Public Meetings - Alameda County, California

The Unincorporated Services Committee (Supervisors Miley and Tam) convened a special meeting on December 10, 2025, with all Municipal Advisory Councils (Castro Valley, Fairview, Eden Area) and the Sunol Citizens Advisory Council to receive the findings and recommendations from the Budget Justice Coalition's pilot budget input process. The meeting included a detailed presentation, extensive deliberation by MAC members, and public testimony. No formal votes were taken, but Supervisors Miley and Tam outlined several next steps. Presentation by Budget Justice Coalition - Claudia Albano (Deputy Chief of Staff for Supervisor Miley), Alina Farouk, Dave Thompson, Sandra Archuletta, and Natalie Kim presented the report. - Process: Six community meetings (September–October 2025) and a survey yielded input from 106 meeting participants and 142 survey respondents. Three key questions guided discussions: major issues, desired changes to county services, and messages for the Board of Supervisors. - Top concerns from survey: 50% cited enforcing local codes (dumping, habitability, zoning); 46% safer roadways for pedestrians/bicyclists; two-thirds prioritized public works (road maintenance, infrastructure); concerns about emergency preparedness; 44% wanted clearer ownership/coordination of responsibilities. - 12 recommendations were grouped into short-, medium-, and long-term categories, including codifying a community budget input process, creating an office of unincorporated communities (already under consultant study), a public service culture shift, a communication hub, and improvements to physical infrastructure and local governance. Public Comments & Testimony - Over 30 public speakers addressed the committee. Many expressed support for the recommendations, especially the formal budget input process and the office of unincorporated communities. Several speakers from the Eden area and Ashland/Cherryland emphasized the need for equitable services, better code enforcement, traffic safety, and a centralized communication hub. - Some speakers (e.g., Bruce King) stressed transparency; others (e.g., Peter Rosen) had questions about the office's authority and relationship with MACs. - A few speakers (e.g., Bobby from Fairview) criticized the MAC process for not taking public comment before forming opinions. Multiple young community members spoke passionately in support of the budget input process. Discussion Items - MAC Member Deliberations: Members from Castro Valley, Fairview, Eden, and Sunol raised various points: - Chuck (Castro Valley) emphasized that Castro Valley has strong relationships with county departments but expressed frustration that supervisors from non-unincorporated areas vote on unincorporated issues. - Sally (Fairview) noted the long history of community engagement in Fairview and urged that MAC recommendations be taken more seriously. - Dan (Castro Valley) cautioned that many budget funds are already designated and that community organizations need accurate data; he also questioned the low survey response rate (0.02% of unincorporated population). - Taylor (Eden MAC) highlighted the need for equal treatment and criticized short notice for budget workshop meetings. - Chris (Fairview) shared a multi-year saga on D Street sidewalks to illustrate the difficulty of getting projects completed. - Vanessa (Fairview) suggested leveraging existing MAC infrastructure rather than creating new bureaucracy. - Tojo (Castro Valley) called for streamlined business permits and more power for MACs. - County Staff Responses: Melanie Atendito (Deputy County Administrator) explained the county's maintenance of effort policy, limited discretionary funds, and the challenges of a structural funding gap. Hank Levy (Treasurer-Tax Collector) offered to be a personal contact for business license issues. Key Outcomes - Supervisor Miley's Proposed Next Steps (endorsed by Supervisor Tam): 1. Budget Input Process: Refer to the Budget Committee (Supervisors Tam and Halbert) to work with the County Administrator's Office to improve the annual unincorporated budget input process, incorporate MACs, and report back to the Unincorporated Services Committee in 2026. 2. Office of Unincorporated Communities: Continue the already-approved consultant study (6-month scope); no decisions have been made on whether to create the office. 3. Recommendations 3–12: Refer these to relevant county departments (Public Works, Community Development Agency, Fire, Sheriff, Library) for review and to report back at a future Unincorporated Services Committee meeting. 4. MAC Decision-Making Authority: Explore giving MACs additional powers, such as area planning commission or BZA authority, while considering staff capacity implications. - Supervisor Miley also noted that the county's budget constraints (e.g., Prop 1, federal cuts, health system deficits) will influence all future decisions. The meeting adjourned at approximately 9:30 PM.

