Commissioner Benedicto asked whether other departments had used a similar interpretation; a representative said they were not aware. Commissioner Yee asked if there was a legal precedent allowing voters to stand in for the board; no such case was known. Public comment included one speaker supporting the drone program. Item 10: DGO 3.10 “Serious Incident Review Board” Sergeant John Crudeau presented the revised DGO 3.10, which expands the former “Firearm Discharge Review Board” (dated 2005) to a broader “Serious Incident Review Board.” The revision includes updated command structures, codifies the Training Division and Force Options Unit as formal participants, and broadens scope to major/critical incidents. The Board will issue policy, training, and tactics recommendations, and will incorporate DPA input. DPA provided 13 recommendations, all resolved through collaboration. The Commission unanimously (7-0) approved the DGO for use in meeting and conferring with bargaining units. Item 11: DGO 8.03 “Crowd Control” Deputy Chief Raj Vaswani presented the revised DGO 8.03, which was developed by a working group that met seven times between December 2023 and April 2024, including participation from DPA, the Public Defender's Office, community groups, and others. Key changes include added definitions, a dispersal order section, provisions for kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents per Penal Code 1365, and alignment with media access provisions of Penal Code 409.7. DPA provided two recommendations, one fully accepted and one partially. The Commission unanimously (7-0) approved the DGO for use in meeting and conferring with bargaining units. Key Outcomes - Approval of consent calendar (receive and file Live Monitoring Q1 2024 and 2023 Awards certification) – unanimous (7-0). - Approval of minutes for September 4, 11, and 18, 2024 – unanimous (7-0). - Approval of revised DGO 3.10 (Serious Incident Review Board) – unanimous (7-0). - Approval of revised DGO 8.03 (Crowd Control) – unanimous (7-0). - Vote to hold a closed session (Item 14) – unanimous (7-0). - Vote not to disclose any discussions from closed session – unanimous (7-0). Closed Session - The Commission held a closed session (Item 14) and voted not to disclose any discussion (Item 15). No details were reported.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 23% · PUBLIC SAFETY 21% · PROCEDURAL 20% · LEGAL 13%
609
OCT 1, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - October 1, 2024

The Board of Supervisors met in regular session on Tuesday, October 1, 2024, with all 11 members present. The board adopted a unanimous consent calendar, passed multiple ordinances and resolutions on first reading, held special order commendations, and conducted two 3:00 p.m. Committee of the Whole hearings: one examining special education funding failures in the San Francisco Unified School District (SFUSD) and another adding emergency security funding for Planned Parenthood Northern California. The board also adopted a resolution supporting the federal Homes Act. Consent Calendar - Items 1 through 5 were adopted unanimously (11-0). These included routine budget and finance approvals, grant acceptances, a commemorative plaque fee waiver, and the Greater Downtown Community Benefit District Master Permitting for Entertainment Activation Program. President Peskin highlighted the master permitting program as a first-in-the-nation permitting reform that streamlines arts and culture activations in public spaces. Unfinished Business - Item 6 (Police Code - Vehicle Sideshows): Supervisor Dorsey moved an amendment to the findings, adding language about seized vehicles and street takeover maneuvers. The amendment was accepted, and the ordinance passed on first reading. It will require a second-reading vote next week. New Business - Item 7: Ordinance retroactively authorizing acceptance of a $14,000,000 grant from the California Economic Development Department for the California Jobs First Catalyst Program (May 1, 2024 through September 30, 2026) passed on first reading. - Items 8-10: Three resolutions accepting grants for HIV/AIDS and PrEP programs, including increases for the Adolescent Medicine Trials Network ($173,063), MyPrEP Plus ($177,860), and The Bridge Clinic for transgender and non-binary people ($160,074), were adopted unanimously. Supervisor Ronan expressed support and asked to be added as co-sponsor. - Item 11: Resolution approving a $7,000,000 increase to the Hunters Point Family Pit Stop Workforce Development Grant Program, for a new total not to exceed $16,238,478.52, with a term extension through June 30, 2025, was adopted. - Item 12: Resolution authorizing acceptance of an in-kind gift from Deloitte Tax LLP valued at approximately $112,089 for climate tax advisory services was adopted. - Item 14: Resolution approving a ground lease with Five Keys Schools and Programs at 42 Otis Street for 100% permanent supportive housing, with rent not to exceed $1, was adopted. - Items 16-19: Four resolutions responding to Civil Grand Jury reports were adopted after a technical amendment to item 17. Supervisor Melgar questioned the board's disagreement with findings in item 16 regarding climate risk communication and bond funding; Vice Chair Stefani replied that departments were consulted and the response was fact-based. - Item 20: Ordinance establishing the 555 9th Street Special Sign District passed on first reading. - Item 21: Ordinance expanding the SFPUC Social Impact Partnership Program passed on first reading. - Items 22 and 23: Appointments of Claudia Quinonez to the Child Care Planning and Advisory Council and Melinda Burrus to the Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee were approved. Committee Reports - Item 27: Ordinance amending the Building Code to excuse professionally prepared architectural drawings for certain change-of-use designations passed on first reading. Special Order 2:30 P.M. - Commendations - Supervisor Ronan recognized Brian and Edwin Suchi Lopez, brothers who arrived as unaccompanied minors from Guatemala and successfully advocated for the right to counsel for immigrant children. Brian is now a UC Santa Cruz student and will vote in his first election; Edwin is a senior at City Arts and Leadership High School. Both received commendations during Latinx Heritage Month. Roll Call Introductions - Supervisor Engardio honored former President Jimmy Carter on his 100th birthday. - Supervisor Mandelman introduced ordinances to acquire 2280 Market Street for an LGBTQ history museum and to repeal outdated Police Code provisions regulating bathhouses. - Supervisor Peskin, with Supervisors Preston and Melgar, introduced an e-bike incentive program aimed at reducing emissions and advancing transportation equity. - Supervisor Ronan submitted a motion for a future Committee of the Whole on the SFUSD math pilot funded by the Student Success Fund. - Supervisor Safai noted the passing of actor John Amos. Adoption Without Committee Reference - Items 30, 31, 33, and 34 were adopted unanimously on a 10-0 roll call (Supervisor Melgar excused). - Item 32, a resolution supporting the federal Homes Act (H.R. 9662), was severed by Supervisor Preston for separate consideration. Preston spoke in support of the bill, which would create a national housing development authority, build 1.25 million climate-resilient homes, invest $300 billion, create 400,000 jobs annually, and repeal the Faircloth Amendment. The resolution was adopted. Committee of the Whole: SFUSD Special Education Funding - Supervisor Safai convened the hearing to examine the unaccounted $20,000,000 (later reported as over $30,000,000) in special education funding and unfilled positions, along with the use of $8,400,000 from the Student Success Fund for a new School Stabilization Team. - SFUSD Board of Education President Matt Alexander testified that the board passed the budget in June believing special education positions were included, but learned on August 30 that they were not. Approximately 250 positions were not in the budget; the budget was amended on September 4, after the school year began. He called the situation unacceptable and requested an independent assessment by the city controller. - Vanessa Morrero, executive director of Parents for Public Schools, explained the SELPA and Community Advisory Committee (CAC) certification process, noting that the CAC must sign off on the special education budget plan. - Maria Su, Director of the Department of Children, Youth and Their Families, testified that the School Stabilization Team was formed on September 22 after a request