Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 611–620 ENTRIES
611
SEP 26, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting Summary – September 26, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular hearing on Thursday, September 26, 2024, to consider continuances, consent calendar items, an informational presentation on the Hazards and Climate Resilience Plan, a public hearing on a Draft Environmental Impact Report, a conditional use authorization for a residential development, and two discretionary review requests. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (2024-007340PCA): Fee Waiver for Vicha Ratanapakdee Mosaic Stairway. The Commission unanimously approved the fee waiver for the Mosaic Stairway. Public Comments & Testimony - Continuance (Item 10 - Whitney Street): Laura Strazzo, attorney for the property owners, opposed a continuance to November 7th, citing the Permit Streamlining Act and Housing Accountability Act, suggesting a shorter continuance to October 10th. Georgia Schudish commented on the project's nature as an enforcement abatement. - Item 3 (Minutes Correction): Georgia Schudish requested a correction to the September 12th minutes, stating she advised the Commission to "look at the site" regarding the Staples project, not to "look at a memo." - General Public Comment: Georgia Schudish presented a historical timeline of Section 317 arguing demolition calculations were never adjusted. Ms. Hester requested the Commission schedule a meeting to adopt the 2025 calendar and hold a presentation on commission rules. - Item 9 (842 California Street): Multiple neighbors spoke in opposition. Catherine Anderson expressed concern over blocking views from the University Club and impacts on light and air. Erica Frick argued the building would block iconic views from the historic cable car crossing. Bob Cohn reported a 21% decrease in his property value and cited the oversupply of luxury housing. Regina Scalaro argued the developer was abusing the state density bonus program. - Item 11 (1657-1659 Mason Street): DR Requester Kelly Melendez argued the project was invalid due to inaccurate plans. The neighboring property owner stated she was misled and the project would box in her rear yard. An architect neighbor spoke in support, calling the site a "gaping hole" needing infill. - Item 12 (1229 45th Avenue): DR Requester Eileen Boken (SPEAK) argued the project was not a legitimate ADU as it was larger than the primary residence. DR Requester Margot Campbell Gross stated the rear structure was uninhabitable and the new building would block light to her dining room. Discussion Items - Item 7 (2025 Draft Hazards and Climate Resilience Plan): The Commission received an informational presentation on the citywide action plan addressing 13 natural hazards. The plan update ensures FEMA grant eligibility and includes 74 actions across buildings, communities, and infrastructure. Commissioners discussed interagency coordination on shoreline resilience, community outreach to environmental justice communities, and the financial scope of projects like the Yosemite Slough Adaptation Plan. - Item 8 (3400 Laguna Street - Draft EIR): Staff presented the Draft EIR for expanding the Heritage on the Marina residential care facility. The draft concluded no significant unavoidable impacts. Commissioner Moore raised concerns about the legibility of plans, the historic value of mid-century buildings slated for demolition, and the safety of the proposed parking garage entrance on Bay Street. - Item 9 (842 California Street - Conditional Use Authorization): The Commission deliberated on replacing five dwelling units with a 33-unit project utilizing a state density bonus. Debate focused on the loss of rent-controlled units, the height and design impacting the historic Nob Hill neighborhood, the provision of five affordable ownership units, and the constraints of state housing law. The commission was split on balancing housing production versus neighborhood character. Key Outcomes - Item 10 (229-233 Whitney Street): Continued. The Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to continue the item to October 17, 2024, adjusting the original November 7th request to meet Permit Streamlining Act deadlines. - Item 1 (Mosaic Stairway Fee Waiver): Approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 3 (September 12th Minutes): Adopted unanimously (7-0) with the requested correction. - Item 9 (842 California Street): Approved 4-3. Commissioners Campbell, McGarry, Braun, and President Seo voted in favor. Commissioners Moore, Williams, and Imperial voted against. - Item 11 (1657-1659 Mason Street): Discretionary Review Taken and Approved with Modifications (6-1). The project must shift massing west, reduce overall height by three feet, and reduce the stair/elevator tower. - Item 12 (1229 45th Avenue): Discretionary Review Not Taken; Project Approved (5-2). Commissioners Campbell, McGarry, Braun, Moore, and President Seo voted in favor. Commissioners Williams and Imperial voted against.

LAND USE 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 11% · PROCEDURAL 8%
612
SEP 26, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Regular Meeting - September 26, 2024

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on Thursday, September 26, 2024, at 6:15 PM, chaired by Supervisor Catherine Stephanie, with Supervisor Dorsey present and Vice Chair Joel Engardio excused. The committee considered three items: two liquor license applications and an ordinance to strengthen the Office of Victim and Witness Rights (OVWR). All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Consent Calendar - None. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public provided testimony on any agenda item. Discussion Items - Item 1 - Liquor License Transfer (1210 Union Street - Union & Hyde): Officer Fionas from the SFPD ABC Licensing Unit reported that the applicant, Union & Hyde, LLC, seeks a Type 21 off-sale general liquor license for a package store at 1210 Hyde Street. There were zero letters of protest or support. The area is in a low crime plot (523) but a high concentration census tract (109.01). The recommended conditions include monitoring to prevent loitering. Chair Stephanie noted that District 3 Supervisor Peskin had no objection. The committee voted unanimously to forward a positive recommendation to the full board. - Item 2 - Liquor License Issuance (3089-16th Street - Skylark): Officer Fionas presented the application by 3089 16th Street LLC for a Type 90 on-sale general music venue license for Skylark. Zero letters of protest or support. The location is in a high crime plot (414) and high concentration census tract (201.02). Mission Station had no opposition; the alcohol liaison unit recommended approval with conditions including noise control, litter maintenance, and requiring two uniformed security guards during live entertainment. Applicants Kimberly and Dave, the owners, spoke in support, noting they have operated for a year and wish to host 18+ events on select nights. Chair Stephanie stated District 9 Supervisor Ronan supports the application. The committee voted unanimously to forward a positive recommendation. - Item 3 - Ordinance: Administrative Code Amendments for OVWR and SHARP Integration: Chair Stephanie introduced legislation co-sponsored by Supervisor Ronan to clarify duties of OVWR, move the Office of Sexual Harassment and Assault Response and Prevention (SHARP) from the Human Rights Commission to OVWR, and require trauma-informed assistance for victims. Three non-substantive amendments were presented: (1) clarifying that OVWR cannot subpoena a crime victim for information; (2) exempting the DA's victim services division from the consolidation plan; and (3) requiring all employees, including the director, to interact directly with survivors of sexual assault/harassment to resolve complaints. Deputy City Attorney Christina Flettez Romo confirmed the amendments are non-substantive. Supervisor Dorsey expressed support. The committee voted unanimously to adopt the amendments and forward the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion carried (2-0, with Vice Chair Engardio excused) to direct the clerk to prepare a resolution finding the transfer serves public convenience or necessity and forward to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 2: Motion carried (2-0, with Vice Chair Engardio excused) to prepare a resolution finding issuance serves public convenience or necessity and forward with positive recommendation. - Item 3: Motion carried (2-0, with Vice Chair Engardio excused) to adopt the three amendments and forward the amended ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. The meeting adjourned at approximately 6:35 PM. Items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of October 8, 2024.