The Eden Area MAC met on December 10, 2025, at 6:00 PM. The meeting included a California Highway Patrol quarterly update, a vote on public art for Fire Station 22, a presentation on inclusionary zoning and ministerial review for affordable housing, and decisions on two conditional use permits. The meeting adjourned at 8:59 PM. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes (November 13, 2025): The council approved the minutes with corrections, including adding a question about parking at the Lorenzo Theater and clarifying that the Sky West property issue had been previously discussed at the Eden Area MAC. Motion passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Angelica Gonzalez (Alameda County Planning): Announced a community meeting on January 15, 2026, from 6-8 PM at the Ashland Reach Youth Center to discuss the future development of the Bay Fair BART parking lot. - Keith Barrows (online): Urged the board to involve Public Works in enforcement of sidewalk food vendor ordinances, stating that Public Works has the manpower and equipment needed for meaningful enforcement. - Glenda (in-person): Expressed concern about large groups of youth on bicycles blocking traffic on International Boulevard, kicking cars, and being disrespectful. She requested that authorities increase patrols and that information on reporting be distributed to neighborhoods. - Zanetta Williams (online): Raised concerns about 18-wheelers illegally using 580 and asked for increased enforcement. Officer Paps agreed to enter a traffic complaint and notify the commercial unit. - Brooklyn (online): Asked if there is a public data portal for CHP statistics in unincorporated areas. Officer Paps stated that statistics are only provided in the tables presented. - Michael Moore (in-person): Commented on the public art proposal, noting only one flagpole and suggesting additional flagpoles or taller ones to include Alameda County and community flags. - Randy Waggy (in-person): Expressed support for the public art selection process and artist David Burke, stating the design was the most representative of San Lorenzo and firefighters. - Michael Moore (in-person, on Maury Manor): Criticized the facility as an example of what is wrong with society, calling it a place to "stash people to die," and noted inadequate parking and lack of oversight. - Zanetta Williams (online, on Maury Manor): Defended the facility, stating it provides necessary care for families who cannot provide 24-hour care, and asked about emergency protocols for multiple simultaneous medical events. Discussion Items - California Highway Patrol Quarterly Update (Officer Paps): Presented year-to-date statistics for unincorporated Eden Area (San Lorenzo, Cherryland, Hayward Acres, Ashland). 2025 numbers were slightly lower due to an influx of trainees, but injury crashes declined. CHP led the state in DUI arrests on Halloween night (24 arrests in 24 hours). The RESET task force (with Sheriff's Office, San Leandro PD, Hayward PD) has prevented large sideshow takeovers. Officer Paps noted that the Castro Valley office consolidation has improved service. Council members asked about coordination with other agencies, specific area trends, and traffic complaint tracking. Officer Paps agreed to provide more data on freeway enforcement (580 vs. 880) and hours spent on traffic complaints. - Alameda County Arts Commission – Public Art for Fire Station 22 (Rachel Imai): Presented the final recommendation of artist David Burke and his artwork proposal for the new Fire Station 22 in San Lorenzo. The artwork will be hand-painted porcelain enamel on steel, depicting local landmarks (duck pond, Sycamore leaf) and firefighter heritage. The selection committee included community members and fire department staff. The council voted unanimously to endorse the recommendation. - Introduction to Inclusionary Zoning and Ministerial Review of Affordable Housing (Angelica Gonzalez, Olivia Ortiz): Presented an overview of the county's effort to develop affordable housing production policies, including inclusionary zoning (requiring a percentage of affordable units in new developments) and expanded ministerial approval (expedited review for projects exceeding affordability requirements). The project is funded by a $400,000 MTC grant and will run through July 2027. The council discussed potential impacts on development, the need for economic feasibility studies, and the importance of avoiding complexity. Council members expressed support for the effort but raised concerns about unintended consequences. The council voted to create an ad hoc subcommittee and appointed Warren and Taylor as representatives. - Conditional Use Permit – Maury Manor (William, Planning): Request for continued operation of a residential care facility for up to 14 individuals at 1476 164th Avenue. The facility had a lapsed CUP since 2010 and 17 deficiencies identified by the Sheriff's Office in 2023, which were resolved by the new administrator. The council heard from the administrator, Mariano Lotore, who described improvements in compliance and care. After discussion, the council approved the CUP for three years (motion amended from one year to three). - Conditional Use Permit – Massage Parlor (William, Planning): Request for continued operation of a massage business at 16242 East 14th Street. The business has two certified massage therapists, no complaints, and passed joint inspections. The council approved the CUP for three years unanimously. Key Outcomes - Minutes Approved: With corrections, unanimous. - CHP Update: Received as information; Officer Paps to provide additional freeway data and traffic complaint hours. - Public Art Endorsement: Motion to endorse artist David Burke and his proposal for Fire Station 22 passed unanimously. - Affordable Housing Policies: Council voted to create an ad hoc subcommittee and appointed Warren and Taylor as members. The subcommittee will work with other MACs and county staff over 18 months. - Maury Manor CUP: Approved for three years (motion by Ray, seconded by Elizabeth, amended to three years, passed unanimously). - Massage Parlor CUP: Approved for three years (motion by Elizabeth, seconded by Megan, passed unanimously). - Council Reports: Warren suggested discussing an economic development subcommittee in the future. Ray thanked staff for new parks, public works presentations, CHP updates, and ongoing language policy work.