from the school board. The $8,400,000 consists of $6,800,000 in unspent Student Success Fund grant funds from FY2023-24 (out of a $9,000,000 allocation, only $2,200,000 was spent) plus $1,600,000 from unallocated FY2024-25 funds. She said no city staff would be paid from these funds and that the goal is to maintain local control of the district. - Superintendent Matt Wayne testified that 14% of SFUSD's 49,000 students have IEPs, and the special education budget is $224,000,000, over 20% of the general fund. He reported 64 vacant certificated special education classroom positions out of 516, and 209 vacant paraeducator positions out of 1,312. He acknowledged a process failure: a $60,000,000 increase was requested in April, but under state oversight and a hiring freeze, the budget office directed removal of 283 FTEs (about $30,000,000) and reduced contracted services by $37,000,000. The district ultimately added $30,000,000 after school started. He said approximately 1,000 students could be impacted by vacancies and four Williams complaints had been filed, three related to special education. - Multiple supervisors expressed concerns: Supervisor Safai pressed on legal mandates and accountability; Supervisor Ronan and Walton warned against diverting Student Success Funds from direct student services; Supervisor Chan questioned the fiscal stabilization plan and use of one-time funds; Supervisor Preston raised the school closure timeline and urged reconsideration of the fall 2025 impact date; Supervisor Melgar stressed the need for operational systems and compliance with state and federal requirements; Supervisor Engardio asked about the PEF arts audit and whether the CAC certification process was legally bypassed. - Public testimony was extensive. Parents, students, and advocates described failures in special education, called for a comprehensive and independent audit, and urged that Prop G / Student Success Funds be spent directly on schools and students. Several speakers shared personal stories of students with IEPs lacking teachers, paras, or services. One speaker questioned the board's jurisdiction over SFUSD. - The hearing was filed. Committee of the Whole: Planned Parenthood Northern California Security Grant - Supervisor Stefani introduced the item, citing unprecedented protest activity and documented security incidents at the San Francisco Planned Parenthood health center. Between July 1 and September 26, 2024, there were 28 documented security incidents; 18% occurred in the first two days of the 40 Days for Life campaign, which began September 25. - DPH Chief Financial Officer Drew Morel testified that the existing grant had a not-to-exceed amount of $400,000 and its security budget was exhausted by July 2024. The proposed amendment increases the grant by $171,000 to a total of $571,000 to fund one security personnel during all operating hours and two during the 40 Days for Life protests through November 3, 2024. Planned Parenthood is contributing $108,000 of its own operating funds toward the $279,666 total security cost. - Kimberly Ellis, Director of the Department on the Status of Women, noted that a recent landscape analysis recommended increased security funding, and she voiced strong support. - Ruth Nunez, Senior Health Center Director at Planned Parenthood, reported intimidation of patients and staff, including a gun-brandishing incident and a suspicious package, and said the center serves about 18,000 patients. - Public comment was supportive, with one speaker suggesting an increase to $800,000. Supervisor Safai was excused from the vote. The ordinance passed on first reading by a roll call vote of 10-0. Key Outcomes - Consent calendar adopted unanimously (11-0). - Vehicle sideshow ordinance amended and passed on first reading; final vote scheduled for next week. - All Budget and Finance Committee items, Civil Grand Jury responses, appointments, and several land-use/administrative ordinances were approved. - The SFUSD special education hearing was filed; school closure recommendations are expected before the October 18 enrollment fair, with school board action proposed for December 10, 2024. - The Planned Parenthood security grant ordinance passed on first reading (10-0) and will return for a second reading. - Adjourned in memory of John Amos.