PROCEDURAL 41% · VICTIM SERVICES 36% · LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 23%
613
SEP 25, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting – September 25, 2024

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on September 25, 2024, to consider ten items, including contract amendments, grant acceptances, ground leases, and a hearing on mayoral reserve funds. All items were approved unanimously by the two present committee members (Chair Connie Chan and Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman) and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors. Supervisor Melgar was excused. Item 1: Pit Stop Workforce Development Grant Amendment - The committee approved an amendment to the contract with Hunters Point Family to provide workforce development and pit stop monitoring services. The amendment extends the term by nine months to June 30, 2025, and increases the contract amount by approximately $6.9 million to a new total not to exceed $16.2 million. In fiscal year 2024, the program recorded over 560,000 uses, 13,000 dog waste bags issued, 5,400 needles safely disposed, and 2,700 trash bags issued. The workforce development component had 206 participants, with 70% graduating, 40% promoted within the organization, and 20% obtaining employment with the city. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) noted that the grant was underspent by 17% last year due to pit stop closures from poor repair and supply delays. The resolution was approved and forwarded to the full board. Item 2: In-Kind Gift from Deloitte Tax LLP – Climate Tax Advisory Services - The committee authorized the Department of the Environment to accept an in-kind gift of pro bono tax services from Deloitte Tax LLP, valued at an estimated $112,089, to help the city identify federal tax credits for qualifying sustainability activities under the Inflation Reduction Act’s direct pay program. The engagement runs through May 31, 2025. The resolution was approved and forwarded. Item 3: California Jobs First Catalyst Grant – Retroactive Acceptance - The committee retroactively authorized the Office of Economic and Workforce Development to accept and expend a $14 million grant from the California Employment Development Department for the California Jobs First Catalyst program, covering May 1, 2024 through September 30, 2026. The grant is part of a $600 million state initiative focused on racial equity, carbon neutrality, and high-road training partnerships. The legislation also exempts subgrants from certain administrative code requirements to maintain regionalism and community-led planning. The resolution was approved and forwarded. Items 4-6: HIV/AIDS Research Grants – Retroactive Acceptance - The committee approved three retroactive grants for the Department of Public Health: (4) $173,063 from the National Institutes of Health through Florida State University for the Adolescent Medicine Trials Network for HIV/AIDS Interventions (December 2023 – November 2024); (5) $177,860 from the Department of Health and Human Services for MyPrEP Plus, a PrEP support tool for transgender women (September 2023 – September 2025); and (6) $160,074 from the National Institutes of Health for the Bridge Clinic, optimizing injectable PrEP delivery for transgender and non-binary people (April 2023 – January 2025). All three were approved and forwarded. Item 7: Ground Lease for 42 Otis Street – Permanent Supportive Housing for Young Adults - The committee approved a ground lease with Five Keys Schools and Programs for 42 Otis Street, a 24-unit building constructed in 2021, to operate as permanent supportive housing for young adults (ages 18-24) experiencing homelessness. The lease has an initial term of five years with 10 automatic extensions of five years each (maximum 55 years) at $1 annual rent. The site serves young adults, 68% of whom are unsheltered according to the most recent point-in-time count. The annual operating cost is estimated at $1.3 million, funded by HUD rental subsidies and local Prop C funds. The city received an $8 million Home Key award for the project. Public comment was overwhelmingly supportive. The resolution was approved and forwarded. Item 8: Ground Lease for 725 Davis Street – Commercial Space - The committee approved a 70-year ground lease (with a 24-year extension option) at $1 annual rent for a 1,240-square-foot commercial parcel at 725 Davis Street, to be developed into community-serving commercial space. The lease is with Broadway Davis Retail Associates LLC (a joint venture of John Stewart Company and Bridge Housing). The project sponsor will build out the space to a warm shell by early 2025 and then market it to small businesses, with a preference for a restaurant offering discounted food to nearby affordable housing residents. The resolution was approved and forwarded. Item 9: Acquisition and Ground Lease for 3300 Mission Street – Affordable Housing - The committee approved the city’s acquisition of three parcels (3300, 3306, 3308 Mission Street) for $4.151 million, a ground lease back to the developer for 75 years (plus a 24-year extension) at $1 annual rent, and a loan not to exceed $12.44 million for construction of a 35-unit 100% affordable housing development (all studios). The development, financed in part with 9% low-income housing tax credits, will serve households at 30-80% of area median income. The city also provided a $1 million limited payment guarantee to support the emerging developer team (Burnle Heights Neighborhood Center, Tabernacle Community Development Corporation, and Mitchellville Real Estate Group). The BLA noted that the project does not meet the NOFA goal of 25% homeless set-aside (no homeless units) and has a higher city subsidy per unit ($474,000 vs. $350,000 target), but supports smaller developers. A technical amendment was made to correct language in the resolution. The amended resolution was approved and forwarded. Item 10: Hearing on Grant Funds Placed on Mayoral Reserve - The committee held a hearing on the mayor’s decision to place funding for community-based organizations (CBOs) on reserve, affecting approximately $50 million in adback funds restored by the Board of Supervisors during the budget process. Representatives from the People’s Budget Coalition testified that the delay is causing layoffs, program closures, and loss of trust, and urged immediate release of funds. They highlighted specific programs at risk, including rental assistance, workforce development, youth services, arts funding, and the sugary drinks tax-funded programs. Mayor’s Budget Director Sophia Kittler explained that the reserve is intended to protect against future deficits (projected $800 million deficit in FY26-27) and to prioritize direct services and mid-contract programs. She provided a list of funds already released, including $250,000 from the sugary drink tax, $575,000 for arts grants, $2.7 million for DCYF violence intervention, and full release of neighborhood grocery access and code enforcement grants. She stated that remaining funds would be reviewed in December after revenue updates. Chair Chan challenged the mayor’s authority to withhold funds from a balanced budget, asserting that the decision is discretionary and reflects a choice to prioritize other initiatives over essential services for vulnerable populations. The hearing was filed.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 25% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 20% · HOMELESSNESS 12% · PROCEDURAL 9%
614
SEP 24, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - September 24, 2024