The Alameda County Board of Supervisors' Ad Hoc Committee on Reparations (Supervisors Marquez and Miley) convened on December 10, 2025, at 4:15 p.m. to receive three informational updates: (1) the commission's work plan and progress, (2) the budget and expenditures, and (3) early survey results and digital presence. The committee heard presentations from Chair Gore, Principal Consultant Letitia Henderson (ECC), Vice Chair McClendon, and Commissioners. No public comment was offered. Discussion Items Work Plan Update – Chair Gore reported that the commission consolidated from 11 to three subcommittees (Admin & Budget, Listening Sessions, Data Research Action Plan) organized around four pillars: experience of harm/inequity, community assets/resiliency, reparative needs/priorities, and vision for the future. Consultant Letitia Henderson described three phases of work (launch, organize, report) and highlighted milestones completed between October and December 2025, including four of six community listening sessions (with more than 175 total attendees), a rough draft outline of the report, and over 70 survey responses collected in person. She noted that 80% of key tasks per subcommittee have been completed. The target date for a draft action plan is June 30, 2026. Budget and Fiscal Stewardship – Vice Chair McClendon presented the budget: of the $500,000 allocated by the Board, $155,038 has been spent, leaving a remaining balance of $34,961 planned for final district sessions, pop-ups, the Black Joy Parade, the final report design, and contingency. Major expenditures include technical assistance ($73,886), website development (with internal data collection features to avoid third-party platforms), translation/transcription, food, and a therapist at listening sessions. McClendon praised the library and county staff for transparent billing and vendor discounts. The commission aims to be fiscally responsible and spend down the remaining balance before the end of the fiscal year. Survey Data and Digital Presence – Early survey results (86 responses, over half from the Taylor Memorial session) showed strong support for scholarship/grants and direct compensation (98th percentile), increased county program funding, public apology/acknowledgment, and memorial/commemoration. Open-ended responses frequently cited taxes, housing/land, policy/systemic changes, education, health care, mental health, and trauma. The commission has built a website, LinkedIn, Facebook, and Instagram presence; a digital survey is being launched to expand reach. A talk show appearance (“Talk of the Town”) is scheduled for December 17, 2025, and a Kwanzaa event is planned. Pop-Up Sessions and Open Seats – The commission discussed adding pop-up listening sessions, including a request from Supervisor Marquez for Hayward. Commissioners confirmed that any commissioner can organize a pop-up using the established structure (run of show, slide deck, videographer, notetaker). Two commissioner seats are vacant due to resignation or attendance issues; the commission requested the Ad Hoc Committee’s help in filling them, ideally with a younger candidate (20–30 age range). Key Outcomes - The committee commended the commission’s progress, momentum, and fiscal responsibility. - Supervisor Miley expressed strong support but reiterated he would not interfere with the commission’s work until the final report is submitted; he noted the board may consider additional resources if needed, citing recent contributions to the Russell City Fund. - The committee directed staff to work with the commission to schedule the next update in March 2026 (tentatively March 13 or a Wednesday in March at 4 p.m.). - No formal votes were taken; all items were informational. - The commission will hold an annual check-in/retreat on January 31, 2026, to plan the final six months.

The Alameda County Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, December 9, 2025, starting at 9:30 AM. The meeting included board remarks, extensive public comment on multiple agenda items, discussion and decisions on consent calendar items, a contested open space grant, several ordinance readings, and closed session matters. Key outcomes included approval of the consent calendar, ratification of an Altamont Landfill Open Space grant, reauthorization of the treasurer's investment authority, appointment of a new county librarian, and direction to recruit separate registrars of voters and chief information officers. Consent Calendar - Items 93 through 102 were approved unanimously by roll call vote. - Item 52 was corrected to remove the word "amendment" and read as executing a contract with Triple A Generator Services. Public Comments & Testimony - Support for Item 34 (Altamont Hills property grant): Multiple speakers including Rebecca Spector (Tri-Valley Conservancy), Tamara Rose, Gina Bonanno, and Diana Roberts urged the board to ratify a $500,000 grant from the Altamont Landfill Open Space Committee for acquisition of the 32-acre Altamont Hills property. Speakers emphasized the property's value for wildlife habitat, biodiversity, a wildlife corridor, and scenic views. - Concern over fair horse racing (closed session item): George Schmidt, David Elliott, Anthony Cordova, Johnny Tagata, and others stated the Alameda