PUBLIC EDUCATION 46% · PUBLIC HEALTH 11% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 11% · PUBLIC COMMENT 10%
610
SEP 30, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - September 30, 2024

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on September 30, 2024, at 9:45 AM, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, joined by President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston. The committee considered three items: a building code amendment to simplify permitting for small businesses, a rent control expansion ordinance contingent on repeal of the Costa Hawkins Act, and a housing code amendment requiring elevators in smaller apartment buildings. Public comment was heard on each item, and votes were taken. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Building Code - Change of Use): Ben Blyman (Entertainment Commissioner, speaking personally) supported the legislation, noting that architectural drawing costs have risen from $1,500 to $8,000-$10,000. Teresa Delales (SoMa resident) urged ensuring the law applies only to small businesses, not developers, to avoid a loophole. - Item 2 (Rent Control Expansion): Several speakers supported the ordinance. Ann (tenant counselor, South of Market Community Action at Work) shared a story of a client facing a massive rent increase after a parent's death. Zachary Friel (D5 resident, Zomkin) cited studies showing rent control does not impact new construction and that Bay Area cities with rent control built 1.8 times more housing per resident. William Palmer (re-entry advocate) said rent control stops gentrification and displacement. Molly Goldberg (San Francisco Anti-Displacement Coalition) noted that over 80,000 units lack rent control due to state preemption. Charlie Sciammas (Council of Community Housing Organizations) supported the three P's: production, preservation, protection. Calvin Welch (Haight Ashbury Neighborhood Council) stated rent control is the only local control on market-rate housing. Kristin Evans (small business owner) said rent control helps retain employees. Mitchell Omerberg (Affordable Housing Alliance) noted that tenants in post-1979 buildings lack predictability. Carla (community organizer, District 7) described patients unable to afford rent. Opposing speakers: Corey Smith (Housing Action Coalition) argued the ordinance could lead to rent control on new housing, harming financing, and suggested a 30-year rolling exemption. Charlie Goss (San Francisco Apartment Association) called it an anti-housing proposal that would stop new housing development, urging a studied approach. - Item 3 (Elevator Maintenance): Kevin Eisenstadt (District 5 resident, Mosser Tower) described hardship when both elevators were out for nearly a week, affecting seniors and disabled residents. Discussion Items - Item 1: Building Code - Change of Use Designation (File 240798) Director Katie Kang (Office of Small Business) presented the Mayor Breed-sponsored ordinance. It would remove architectural plan requirements for building permits when there is a change of use but no construction or change in occupancy classification. The legislation codifies a pilot program that has helped about a dozen businesses, saving thousands of dollars and time. A common example is a limited restaurant adding a liquor license. Chair Melgar expressed support but raised concerns about existing building code violations, noting a constituent's billiards-to-childcare conversion required costly corrections. Tate Hannah (DBI) confirmed that violations must be corrected before permits, per code. The committee voted unanimously to recommend the ordinance. - Item 2: Administrative Code - New Construction Exemption from Rent Control (File 240880) President Peskin introduced the ordinance, which would extend rent control to multifamily buildings completed up to November 5, 2024, effective if Costa Hawkins is repealed (e.g., via Proposition 33). He argued it does not affect new construction. Vice Chair Preston expanded on protections rent control provides: limits on rent increases, pass-throughs, rent reductions for repairs, and access to the Rent Board. Chair Melgar expressed concern about potential interaction with the inclusionary housing program (Planning Code Section 415), worrying it might undermine the nexus study and deed restrictions. Staff from the Rent Board clarified that deed-restricted affordable units are already exempt from rent control. After public comment, President Peskin made non-substantive amendments to clarify the June 13, 1979 date. The committee voted 2-1 to recommend the amended ordinance (Peskin and Preston in favor, Melgar opposed). Chair Melgar then moved to duplicate the file and continue it to the call of the chair, which passed unanimously. - Item 3: Housing Code - Operational Elevators (File 240807) Lorenzo Rosas (from Supervisor Stefani's office) presented the ordinance, which fixes a loophole in Housing Code Section 713. Currently, only buildings over 50 feet are required to maintain operable elevators, allowing owners of 3-4 story buildings to let elevators fall into disrepair, affecting mobility-impaired and senior tenants. The ordinance would allow housing inspectors to cite under-50-foot buildings with elevators. Non-substantive amendments were adopted: removing subsection C (which addressed good-faith repair efforts) and adding findings. Vice Chair Preston offered a friendly amendment to add a finding that a non-functional elevator creates extreme hardship for seniors and persons with disabilities, which was accepted. The committee voted unanimously to recommend the ordinance as amended. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Passed unanimously (3-0) with a positive recommendation to the Board of Supervisors as a committee report. Chair Melgar added as co-sponsor. - Item 2: Passed 2-1 (Peskin, Preston in favor; Melgar opposed) to recommend the amended ordinance to the full board. A duplicated file was continued to the call of the chair (3-0). - Item 3: Passed unanimously (3-0) with amendments (including Preston's hardship finding) and a positive recommendation to the full board.

PUBLIC COMMENT 35% · RENT STABILIZATION 24% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 14% · BUILDING INSPECTION 12%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com