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on September 24, 2024, starting at 10:15 AM. The meeting included a consent agenda, multiple legislative items, a closed session regarding litigation with the EPA, and a special order hearing on a CEQA appeal for the 700 Indiana Street project. The board voted on various ordinances, resolutions, and motions, with several items passing after debate. Consent Calendar - Items 1 through 5 were approved unanimously (11-0). These included routine approvals such as park code amendments, tax-exempt certificates of participation (not to exceed $61,395,000), and surveillance technology policies for police and emergency management. Public Comments & Testimony - Closed Session (EPA lawsuit): Over 30 members of the public, including representatives from Sierra Club, Surfrider, and community organizations, urged the board to drop the city's lawsuit against the EPA. They argued that the lawsuit could weaken the Clean Water Act, harm public health, and damage San Francisco's environmental reputation. Several speakers shared personal stories of illness from sewage-contaminated water. No speakers supported the lawsuit. - 700 Indiana Street Appeal: Public comment was divided. Appellants and neighborhood representatives argued that the planning department failed to adequately review environmental impacts, particularly regarding shadow, air quality, and hazardous materials. Project supporters, including biotech workers, union representatives, and business groups, emphasized the need for lab space, job creation, and economic recovery, and noted that the project meets CEQA requirements. Discussion Items - Item 6 – Drone Ordinance (Unassisted Aerial Vehicles): Passed 9-2 with Supervisors Ronan and Walton voting no. Supervisor Preston expressed concern about data accuracy in findings, but the ordinance was approved on first reading. - Item 11 – Student Success Fund Grant ($26,519,360): Extended discussion about SFUSD transparency and use of funds. Supervisors Walton, Safai, and Ronan raised concerns about potential school closures and lack of accountability. DCYF Director Maria Sue and staff responded. The resolution was adopted after debate. - Item 21 – Vehicle Sideshow Ordinance: Passed on first reading. Supervisors Preston, Safai, and Walton criticized the ordinance as largely performative, noting existing laws. Supervisor Dorsey defended it as a clarifying tool. The board requested accurate findings be provided for second reading. - Closed Session (2:30 PM): The board convened to discuss the pending litigation with the U.S. EPA. After the session, the board voted 10-0 (Supervisor Peskin absent) to not disclose deliberations. - Special Order 3:00 PM – 700 Indiana Street CEQA Appeal: A public hearing was held on the appeal of a general plan evaluation (GPE) for a 70,650 sq ft biotech lab at 700 Indiana Street. Appellants argued the GPE was inadequate for failing to review shadow impacts on Dog Patch Arts Plaza, air quality mitigation, and hazardous materials. Planning department staff and project sponsor (MBC Biolabs) countered that the project was consistent with the Eastern Neighborhoods EIR and that all analyses were properly conducted. The board voted 2-8 against a motion to reverse the GPE (Supervisors Ronan and Walton in favor), and then voted 9-1 to affirm the planning department's determination (Supervisor Walton dissenting). The project's CEQA exemption was upheld. Key Outcomes - Consent Agenda: Approved unanimously (11-0). - Item 6 (Drones): Passed 9-2. - Item 7 (USDA Forest Service Grant): Passed 11-0. - Items 8-9 (Certificates of Participation & Parking Garage Management): Passed on same house same call. - Item 11 (Student Success Fund): Adopted after discussion. - Item 12 (Dementia Care Program): Adopted. - Item 13 (Workers' Comp Fraud Grant): Adopted. - Item 14 (Property Tax Rate): Adopted. - Item 15 (Commemorative Plaque): Passed. - Item 16 (Downtown Entertainment Activation): Passed. - Item 17 (Mike Chen appointment to SFMTA Board): Approved. - Item 18 (Urban Forestry Council Appointments): Approved. - Item 19 (Eleanor Blume appointment to Public Works Commission): Approved. - Item 21 (Vehicle Sideshow Ordinance): Passed on first reading; amendments to findings requested for second reading. - Closed Session: Board voted 10-0 not to disclose deliberations. - 700 Indiana Street Appeal: Motion to reverse GPE failed 2-8; motion to affirm GPE passed 9-1. - For Adoption Without Committee Reference (Items 28, 31, 32): Adopted. Items 29 (St. Vincent de Paul School Day) and 30 (USS Dianne Feinstein) were approved after separate votes. - Introductions: Supervisor Safai requested a hearing on SFUSD financial issues; Supervisor Chan introduced a resolution urging SFUSD to reconsider school closures; Supervisor Dorsey requested legislation on notification policies for permanent supportive housing. The meeting adjourned in memory of Rudy Saddleberger, Ed Donnelly, and Ali Reza Garavi.