County Fair Association plans to not offer horse racing in 2026, which they argued violates Paragraph M of the 2017 contract. They asked the board to enforce the contract or pursue litigation. - Support for Item 61 (treasurer investment authority reauthorization): A majority of public speakers (Lori Weinstock, Jean Moses, Jake Peterson, Bob Johnson, Tim Drew, Ed Romano, Michael Seldon, and others) expressed strong support for Treasurer Hank Levy, praising his performance (e.g., $400 million income last fiscal year, highest in pool history) and urging the board to reauthorize his investment authority without further delay. Many also called for immediate implementation of the Ethical Investment Policy (EIP) approved October 3, 2025, and characterized critics as politically motivated or misinformed. - Opposition to Item 61: Few speakers (Chris Moore, Robert Edelman, Lara Gabriel) questioned the treasurer's transparency and returns, arguing the county's peer analysis ranks near the bottom and that independent oversight is needed. Chris Moore, who identified himself as holding an MBA in finance, claimed Treasurer Levy misrepresented performance data. - Other comments: Simeon Ramey spoke on mental health housing needs; an online speaker criticized construction-related bus disruption in Oakland; and a speaker raised procedural concerns about public comment time limits. Discussion Items - Item 34 – Altamont Landfill Open Space Grant: The board considered the Altamont Landfill Open Space Committee's recommendation to approve a $500,000 grant to the Tri-Valley Conservancy (TVC) to purchase the Altamont Hills property (32 acres of grassland in unincorporated Alameda County, listed at $1.05 million, with two appraisals of $872,500 and $876,500). President Halbert expressed concerns about the lack of a purchase contract and the requested amount exceeding appraised value. TVC's executive director explained they need the grant committed to negotiate a short 30-day close and will not pay more than appraised value. After debate, President Halbert withdrew his initial motion to send the item back to the committee, and instead moved to approve the grant with the condition that the purchase price not exceed the appraised value of $876,500. The motion passed unanimously (5-0). - Item 54 – Specialized Transportation Services Contract: The board discussed a staff recommendation to award contracts to Ride Trans (local San Leandro-based) and a Washington D.C.-based firm for five levels of non-emergency medical transport for individuals in the LPS conservatorship pathway. Supervisor Miley expressed reluctance because only two vendors applied and one is out-of-state, but acknowledged specialized needs (e.g., locked assisted transport with EMT supervision). The motion passed on a 5-0 vote with Supervisor Miley voting "reluctant yes." - Item 61 – Reauthorization of Treasurer's Investment Authority: The board debated the annual ordinance to delegate investment authority to Treasurer Hank Levy. County counsel explained that if not renewed by December 31, the board would become the fiduciary and prudent investor standard would apply to them. Supervisors Fortunato Bass and others praised the treasurer's performance and supported delegation. Supervisor Halbert stressed the importance of the ethical investment policy review process (Financial Oversight Committee and potential peer review). The ordinance passed on first reading (5-0). - Item 67 – Decoupling Registrar of Voters and Chief Information Officer: The board approved separate recruitments for the positions of Registrar of Voters and Chief Information Officer (currently held by one person). The related salary ordinance amendments sunset the 25% pay differential and adjust salaries based on a recent review. The motion passed unanimously. - Item 65 – Appointment of County Librarian: The board unanimously appointed Deborah Sika as County Librarian effective December 7, 2025, at a bi-weekly salary of $9,205.60. Sika had served as acting librarian for 20 months. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar Items 93-102: Approved unanimously. - Item 34 – Altamont Hills Grant Approved: The board approved a grant of up to $500,000 to the Tri-Valley Conservancy for acquisition of the Altamont Hills property, contingent on the purchase price not exceeding the appraised value ($876,500). (Vote: 5-0) - Item 40 – Ordinance on Pre-Election Residency Requirement: Approved on first reading. - Item 54 – Specialized Transportation Contracts: Approved for Ride Trans and the out-of-state vendor for three years. (Vote: 5-0) - Item 56 – Salary Ordinance Amendment: Adopted on second reading. - Item 61 – Treasurer Investment Authority Reauthorization: Approved on first reading (5-0). - Item 65 – Appointment of Deborah Sika as County Librarian: Unanimous. - Item 67 – Separate Recruitments for Registrar of Voters and CIO: Approved along with salary ordinance amendments. - Item 87 – Traffic Code Amendment: Approved on first reading. - Item 89 – Building Code Updates: Approved on first reading. - Closed Session: No reportable actions; the board recessed into closed session twice, and at the end of the meeting reported a settlement in Gonzalez et al. v. A. Hearn et al. for $300,000 (unanimous vote on Feb 27, 2024).