PUBLIC EDUCATION 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW 13% · PUBLIC SAFETY 10%
615
SEP 24, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - September 24, 2024

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on Tuesday, September 24, 2024, at 9:30 AM with a quorum of three commissioners (President Paulson, Vice President Rivera, and Commissioner Stacy). The meeting included a land acknowledgment, approval of the September 10, 2024, minutes, general public comment, reports from the General Manager and staff, and action on several consent and regular calendar items. The commission also recognized three retiring employees with 25+ years of service and heard public comments on the city's lawsuit against the EPA and other matters. Consent Calendar - Item 7a: Amendment No. 4 to Contract CS-1101 with Yardi Systems, Inc. – software as a service agreement – approved unanimously. - Item 7b: Award Contract WD-2844 for 12-inch ductile iron water main installation on Parnassus Avenue to Basset Engineering ($8,118,045) – approved unanimously. - Item 7c: Accept work performed by D’Arcy & Harty Construction, Inc. under Contract WW-724 (Panhandle and Inner Sunset sewer rehabilitation) – approved unanimously. - Item 7d: Approve Modification No. 1 to Job Order Contract JOC-90 with GSW Construction, Inc. (additional time) – approved unanimously. - Item 7e: Award Contract WW-755 for Sunnydale Pump Station Safety Improvements to Anvil Builders, Inc. – approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Lane Figot (Sierra Club California, District 9 resident) urged the Commission, Mayor Breed, and City Attorney Chu to drop the lawsuit against the EPA, arguing it threatens the Clean Water Act and allows sewage releases into the Bay and ocean. - Francisco de Costa (45-year veteran) criticized the removal of commissioners, stating it undermines the SFPUC and cited billions in cost overruns (e.g., the source system rising from $8 billion to $12 billion). - Peter Dreckmeyer (Policy Director, Tuolumne River Trust) thanked outgoing commissioners, expressed concern that staff do not respond to Public Records Act requests and have not followed through on resolutions from 2019-2020 regarding biological goals and adaptive management for the Tuolumne River Voluntary Agreement. - Peter Dreckmeyer also commented on Item 5A, questioning why the drought surcharge was not planned to be removed given the wet conditions in January 2022 and total system storage at 81%. Discussion Items - Item 5: Report of the General Manager - 5a: FY 2023-24 Q4 Budget Status Report (Laura Bush, Deputy CFO): Water enterprise projected a net negative $12 million impact due to removal of drought surcharge, lower demand, and billing delays; wastewater and power enterprises showed positive results. Revenues delayed by $6.6 million each for water and wastewater due to meter issues. State grant funding of $8.2 million (water) and $11.6 million (wastewater) offset some shortfalls. Power enterprise saw $72.4 million positive net operating result. - 5b: Hetch Hetchy Capital Improvement Program Quarterly Report (Katie Miller): 17 projects in various stages; $339 million spent of $1 billion budget. One new cost variance of $13 million for the Moccasin Powerhouse systems upgrade. $85 million spent on major capital projects in FY24. Work continues on the 100-day shutdown of the Hetch Hetchy system (third of five). Tunnel concrete lining repair was 72% complete; contact grouting at 23%. - 5c: Employee Retirement Recognitions: Three employees with 25+ years of service recognized: Michael Broussard (29 years), Frank Marvich (28 years), and Anthony Scott (29 years). General Manager Herrera thanked outgoing commissioners for their service. - Item 6: Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA) Report (Nicole Sandkulla, outgoing GM): Announced passage of AB 2962 (extending state oversight on water system improvement program) and selection of Tom Smigel as new BAWSCA GM (starting December 1, 2024). Sandkulla thanked outgoing commissioners. - Items 8 & 9: Clean Water State Revolving Fund (SRF) Loan Agreements (presented jointly): - Item 8: $120.3 million installment sale agreement (including $8 million grant) for the New Treasure Island Wastewater Treatment Plant project. - Item 9: $59 million installment sale agreement (including $5 million principal forgiveness) for the Folsom Area Stormwater Improvement Project Phase 2. - Both loans at 2.1% interest, 30-year repayment, senior lien pledge. Combined with WIFIA financing. Approved unanimously. - Item 10: Amendment No. 1 to Contract PRO.0168.B (Kennedy/Jenks Consultants & AGS, Inc. JV): Increase of $10 million (total $17 million) for engineering services on five transmission pipeline projects. No additional time. Commissioners questioned cost escalation from original $5 million estimate; staff explained initial estimates were based on limited information and that condition assessments and safety requirements (e.g., double isolation valves) increased scope. Approved unanimously. - Item 11: Award Contract PRO.0239 (New City Distribution Division Campus at 2000 Marin): Construction management staff augmentation services to Consor PMCM, Inc. for $10,720,500 over 4 years 3 months. Commissioner Rivera raised a question about alternative fuel (hydrogen) for the fueling station; staff agreed to follow up. Approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Minutes Approved: The September 10, 2024, minutes were approved with two amendments (adding closed session announcement and clarifying mitigation monitoring program). - Consent Calendar Approved: Items 7a through 7e approved unanimously. - Items 8 & 9 Approved: Authorized the General Manager to execute installment sale agreements for SRF loans for the Treasure Island and Folsom projects. - Item 10 Approved: Contract amendment for transmission pipeline engineering services. - Item 11 Approved: Contract award for construction management staff augmentation. - Closed Session: The commission voted to assert attorney-client privilege and went into closed session regarding Gabriel Perez v. City and County of San Francisco. After closed session, the commission recommended Board approval of the settlement referenced in Item 16 and voted not to disclose the discussion. - Commissioner Farewells: President Paulson and Vice President Rivera acknowledged the pending end of their terms, with Commissioner Stacy thanking them for their service. General Manager Herrera also thanked outgoing commissioners for their professionalism.