The Health Committee met on Monday, December 8, 2025, at approximately 9:45 AM. The meeting covered three agenda items: the fourth annual report on Measure A1 (action item), an update on HUD’s Notice of Funding Opportunity (NOFO) for the Continuum of Care (informational), and a discussion of Alameda Health System (AHS) governance options (informational). A brief recess was taken when quorum was lost, but the meeting reconvened. The committee approved the Measure A1 report and directed that the AHS governance legislation be sent to the Policy, Administration, and Legislation (PAL) committee for sponsorship consideration. Public Comments & Testimony - David (caller, representing SCAU 1021 members) spoke in support of the AHS governance discussion, stating that it would help address ongoing labor and personnel concerns and thanked the committee for taking up the item. Discussion Items - Measure A1 Fourth Annual Report – The report covered the period July 2020 through June 2022, catching up on annual reporting. Highlights include: 73% voter approval for Measure A1; 54 rental projects (15 pre-development, 14 under construction, 25 completed) totaling over 3,900 affordable rental units; leverage of $6 from other sources for every $1 of Measure A1; 173 homeowners assisted through two homeownership programs with over 800 workshop attendees; acquisition of two hotels using state Homekey funds and the county’s acquisition fund. The report noted delays due to COVID-19 (over 50% staff vacancy rate) and quorum issues for the oversight committee. Proposed bylaw changes would allow informational meetings even without a quorum. The report also highlighted that the borough’s locally funded housing portal (Doorway) had been transitioned to a regional Bay Area system. Supervisor Miley noted that local hire goals (30%) were exceeded (42%) and that 105 Alameda County businesses received $180 million in construction contracts, while 73 small local businesses received nearly $79 million. Supervisor Tam inquired about coordination of funding streams for Homekey projects and the potential for reauthorization of a new bond measure. Staff reported that Measure A1 funds are fully committed except for program income, and that discussions with the city of Oakland regarding hotel operations are ongoing. The committee adopted the report as an action item. - Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Notice of Funding Opportunity (NOFO) for Continuum of Care – Jeanette Rodriguez (Deputy Director for Housing, Housing and Homelessness Services) presented an update on the FY25 NOFO, released November 13, 2025, with a short turnaround (due January 14, 2026). Key changes: only 30% of funding (tier 1) can be protected, down from historical 90%; the share for permanent housing is capped at 30% (previously 86% locally). This puts up to $42 million of the county’s $60 million in HUD funding at risk, with $33 million in permanent housing needing reallocation or loss. The new NOFO shifts away from Housing First principles and includes requirements aligning with recent executive orders on DEI, gender identity, and harm reduction. Local actions include forming a NOFO response team, assessing local backfill funding (e.g., Measure W), and coordinating with grantees. The committee noted that HUD withdrew the NOFO during the meeting for revisions, which may further delay funding. Supervisor Miley stressed the need to be proactive, prepare bridge funding, and potentially adjust Measure W allocations to prevent service gaps. The item was informational. - Alameda Health System (AHS) Governance Options – Scott (County Counsel) and Amy (County Administrator’s Office) presented two governance options developed by a prior subcommittee: Option A gives the Board of Supervisors the authority to become the governing board of AHS with a subsidiary board of trustees for day-to-day operations; Option B retains the current board of trustees but gives the Board of Supervisors appointment authority. The presentation summarized key legislative decisions made in 2024, including flexibility for the board to choose its governance model, explicit conflict-of-interest waivers, delegation language, and representation for the City of Alameda Healthcare District. The legislation (amending Health and Safety Code Section 101850) needs to be introduced by February 20, 2026, with a request to legislative counsel due by January 23, 2026. Supervisor Miley provided historical context and expressed support for moving forward, noting labor’s eagerness. Supervisor Tam agreed to send the item to the PAL committee for sponsorship consideration. The committee directed staff to prepare a request for the January 13, 2026 PAL meeting. Key Outcomes - Measure A1 Annual Report – Approved unanimously (Supervisors Tam and Miley voted yes). The report will be forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors for adoption. - HUD NOFO Update – No formal action taken (informational item). The committee emphasized the need for continued monitoring, backfill planning, and coordination with the board on Measure W adjustments. - AHS Governance – The committee directed that the item be placed on the January 13, 2026 PAL committee agenda to seek a legislative sponsor for the proposed bill. Supervisors Tam and Miley will jointly submit the request.

The committee met on Monday, December 8, 2025, via Microsoft Teams, with Chair Tam presiding and Supervisors Fortunato and Town present. The meeting focused on federal and state legislative updates, including the Affordable Care Act, appropriations, a new California portal to report federal misconduct, and the impact of stock-based compensation on state revenues. No formal votes were taken, and no public comments were offered on agenda items. Federal Legislation Update - CJ Lake representatives Emily DeSola and John provided an update. They reported that Congress has two weeks left before adjournment on December 19, 2025, and that an appropriations package ("minibus") is unlikely before the end of the year, meaning a continuing resolution (CR) expiring January 30 may need to be extended. The focus is now on healthcare and defense. - On the Affordable Care Act subsidies, DeSola noted the Senate is expected to vote on a Democratic proposal for a three-year extension of enhanced premium tax credits on December 11; Republicans have not agreed on an alternative. John added that Republican leadership sees little incentive to act, and a one-year extension with additional policy riders (e.g., income cap, Hyde amendment language) would face strong Democratic opposition, making passage unlikely before year-end. - The National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) deal was reached over the weekend; House vote expected December 11, Senate the following week. - Supervisor Fortunato expressed frustration over Democrats losing leverage during the government shutdown and asked about a county comment letter on the public charge rule. Hanna Hamilton (Social Services Agency) confirmed a joint comment letter is in progress and will be brought to the full board on December 16. - Supervisor Town reported attending a press event with Senator Adam Schiff on the Building Occupancy Opportunities for Millions Act (housing BOOM), and asked how the county is engaging. Housing Director Michelle Spirit said staff are reviewing the bill and could bring a PAL letter. Supervisor Town also noted Congresswoman Simon is introducing a House companion bill and suggested lobbyists coordinate with both representatives. - Lobbyists confirmed they would reach out to both Schiff and Simon. State Legislation Update - Amy Costa of Full Moon Strategies reported that California launched a new online portal for the public to report potential misconduct by federal agents, jointly announced by the Governor and Attorney General. The state has at least 48 lawsuits against the Trump administration. - The Attorney General filed an amicus brief opposing the Trump administration's emergency appeal to deploy National Guard troops in Washington, D.C., and seven other states without consent. Bonta argues the deployment is unlawful and harms communities; 22 states joined the brief. - The Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) released data showing that stock-based compensation (especially restricted stock units, RSUs) from major tech companies (Apple, Google, NVIDIA, Broadcom, Meta) drives over 25% of withholding growth in early FY 2025-26. RSU withholdings now account for roughly 10% of all state income tax withholdings (≈$10 billion annually), increasing revenue volatility. - Supervisor Town noted upcoming legislative deadlines (January 31 for two-year bills to pass house of origin) and asked about potential new bills. Costa confirmed awareness of discussions about a new county-sponsored bill and said there is time to develop it. Key Outcomes - No formal votes were taken. - The committee directed lobbyists to engage with Senator Schiff and Congresswoman Simon on the housing BOOM bill. - The Social Services Agency and Health Department will bring a joint comment letter on the public charge rule to the full board on December 16. - The committee acknowledged the ongoing state and federal legal challenges and will monitor developments. - The meeting adjourned after a roll call of participants, including representatives from various county departments and the Alameda County Community Food Bank.

This meeting of the Alameda County Act for All (Together for All) Ad Hoc Committee was held on December 4, 2025, from 2:00 PM (UTC). The committee focused on two safety net issues: proposed changes to the public charge rule and food security amidst federal cuts. Supervisors Fortunato Bass and Marquez led the meeting, which included presentations from federal lobbyists, legal aid, the Alameda County Community Food Bank, and Oakland Thrives, as well as public comment. Supervisor Opening Remarks - Supervisor Marquez reported likely ICE activity in Hayward that day, reminding the public of their rights (right to remain silent, legal representation, not opening the door without a judicial warrant) and providing the A-CLIP hotline (510-241-4011). She urged community members to pause and verify law enforcement identity instead of assuming ICE. - Supervisor Fortunato Bass noted confirmed ICE enforcement in Oakland and Fremont since the last meeting. Discussion: Public Charge Rule Changes - Lynn Jacques (CJ Lake, federal lobbyist) described a State Department circular greatly expanding consular discretion to deny visas based on speculative health or financial burden, with no appeal process. She also detailed the Department of Homeland Security’s November 17 Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) that would rescind long-standing definitions of public charge, removing protections for means-tested benefit use and potentially allowing consideration of family members’ benefit receipt. Comment period closes December 19, 2025. - Lisa Newstrom (Bay Area Legal Aid) presented a PowerPoint explaining current public charge rules (ABCs: who is subject, which benefits count, other factors). The proposed rule eliminates all prior regulatory guidance except for public charge bonds. It rejects the definitions of “primary dependency” and “means-tested,” allowing speculative health costs and incidental use to be considered. She noted that statutory exemptions for humanitarian immigrants remain. - Supervisor Marquez confirmed that a Board comment letter on the NPRM had been drafted and requested copies for all supervisors. Lynn Jacques suggested scheduling an OIRA meeting to present county economic impact data. - Supervisor Fortunato Bass asked about the timeline for final rule; Lynn Jacques explained there is no strict deadline, but the more comments, the longer the review. - Lisa Newstrom reported that community advocacy on public charge is currently less active than in 2018-2019, but other issues (data sharing, eligibility changes) are adding to immigrant fear. Discussion: Food Security - Reggie Young (Alameda County Community Food Bank) described the impact of the federal government shutdown (SNAP freeze) on November 1, 2025. Pantry visits surged 30-100% above pandemic peaks. A survey found 50% of respondents were food insufficient (vs. 33% a year earlier) and 21% had never used a food distribution before. He warned that impending HR1 cuts will permanently remove tens of thousands from SNAP and reduce benefits for most recipients. The county’s $16.5M Measure W allocation plus $2M from other sources helped provide 1 million additional pounds of food in November. - Melanie Moore (Oakland Thrives) reported on the Rapid Response Fund, which raised $1.1 million in 30 days (including $500K from Alameda County/ACOE/Supervisor Fortunato Bass, $500K from philanthropies, and later $100K from Haas Senior Fund). 74 grants ($5,000-$25,000 each) were distributed to 81 applicants (87% approval rate), prioritizing small grassroots organizations. 44% went to Oakland, 11% to Hayward, 8% to Fremont, 8% unincorporated, 6% Berkeley, 6% San Leandro. The fund closed November 26 but demand continues due to HR1. - Alisa Cosmi (Supervisor Fortunato Bass’s office) described the food system roundtable convening over 60 partner organizations to coordinate food procurement, recovery, and distribution, with a focus on geographic equity and long-term sustainability. - Supervisor Marquez raised capacity building for small organizations (e.g., refrigeration, technology) and the potential to include street vendors and restaurants in food distribution. Reggie Young confirmed that $8.3 million in remaining Measure W funds can be used for capacity building, with community-led allocation through Oakland Thrives. - Supervisor Fortunato Bass emphasized that food is a human right and that the county’s farmland and urban agriculture should be leveraged. She stated that the remaining $182 million in Measure W should focus on safety net services. No formal vote was taken, but the committee expressed consensus on prioritizing safety net investments. Public Comments & Testimony - Mariselo Quinonez (Alameda County Office of Education) reported distribution of 5,500 grocery gift cards to support foster and homeless youth through 18 school districts, and upcoming communication on the Safe Pathways project to ensure student safety. - Tony Panetta (Alameda Health Consortium) stated that safety net clinics are already seeing a suppression effect from current policies. He cited Kaiser Family Foundation research showing 40% of immigrant adults nationally (77% of undocumented) reporting negative health effects from immigration-related fears since January 2025. He urged the county to submit comments on the public charge rule and to pursue flexible enrollment (e.g., digital signatures). Key Outcomes - The committee will continue monitoring public charge developments; a board comment letter on the NPRM is expected before the December 19 deadline. - The Rapid Response Fund for food security is closed, but ongoing demand is high; the committee will continue coordinating food system partners and exploring capacity building for grassroots organizations. - Supervisors expressed intent to focus Measure W resources on safety net programs during the upcoming budget process. - The next Ad Hoc Committee meeting is scheduled for January 15, 2026.