PROCEDURAL 30% · ENGINEERING AND INFRASTRUCTURE 22% · PERSONNEL MATTERS 14% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 10%
616
SEP 23, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
Rules Committee Regular Meeting – September 23, 2024

Meeting started at 10:01 AM and was chaired by Supervisor Walton (Chair), with President Peskin (member) and Supervisor Safai excused. The committee considered three items: an appointment to the Child Care Planning and Advisory Council, an appointment to the Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee, and an ordinance strengthening the SFPUC Social Impact Partnership Program. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Appointment – Claudia Quinonez): One speaker strongly objected to the candidate, alleging that a forum on early childhood education organized by her employer (Children's Council) excluded the speaker and misrepresented a candidate. Another speaker (Alan Wong, Policy Director at Children's Council) supported the appointment, citing Quinonez's 16 years of experience in early childhood education, her role as a former child care subsidy recipient, and her current position as Chief Strategy and Impact Officer. - Item 2 (Appointment – Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee): Multiple speakers expressed support for both candidates. For Marty Dulales: representatives from SomCan (PJ Eugenio, Zachary Friol) highlighted her long history of community advocacy, her work as a community health ambassador, and her personal experience with the health impacts of sugary drinks. A friend (Nadia Baikova) and her mother (Teresa Dulales) also testified. For Melinda Burris: Laura Jones (Programs Manager, Leah's Pantry) and Marcusitu (Coordinator) supported her, citing her community engagement work on nutrition education, water access, and her experience on other advisory groups. - Item 3 (Ordinance – SFPUC Social Impact Partnership Program): No public comments were made. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Appointment to Child Care Planning and Advisory Council: Claudia Quinonez introduced herself, sharing her background as an immigrant, mother of two (including a child with disabilities), and early childhood education professional with 16 years of experience. She currently serves as Chief Strategy and Impact Officer at Children's Council of San Francisco. The committee expressed no questions and proceeded to a vote. - Item 2 – Appointment to Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee (Seat 3): Two candidates presented: Marty Dulales, a 30-year San Francisco resident and community advocate with experience in SomCan's health programs, and Melinda Burris, a 27-year-old from Bayview Hunters Point working as a community engagement specialist at Leah's Pantry. Both shared personal stories of family health struggles related to sugary drinks and described their community work. President Peskin noted the difficult choice and reminded that additional seats will open in December 2024. Supervisor Walton echoed that there will be more opportunities. - Item 3 – Ordinance Amendment – SFPUC Social Impact Partnership Program: Supervisor Walton, the sponsor, explained that the amendment clarifies that all covered contracts, regardless of solicitation date, must include social impact commitments, and that any amendment or modification increasing contract value triggers a proportional increase in those commitments. The amendment also removes the minimum threshold for triggering such increases. He emphasized that the program is intended to benefit communities disproportionately affected by SFPUC operations, particularly Bayview Hunters Point. President Peskin did not add comments. Key Outcomes - Item 1 – Motion to appoint Claudia Quinonez to the Child Care Planning and Advisory Council (with a residency waiver) passed unanimously (Walton and Peskin in favor; Safai excused). - Item 2 – Motion to appoint Melinda Burris to Seat 3 of the Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee passed unanimously (Walton and Peskin in favor; Safai excused). Supervisor Walton encouraged Marty Dulales to apply for upcoming vacancies in December 2024. - Item 3 – Motion to recommend the ordinance amending the Administrative Code for the SFPUC Social Impact Partnership Program to the full Board passed unanimously (Walton and Peskin in favor; Safai excused). The ordinance is expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda for October 1, 2024.

PUBLIC HEALTH 33% · EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION 17% · PROCEDURAL 16% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 15%
617
SEP 23, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use Committee Approves 555 Ninth Street Sign District on Sept. 23, 2024

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met and considered a single agenda item: an ordinance to establish the 555 Ninth Street Special Sign District, amending the Planning Code and Zoning Map to modify sign controls for the shopping center at 555 Ninth Street in the Show Place Square neighborhood. The ordinance is designed to improve signage for the shopping center, which is zoned UMU (Urban Mixed Use) and has struggled with high vacancy rates and tenant turnover. The committee adopted an amendment to limit sign illumination to business hours and forwarded the ordinance to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Discussion Items - Madison Tam, presenting the legislation, explained that the UMU zoning sign limitations are not conducive to large shopping centers, particularly those adjacent to a freeway. She noted that the center has suffered from high vacancy rates and tenant turnover, and that The Container Store has recently moved in, reflecting revitalization efforts. - Tam reported that Supervisor Dorsey requested a non-substantive amendment to add restrictions on illumination hours. The amendment, found on page 4, line 3, states that signs may be illuminated, non-illuminated, or indirectly or directly illuminated, but may only be illuminated during the business hours of the shopping center. - Veronica Flores, Planning Department staff, reported that the Planning Commission heard the item on July 18, 2024, and recommended approval. The commission expressed concerns about the impacts of illumination on adjacent neighbors, which led to the incorporated amendment. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public came forward to testify on the item. Key Outcomes - Chair Melgar made a motion to adopt the proposed amendment and send the ordinance to the full Board with a positive recommendation as amended. - The motion passed unanimously: Vice Chair Preston (aye), Member Peskin (aye), and Chair Melgar (aye). The tally was 3 ayes. - The item will be agendized at the Board of Supervisors meeting on October 1, 2024, unless otherwise stated.

LAND USE 55% · PUBLIC COMMENT 24% · PROCEDURAL 21%
618
SEP 20, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Special Meeting - September 20, 2024

A special meeting of the Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee was held on September 20, 2024, at 9:15 AM. The committee considered an ordinance amending the San Francisco Police Code to address vehicle sideshows, including prohibitions on promotion, assembly, presence, and interference with law enforcement, as well as vehicle seizure and sale. The item was sponsored by the Mayor's Office with co-sponsors Supervisors Stephanie and Dorsey (Vice Chair Engardio later added as co-sponsor). Commander Nicole Jones of the SFPD Special Operations Bureau presented the ordinance, describing sideshows as "vehicle insurrections" and emphasizing the need for additional enforcement tools. Two non-substantive amendments were introduced and adopted. The committee voted unanimously to forward the amended ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Discussion Items - Presentation by Commander Nicole Jones: Commander Jones, joined by Sergeant Dan Guzman and Lieutenant A.J. Holder, described the significant challenge of sideshows and dirt bike events since 2020, characterizing them as lawless "vehicle insurrections." She stated the ordinance provides "much needed tools and consequences" for enforcement. - Supervisor Dorsey: Expressed gratitude to SFPD and noted frustrations with limitations under state law, particularly regarding asset forfeiture. He emphasized the need for continued policy work at the state level to address urban density concerns. - Supervisor Engardio: Asked about distinguishing between spectators and participants. Commander Jones explained that spectators are integral to sideshows ("can't have a sideshow without people watching") and that officers can typically identify active participants based on behavior (e.g., cell phone use, arriving in caravans, cheering). Engardio also raised concerns about the ordinance being too broad, but Commander Jones stated she did not believe it was and that the department would evaluate its application. - Chair Supervisor Stephanie: Noted the presence of firearms at sideshows, including shots fired and injuries, and the danger of such events. Commander Jones confirmed that firearms are often seen and that other crimes are connected to sideshows. - Amendments: Deputy City Attorney Brad Russell confirmed the two amendments were non-substantive. The first amendment required SFPD to warn people of unlawful assembly before arresting (an existing requirement). The second corrected an administrative error on page 7, line 5, and page 8, lines 24-25, adding language about consent of private property owner and consistent with First Amendment. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were offered. Key Outcomes - Motion to amend: The committee voted unanimously (Vice Chair Engardio, aye; Member Dorsey, aye; Chair Stephanie, aye) to adopt the two non-substantive amendments. - Motion to forward to full board: The committee voted unanimously to forward the amended ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors as a committee report with a positive recommendation. The item is expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on October 1, 2024, and will be presented as a committee report at the September 24, 2024 Board of Supervisors meeting.

TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 61% · PROCEDURAL 23% · PUBLIC SAFETY 16%
619
SEP 19, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - September 19, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission held its regular meeting on Thursday, September 19, 2024, at 2:15 PM. The meeting covered a wide range of items including continuances, consent calendar approvals, a contested election of officers, and several major land use and conditional use authorizations. The commission voted on a new president, approved a senior housing special use district, rescinded a child care condition, and approved a dialysis center, among other items. A contentious vote on the replacement of a legacy business at 200 Capp Street passed 4-3. Consent Calendar - Items 3, 4, and 5 were approved by a unanimous 7-0 vote. Item 6 (Central Soma Area Plan initiation) was pulled from consent by Commissioner Imperial and considered separately. Election of Officers - The commission held an election for president following the departure of former President Sue Diamond. After public comment, Commissioner McGarry nominated Commissioner Lydia So, and Commissioner Imperial nominated Vice President Catherine Moore. The vote was 4-3 in favor of Commissioner So as president (Commissioners Campbell, McGarry, So, Braun in favor; Williams, Imperial, Moore against). Commissioner Braun then nominated Commissioner Moore for vice president, which passed unanimously 7-0. Commissioner So became the new president, and Commissioner Moore continued as vice president. Public Comments & Testimony - Election of Officers: Several public speakers supported Commissioner So, citing her experience on multiple commissions and representation of the AAPI community. Others supported Commissioner Moore, emphasizing her 18 years on the commission and expertise on housing element upzonings. One speaker requested deferral for a rules discussion. - New Asia Senior Housing SUD: Multiple speakers, including representatives of Chinatown community organizations, expressed strong support for the 100% affordable senior housing project, noting the need for affordable housing and a banquet hall for cultural events. - 740 Sanchez Street: A neighbor from Dolores Heights spoke in support, noting the project’s sensitivity and adherence to the special use district. - 1830 Ocean Avenue Dialysis Center: Patients and medical professionals spoke in support, emphasizing the need for continued dialysis access. A resident from the condominium above opposed, citing concerns about mechanical noise and property management. - 200 Capp Street (Kiitos Bar): Extensive public comment. Supporters cited activation of vacant space and economic benefits. Opponents, including former owners of the legacy business Uptown and community members, accused the landlord of predatory practices, forced displacement, and Ellis Act evictions. Some spoke of the bar’s cultural significance. Discussion Items - Central Soma Area Plan Initiation: Commissioner Imperial requested removal from consent to ensure community engagement. The commission voted unanimously to initiate the general plan amendment and schedule a hearing on or after October 9, 2024, with staff to conduct outreach to stakeholders. - New Asia Senior Housing Special Use District (758-772 Pacific Avenue): The department recommended approval of the SUD to allow up to 155 feet height for 175 affordable senior units. The project includes a restored banquet hall. Commissioners praised the project as a model for community-driven development. The motion to approve with an amendment to the title passed 7-0. - 2024 Code Corrections Ordinance: Staff presented the annual ordinance to fix errors and clarify code language. A public commenter requested an additional amendment for a self-storage project at 2270 McKinnon. The commission voted 7-0 to approve with staff modifications, directing staff to work with the applicant on the proposed amendment. - 345 Spear Street Child Care Condition Rescindment: The commission considered a request to remove a condition requiring a nonprofit child care provider. The current for-profit provider, Bright Horizons, has operated since 2003. The department recommended approval to avoid enforcement action that could close the center. The motion passed 6-1, with Commissioner Williams dissenting. - 740 Sanchez Street CUA and Variance: A conditional use authorization for a vertical addition exceeding 3,000 square feet and a variance for rear yard encroachment. The project was supported by the department and a neighbor. Commissioners noted the contextual design and difficulty of adding an ADU. The motion passed 7-0, and the zoning administrator granted the variance. - 1830 Ocean Avenue Dialysis Center: A conditional use authorization for a health services use (dialysis clinic) with early morning hours (5 AM). The department recommended approval, noting the activation of a vacant Target space and relocation of an existing clinic. Public testimony raised concerns about noise and traffic, but the applicant addressed mechanical systems and coordinated with SFMTA for a new passenger loading zone. The motion passed 7-0. - 200 Capp Street (Kiitos Bar): A conditional use authorization to replace the legacy business Uptown bar with a new bar. The department recommended approval despite opposition. Commissioners debated the lack of protection for legacy businesses and the difficulty of denying based on the landlord’s reputation. The motion to approve passed 4-3 (Commissioners Campbell, McGarry, Braun, So in favor; Williams, Imperial, Moore against). Key Outcomes - Election of Officers: Lydia So elected President (4-3); Catherine Moore re-elected Vice President (7-0). - Central Soma Initiation: Initiated (7-0), hearing scheduled for on or after October 9, 2024. - New Asia Senior Housing SUD: Approved (7-0), including title amendment to “758 and 772 Pacific Avenue Affordable Senior Housing SUD.” - 2024 Code Corrections Ordinance: Approved with staff modifications (7-0), with direction to consider additional amendment. - 345 Spear Street Child Care Condition: Rescinded (6-1). - 740 Sanchez Street CUA and Variance: Approved (7-0) with conditions; variance granted. - 1830 Ocean Avenue Dialysis Center: Approved (7-0) with conditions. - 200 Capp Street Kiitos Bar: Approved (4-3) with conditions.