The Transportation Planning Committee met on December 1, 2025, at 9:15 AM, to discuss several items including the adoption of the 2025 California Building Standards Code, an update on mandatory solid waste and organics collection services to comply with SB 1383, a proposed amendment to allow event centers on Resource Management (RM) land, battery energy storage regulations, and a land mapping correction for the Valasetus (nuclear plant) site. Public comments were heard on each item. Discussion Items Item 1: Adoption of 2025 California Building Standards Code - Director of Public Works Daniel Wildesenbet presented the item as a routine administrative procedure. The state requires adoption by January 1, 2026. The new code includes the California Wildland Urban Interface Code (WUI) as a new component of Title 24. Alameda County will also retain its existing stricter requirement for automatic gas shutoff valves (anomatic shutoff valve) in new construction due to seismic risks. The rest of the code remains consistent with current state standards. Supervisor Miley clarified that the gas shutoff requirement is above state code. The committee voted unanimously to forward the item to the full Board of Supervisors for adoption at the December 9 meeting. - Motion: To adopt the building standards and forward to full board. Approved (Supervisor Miley moved, Supervisor Hauber seconded; unanimous). Item 2: Update on Mandatory Solid Waste Recycling and Organics Collection (SB 1383) - Waste Program Manager Andy Schneider presented an informational update. SB 1383 requires three-container collection services to reduce methane emissions. In County Collection Service Zone One (Livermore area), approximately 300 unincorporated accounts exist, with 50 remaining non-compliant. A self-haul certification program was developed for rural residents. In the new Zone Two (Pleasanton/Sunol/Castlewood area), a MOU with Pleasanton Garbage Service (PGS) will bring mandatory service to about 400-600 accounts, with a 10% rate increase (e.g., from $40 to $50/month for a 32-gallon cart). Enforcement penalties range from $100 (first citation) to $500 (third). Supervisor Miley expressed concern about fines being too low to ensure compliance. Supervisor Hauber requested a rural roads meeting in early 2026 to inform constituents. The item was informational; no vote taken. Item 3: Proposed Amendment to Allow Event Centers in Resource Management (RM) Land - Albert Lopez (Planning) presented. Allowing new event centers in RM via conditional use permit (CUP) would likely violate Measure D because visitor-serving commercial uses are explicitly permitted in Large Parcel Ag (LPA) but not in RM. Two existing event centers in RM (Sunol and Cole Canyon) were permitted before or in error. Public speakers included: Jerry Miller (support, 45-year resident, argued amendment helps farmers); Griffin Miller (support, family ag business); Kelly April (opposed, claimed the proposal undermines Measure D); William Urage (opposed, said it violates Measure D and should go to voters). Staff and county counsel noted that a ballot measure would be needed for substantive change. Supervisor Howard suggested holding work sessions to explore Measure D amendments. Supervisor Miley agreed, citing past surgical amendments (equestrian facilities). The committee took no formal action but agreed to schedule further discussion. Item 4: Battery Energy Storage Regulations - Albert Lopez continued. The county lacks a zoning path for battery storage projects. Some applicants are opting for state CEC approval, which can preempt local land use authority. Staff recommended a general plan amendment and zoning code update, with CEQA review, to create a permissive path. Supervisor Miley requested a time-bound project plan for developers to choose between local and state processes. The item was informational; no vote taken. Item 5: Valasetus Land Mapping (Nuclear Plant Site) - Albert Lopez presented. The site (owned by GE Vernova) has six parcels. The zoning is heavy industrial (M2) for the facility, but the general plan (ECAP) designates most as RM and LPA, with only a small industrial designation. This discrepancy appears to be a mapping error. Staff suggested a general plan amendment as a correction, which would go through the Planning Commission and public review. Supervisor Howard and Supervisor Miley supported moving forward with the correction. County counsel reserved opinion pending further review. No vote taken, but direction given to proceed. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 3: Jerry Miller expressed support; Griffin Miller expressed support; Kelly April opposed; William Urage opposed. - Item 4: Kelly April commented that battery storage is compatible with ECAP. - Item 5: Kelly April commented that the rumor about a nuclear plant on RM land is false and raised concerns about Hunters Point contamination. - Public Comment on Items Not on Agenda: Kelly April criticized the board and planning commission for a prior road giveaway to a developer, alleging a campaign contribution connection. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved unanimously (forward to full board on December 9). - Item 2: Informational; agreed to schedule a rural roads meeting in early 2026. - Item 3: No action; direction to hold work sessions on Measure D amendments. - Item 4: No action; staff to provide a time-bound project plan for creating a local approval path. - Item 5: Direction to initiate a general plan amendment to correct the Valasetus site mapping (zoning vs. general plan discrepancy).