LAND USE 19% · PROCEDURAL 15% · LEGACY BUSINESS 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11%
620
SEP 19, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
San Francisco Gov't Audit & Oversight Committee Reviews Civil Grand Jury Reports - Sept 19, 2024

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston and joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Connie Chan, held a regular meeting on September 19, 2024, starting at 9:00 AM. The committee heard presentations and responses on five civil grand jury reports from the 2023-2024 term, covering flood management, city commissions, infrastructure, budget and governance, and illegal fireworks. The committee also received public comment and voted on board responses. The civil grand jury foreperson, Michael Carboy, noted that the jury's 19 members (5 women, 14 men) contributed approximately 18,400 work hours and conducted over 260 interviews. He expressed concern that 75% of the jury's findings were fully or partially disagreed with by city departments. Public Comments & Testimony - Dr. Himsa Porter Sum Chai (Hunters Point Biomonitoring Program) urged recognition of current flooding impacts, citing damage from atmospheric storms in 2022-2023 at his property in District 10, and submitted findings of atomic bomb radioactivity residues in community members. - Shirlita Holmes Box emphasized that flooding is a present reality, not a future threat, and submitted photos of the atmospheric river in District 10. She noted groundwater mercury contamination from the Navy and called for city-wide attention. - Brian Adam (resident) recommended consulting city staff when implementing process changes and cited existing examples of coordination (Office of Civic Engagement and Immigrant Affairs, Controller's auditing division) that could be expanded. Discussion Items 1. Flood Management (Items 1 & 2) – Civil Grand Jury Report: "Come Hell or High Water" - Grand Jury Presentation (Ralph Lane): The jury found that Climate SF governance is inadequate for implementation, funding for adaptation is hampered by a self-imposed debt cap, formal flood coordination is lacking, and the city fails to communicate climate impacts. The mayor's detailed response disagreed with all four findings sent to her, despite her letter agreeing. The jury urged the board to use oversight authority and consider increasing general obligation bond capacity. Over 23,000 residents are at risk of inland flooding; the Army Corps waterfront study estimates $13.5 billion in total costs, with the city responsible for a portion. - City Response (Brian Strong, Office of Resilience and Capital Planning): Strong partially disagreed with findings, noting existing coordination through Climate SF (since 2019) and the Sea Level Rise and Flood Hazard Coordinating Committee. He emphasized the city's 10-year capital plan and debt policy (only issuing new bonds as old ones retire) has been successful, with over 90% bond approval. He acknowledged the need for better project identification and funding for climate adaptation, but noted fiscal constraints. - Controller (Greg Wagner): Explained that the debt cap is a policy decision that has built stakeholder confidence. He noted there is room under the state's 3% assessed value limit for general obligation bonds. - SFPUC (Sarah Minick): Described a recently launched governance and policy project to develop a more holistic flood management structure, with case studies and stakeholder engagement. - Port of San Francisco (Adam Barrett): Discussed the Waterfront Resilience Program and the Army Corps study. The draft plan released in January 2024 recommended $13.5 billion in adaptation strategies. The city is working on a non-federal funding plan. - Board Discussion: Vice Chair Stefani led the item. Supervisor Chan asked about incorporating the Army Corps plan into the capital plan. Chair Preston noted the debt cap is a policy choice that could be revisited, especially if Proposition 5 (lowering bond approval threshold from 2/3 to 55%) passes. The board proposed responses partially disagreeing with findings F1, F3, F5, F6, and agreeing with F4. 2. City Commissions (Items 3 & 4) – Civil Grand Jury Report: "Commission Impossible?" - Grand Jury Presentation (John Monson and Niall Murphy): The jury found no current accurate list of active commissions, too many commissions, and poor management due to lack of single oversight authority. They recommended the city attorney publish an accurate annual list (with the "three A's": accurate, active, annual) and create a permanent commission oversight body. The jury noted that the city attorney's list, even after a July 2024 correction, still does not comply with the 2014 and 2024 grand jury recommendations. They also recommended standardizing training, performance evaluations, and annual reports. - City Response (Sophia Kittler, Mayor's Budget Director): The mayor's office agrees that commissions are essential and that reform is needed, but believes a comprehensive charter reform initiative (expected in 2026) is the proper vehicle. They disagreed with performance evaluations for commissions and with standardizing annual reports. They noted that the city attorney already publishes a list and that the mayor's office monitors commissions. - City Administrator (Sophie Hayward): The 311 database lists commissions, but relies on department updates. - Board Discussion: Chair Preston led the item. He acknowledged the need for a comprehensive list but noted existing efforts by the city administrator, city attorney, and clerk of the board. He expressed caution about eliminating commissions without considering their policy origins (e.g., Housing Stability Fund Oversight Board). He proposed responses generally disagreeing partially with findings F1, F2, F3, F5, F7, F9, and agreeing with F4, F6, F8. Many recommendations were not implemented pending the November 2024 election outcomes and charter reform. The board agreed to further analyze R1.2 (improving the database) and R9.1 (training) within six months. 3. Infrastructure (Items 5 & 6) – Civil Grand Jury Report: "Building San Francisco" - Grand Jury Presentation (Mr. McCaw): The jury's three main intentions: 1) Provide the Public Works Commission with a roadmap for oversight of large capital projects, 2) Encourage proper funding of the Capital Planning Fund, 3) Improve information on financial and operational impacts of degraded assets. The jury recommended better public transparency on project evolution, a realistic assessment of degraded assets, and increased capital planning fund budget. The city disagreed with most recommendations, but the jury urged discussion on how to achieve these goals. - City Response (Brian Strong, Sophie Hayward, Nicholas King): The city acknowledged finite resources and competing priorities. They described the 10-year capital plan and the Facility Resource Renewal Model that estimates building subsystem life. The Capital Planning Fund has been used but is strained by many bond projects. DPW provides its rates to client departments upon request, but does not publicly post a formal report. The city believes existing transparency measures are sufficient. - Board Discussion: Vice Chair Stefani led. She noted that many responses were "will not be implemented" but urged continued dialogue. The board partially disagreed with finding F1 (degraded assets) and deferred action on R1.5 (mandatory biannual reporting) pending analysis by the Office of Resilience and Capital Planning, with a decision due within one year. 4. Budget and Governance (Items 7 & 8) – Civil Grand Jury Report: "Lifting the Fog" - Grand Jury Presentation (Paul Dravis): The jury found that budget oversight responsibilities need improvement, the city administrator's role is ambiguously defined, siloed departments hinder service delivery, and there is no formal process for assessing benefits of legislation. They noted that the city has two inconsistent org charts, and that voter-mandated spending constraints create challenges. They recommended clarifying the city administrator's role, possibly adding deputy mayors, and improving cost-benefit analysis. - City Response (Sophia Kittler): The mayor's office agrees that governance is complex and that cross-departmental coordination is a challenge. They believe these issues should be addressed through comprehensive charter reform, not piecemeal. They will not implement the specific recommendation for additional cost-benefit analysis beyond the BLA's fiscal impact, as benefits are inherently political. The December 2024 timeline is unrealistic. - Board Discussion: Supervisor Chan led. She agreed with the findings on budget oversight, city administrator ambiguity, and siloing. She noted that unfunded mandates and set-asides should be revisited. The board proposed responses agreeing with findings F1, F2, and F4, and not implementing recommendations R1.4, R2.1, and R4.2 because they depend on charter amendments or duplicative of existing executive directive. 5. Illegal Fireworks (Item 9) – Civil Grand Jury Report: "Uncontrolled Burn" - Grand Jury Presentation (Bart Fisher): The jury found lack of interdepartmental coordination, conflicting public messaging on reporting, inadequate public education, failure to stop deployments at known hotspots, and failure to gather metrics. They recommended a working group headed by the Department of Emergency Management and metrics tracked by the Controller's Office. The city disagreed partially with more than half the findings and did not implement the working group, calling it "duplicative." The jury noted that other cities have successful task forces, civil penalties, public reporting apps, and targeted media campaigns. - City Response (Sophia Kittler, Jackie Thorntell - DEM, Captain Jonathan Baxter - SFFD): The city acknowledged that coordination and messaging have improved since the report, especially around July 4th. DEM is working on year-round messaging, including for Lunar New Year. Reporting is via 311 (unless life safety). The fire department is committed to reducing illegal fireworks and their harms. - Board Discussion: Supervisor Chan led. She emphasized the year-round nature of the problem and the need for education on impacts on veterans, people with dementia, and pets. The board filed the hearing (no resolution required from the board). Key Outcomes - Items 1 & 2 (Flood Management): The hearing (Item 1) was continued to the call of the chair. The resolution (Item 2) was forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation (3-0 vote; all present: Preston, Stefani, Chan) with the responses as read by Vice Chair Stefani. - Items 3 & 4 (Commissions): The hearing (Item 3) was continued to the call of the chair. The resolution (Item 4) was forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0) with the responses as read by Chair Preston, amended to include a six-month timeline for analysis of R1.2 and R9.1. - Items 5 & 6 (Infrastructure): The hearing (Item 5) was continued to the call of the chair. The resolution (Item 6) was forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation (2-0, with Supervisor Chan absent) with the responses as read by Vice Chair Stefani. - Items 7 & 8 (Budget & Governance): The hearing (Item 7) was filed. The resolution (Item 8) was forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0) with the responses as read by Supervisor Chan. - Item 9 (Illegal Fireworks): The hearing was heard and filed (3-0). No board resolution was required.

GOVERNMENT TRANSPARENCY 15% · CAPITAL PLANNING 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11% · CLIMATE ADAPTATION 11%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com