The Personnel Administration and Legislation (PAL) Committee of the Alameda County Board of Supervisors met on Monday, December 1, 2025, at 1:30 PM. Chair Lena Tam presided, with Supervisors Fortunato and Tam present. The meeting included updates on federal and state legislation, public comment, and discussion of upcoming policy and funding issues. Public Comments & Testimony - Michelle (online speaker) asked about reports that Section 8 vouchers might be cut, specifically whether December vouchers would be unfunded. Federal legislative staff responded that they had not heard such reports, noting that both the House and Senate THUD bills fully fund current vouchers and that under a continuing resolution, the program is funded at FY24 levels. They agreed to investigate further. Federal Legislation Update - CJ Lake and Emily presented the update. Key points included: - FY 2026 Appropriations: Congress is back in session after Thanksgiving recess; House will be in session 13 days over the next three weeks, Senate 12 days. The Senate is debating a minibus package that could include defense, labor-HHS, transportation-HUD, CJS, interior, energy-water, and foreign ops. House leadership will wait for Senate action. Four objections remain on the Senate hotline. - Enhanced Premium Tax Credits (Affordable Care Act): Expire December 31. Senate may vote next week, but House leadership is not committed to a vote. The White House shelved a two-year extension plan after Hill pushback. A straight one-year extension is estimated to cost $280 billion nationally, but costs depend on income caps and duration. - LIHEAP Funding: HHS released $3.6 billion to states and tribes on November 29; California should have received its allocation. - National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA): Markup expected this week; the Senate authorized $925 billion, the House $883 billion (aligned with White House request). Final text will set defense appropriations levels. - Supervisor Fortunato asked about the number of Covered California enrollees affected by the tax credit expiration. Staff replied that about 1.9 million Californians are on the exchange, but the number receiving subsidies would need to be researched. She also asked for cost estimates of the tax credit extension, which staff agreed to provide. State Legislation Update - Amy (Full One Strategies) presented the update. Key points included: - Gubernatorial Race: Billionaire Steven Klubeck dropped out and endorsed Congressman Eric Swalwell, adding to a crowded Democratic field. Tom Steyer also announced. - Medi-Cal: A 29-member Future of Medical Commission will craft a 10-year plan to stabilize the program, which covers 15 million low-income Californians. Recommendations expected in early 2027. - Revenue Measures: SEIU-UHW is pushing a ballot measure to impose a one-time 5% tax on Californians with net worth over $1 billion, projected to raise $100 billion over five years (90% for healthcare, 10% for education). Another idea being discussed is a tax on large employers whose workers rely on public benefits. The SEIU measure was amended late last week; controversy exists over whether it circumvents Proposition 98 school funding. The California Teachers Association may not support it. - HUD Lawsuit: On November 25, California and a multi-state coalition sued HUD over a rule capping permanent housing funding at 30% for Continuum of Care programs. The change is projected to cost California $250–300 million annually for permanent supportive housing and rapid rehousing. The lawsuit argues the rule is illegal because it alters eligibility without congressional authorization. - SNAP/CalFresh Lawsuit: On the eve of Thanksgiving, Attorney General Bonta and 21 other states sued the USDA over guidance restricting SNAP eligibility for certain lawful permanent residents. This is California’s 48th lawsuit against the federal government this year. - Supervisor Fortunato requested a table of the various revenue measures being circulated, which staff agreed to provide. She also asked about opposition to the SEIU billionaire tax from Central Valley legislators and what CSAC could do; staff noted the Proposition 98 concern may affect support. Key Outcomes - No votes were taken. - The committee received and discussed the federal and state legislative updates. - Staff will follow up on: the impact of Section 8 voucher funding, the number of Covered California enrollees receiving subsidies, cost estimates for extending premium tax credits, and a table of state revenue measure proposals. - LIHEAP funding of $3.6 billion has been released to California. - Two lawsuits were noted: one challenging HUD’s permanent housing cap and one challenging USDA SNAP guidance for legal permanent residents.